Smartfish (林聰明沙鍋魚頭)
aka
Lin Congming's Stewed Fish Head in Clay Pot
This eatery is featured in Episode 5 of Netflix's
Street Food: Asia, which highlights the street food scene in Chiayi. This is not a city I'd ever heard of before watching the documentary, only a couple weeks before my flight to Taiwan. I would have expected Taipei to be covered on the show instead of Chiayi, which made me look up this city and why it might have been selected instead. Turns out Chiayi has a unique culinary history and unique regional dishes on offer. It also turns out that one of the people Netflix hired to do the show was based in Chiayi at the time, and he was the person who recommended they film the episode here as opposed to Taipei. Alexander Synaptic also told me I made the right decision in deciding to stop in Chiayi, calling it a bit of a hidden gem.
The story of the poor family who started a fish head stew food stall in 1953 in an attempt to reverse their family fortunes really spoke to me. At the time fish heads were practically given away for free, which is why they embraced this particular ingredient. The fish head stew recipe had been in their family for a while; the hope was that this business would make them some money and help them out a bit, but also that the dish would be embraced by others. At first they did not see much success and were laughed at and called "fish heads", but the family kept at it and slowly over time their dish became popular. The Netflix show episode boosted their popularity, but by the time it aired Smartfish was already popular to some degree.
The episode focuses on and interviews the daughter of the couple who founded that food stall back in 1953. Her story really touched me. She made it her mission to help her parents with the food stall, and worked hard for years, until finally the food stall gained some traction and became somewhat popular. She helped modernize and run the eatery, overseeing the move to the new location. Such dedication in the face of ridicule by someone who came from such humble beginnings, leading to such a success story, it really left a mark on me. Smartfish is now known as THE Chiayi fish stew. During busy parts of the day it's not uncommon to see a couple hundred people waiting in line for their fish head stew.
I had to come here.
I have to admit it felt a bit surreal standing in line, waiting for my number to be called. I've visited many places in the past that I had previously seen in a documentary, but this felt different. Maybe it was my emotional reaction to the story?
After a 20 minute wait my food was ready and I was shown to a table. Wow.. This was a
large bowl packed with all sorts of stuff! Alexander Synaptic told me that the stew is full of basically a lot of the things Taiwanese people like to eat, plus a fish head.
The rich with flavour broth caught my attention right away; it was a pleasure to sip. Pork bones and pork belly are used to make it, although I couldn't really tell if there were any pieces of pork belly in the mix. There was just so much going on - this must have been the most elaborate dish I'd eaten in Taiwan up until that point. I really liked the various kinds of tofu I found in the stew, it went very well with the broth. It also contained several kinds of mushroom, green onion, cabbage, and a variety of sauces and spices. What else am I forgetting.. Rice wine, soy sauce, chili oil, coriander.. I'm told that Sha Zha sauce is a key part of this dish as well. This is a sauce that's sometimes called "Chinese BBQ sauce", although that's not really a great way to describe it either. I'm probably forgetting some ingredients as well.
You are no doubt wondering about the fish head. I tried to eat it, but I wasn't really sure how to attack it. I tried to put parts in my mouth, but I had trouble grabbing hold of any meat. I managed to scrape off a bit here and there, but eventually went back to enjoying the broth, tofu, mushrooms, cabbage, and everything else. Later research told me that I should have been trying to eat the fish head cheeks.
Did my experience do my expectations justice? Basically. Before my arrival here I expected the fish head to be doing most of the talking. Turns out the broth, the tofu, the cabbage, the mushrooms, and the other ingredients were sort of the stars of the show, as far as I was concerned anyway. I wish I had taken more time to study the fish head and how to eat it properly, but after my meal I was satisfied that I came here and got to experience all the love that this family had put into this restaurant and this dish over the decades. Against all odds they became successful and I felt privileged I got to experience their creation.
Every once in a while I'd look around hoping to catch a glipse of the person who was the focus on the show, the daughter who made it her life's work to make this place successful. I doubted I'd actually run into her there, she must be an even busier person now that the Netflix show made their restaurant even more popular. I wanted to meet her and say how great it is that their fish head stew restaurant is now popular, but did not get the chance to. That's alright though! It was a long shot, and I felt great paying for my meal and contributing to their success. It also felt great just sitting there, looking around, just being there. The meal itself was also of course memorable, but there was more to the experience than just that.
A memorable visit to a restaurant I'd never have guessed I'd want to go out of my way to visit. Sometimes an unexpected emotional connection can make a big difference in how you enjoy something.