Fixed this with the latest commit, but the fix will not affect the ongoing game. So here is the same save with the goal completed instead.
Bug Reports and Technical Issues
- Thread starter Leoreth
- Start date
Hickman888
Prince
Thank you! You're the man!
Genghis Khaiser
King
- Joined
- Aug 10, 2012
- Messages
- 701
Is Colombia's trade goal supposed to be 3000 gold on the lowest game speed? Because I'm playing that and it was.
Attaching a random save JIC.
Attaching a random save JIC.
Crimean Lord
Warlord
Serbia occupied by mighty Ethiopia!!!
Can you upload the last save before this happens?
Unfortunately it doesn't reproduce for me.
Checked if I made a mistake, but it's always been like that. Even on 1.16.0 the goal requires 3000 gold on normal speed.
Dracosolon
King
Attacked England during its rise of civ phase... Am I really supposed to get that many conquerors?
(Saves before and after in attachments.)
(Saves before and after in attachments.)
kontrakultur
Chieftain
- Joined
- Mar 25, 2019
- Messages
- 13
Playing as Rome I tried refusing the flip of Spain which first of all causes us both to get some pretty insane stacks of troops because of the new Rise of Spain as well as the Roman Expansion still kicking in (which may not be intentional). I got 18 units and Spain is sitting on a whopping 42.
More seriously though, while retreat chance only shows up as somewhere between 1-8% for every legion, they all invariably retreat. As this could be a statistical oddity I ran some other tests.
I also tried spawning in 6 Marines right next to the Moors capital through World Builder and attacking. They show no retreat chance in the tooltip, but 4 out of 6 retreated from combat.
On the Arab capital, 5/6 retreated. Viking capital, 6/6. Byzantine capital (which does not have the Rise of modifier) seems to work as normal.
Edit: I'm playing on the Git version updated Thursday 2021-12-30.
More seriously though, while retreat chance only shows up as somewhere between 1-8% for every legion, they all invariably retreat. As this could be a statistical oddity I ran some other tests.
I also tried spawning in 6 Marines right next to the Moors capital through World Builder and attacking. They show no retreat chance in the tooltip, but 4 out of 6 retreated from combat.
On the Arab capital, 5/6 retreated. Viking capital, 6/6. Byzantine capital (which does not have the Rise of modifier) seems to work as normal.
Edit: I'm playing on the Git version updated Thursday 2021-12-30.
Yeah, I did not really consider the interaction between two civs that either both benefit from birth protection or where one benefits from birth protection and the other from expansion bonuses.
I think the retreat behaviour stems from a) birth protected units that defend being able to retreat if their health is reduced below 50% (as long as it started above 50%) and b) expansion units having +50% retreat chance on attack. That means that if an expansion benefited unit attacks and wins, it ends in a retreat on the defender's part, and if it loses, there is a high chance that it will retreat itself.
Especially, if you only attack undamaged birth protected units, you will virtually 100% see a retreat, that is intentional.
Likewise, I think there is a feedback loop between the free units that are possible to receive in these situations, leading to way more free units than intended. I need to look into that, and probably intend to make expansion bonus effects depend on the target not being birth protected.
I think the retreat behaviour stems from a) birth protected units that defend being able to retreat if their health is reduced below 50% (as long as it started above 50%) and b) expansion units having +50% retreat chance on attack. That means that if an expansion benefited unit attacks and wins, it ends in a retreat on the defender's part, and if it loses, there is a high chance that it will retreat itself.
Especially, if you only attack undamaged birth protected units, you will virtually 100% see a retreat, that is intentional.
Likewise, I think there is a feedback loop between the free units that are possible to receive in these situations, leading to way more free units than intended. I need to look into that, and probably intend to make expansion bonus effects depend on the target not being birth protected.
ariel552
Chieftain
ariel552
Chieftain
savegame here
ariel552
Chieftain
just passing turn
freethink
Prince
In mother Russia, the polar bears invites the pirates for dinner.
Zaddy
Prince
- Joined
- Jan 14, 2018
- Messages
- 341
Hi,
I don't know if this is a bug or not, but I'll post here to see if it is or not.
So, England is fighting a war with Russia, Germany and Thailand. Independently of that war, I launch my own war as Iran to conquer British India. I begin making progress, claiming cities, when suddenly I am put into a forced peace with England as a congress begins, triggered by the conclusion of the other English war. Not only am I forced into a peace and congress negotiations, during the triggered congress England gets to reclaim one of the cities I conquered.
To say the least, this didn't leave a great taste in my mouth. I don't see why I wouldn't be given an option to not end my war. Turn before the congress attached.
Also, another thing I've noticed: Is it intended that you can now build farms on riverside desert tiles, and can now build cottages on tiles that provide no food (plains hills, desert, etc)? It used to be that you couldn't.
I don't know if this is a bug or not, but I'll post here to see if it is or not.
So, England is fighting a war with Russia, Germany and Thailand. Independently of that war, I launch my own war as Iran to conquer British India. I begin making progress, claiming cities, when suddenly I am put into a forced peace with England as a congress begins, triggered by the conclusion of the other English war. Not only am I forced into a peace and congress negotiations, during the triggered congress England gets to reclaim one of the cities I conquered.
To say the least, this didn't leave a great taste in my mouth. I don't see why I wouldn't be given an option to not end my war. Turn before the congress attached.
Also, another thing I've noticed: Is it intended that you can now build farms on riverside desert tiles, and can now build cottages on tiles that provide no food (plains hills, desert, etc)? It used to be that you couldn't.
Similar threads
