Greek Overhaul?

What do you think their traits should be?

  • Seafaring/Religious

    Votes: 2 3.7%
  • Seafaring/Scientific

    Votes: 14 25.9%
  • Seafaring/Commerical

    Votes: 4 7.4%
  • Scientific/Religious

    Votes: 7 13.0%
  • Commercial/Religious

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Scientific/Commercial (Current)

    Votes: 22 40.7%
  • None of the above

    Votes: 5 9.3%

  • Total voters
    54
Originally posted by CivCube
I really don't care. You're playing the traits, not truly as the civs.

exactly, which is why i have a problem w/ france/carthage having the same traits, i think there's a few other civs who share traits, i mean, yes your supposed to be historicly arcurate, but not at the expense of gameplay, maybe the greeks could have different traits, but then people would still complain, no game is 100% historically acurate, and nne tries to be. if it's that big a deal, mod it
 
i voted scientific seafaring as well, natural evaluation. But Scientific Commercial ain't a bad second. Hoplite remains one of the best Unique Units graphically tho.
 
Sci/commercial or scientific/seafaring. Change Byzantines to Scientific/Commercial if Greece gets Scientific/Seafaring.
 
IMO, it would be better if every civ has three traits.So there would be no civs with completly equal traits.
 
Switching with Byzantines makes perfect sense. I mean, Byzantium was big and powerful because of trade -ie Commercial-
the thing is Athens was a sea power that used the sea for ...trade....so a close call on both of these. And too byzantine UU is a sea UU so a seafaring trait kinda goes with it. Like the beserk (amphib assault which at least ties to boat) goes with the Scandanavians-Man O War England , Portugal boat . Carthage and Spain got jipped out of that connection but both have nice uu's and good traits. They should , for continuity sake, tie in each trait to each civs uu as that would make sense as to their coming into being...So maybe Conquistidors could have some kind of blitz/movement out of boat thing and Carthage is allowed 1 xtra transport for UU -Mercenary.
Of course would that mean to say that all Agricultural Civ UU's should be congruent as well? Might get complicated.
 
Originally posted by ybbor


exactly, which is why i have a problem w/ france/carthage having the same traits, i think there's a few other civs who share traits, i mean, yes your supposed to be historicly arcurate, but not at the expense of gameplay, maybe the greeks could have different traits, but then people would still complain, no game is 100% historically acurate, and nne tries to be. if it's that big a deal, mod it

actually they changed Carthage traits to Ind/Sea in C3C so they are no longer share the same triats
 
Okay, I'll be the one to ask. "Why fix a civ that ain't broke?"
Greece has two very strong traits that are as appropriate as any of the others suggested and a UU that's extremely strong early and is useable well into the medierval era. Any time the RNG starts me as Greece, I figure I'm in pretty good shape.
I don't see any real improvement coming from changing the traits.
 
Well, they seem fine now, but I think for the sake of realism, they are definately seafaring. I wonder how many people voted for sci/com, just because that's what it is now...
 
I agree that Scientific is the right trait,for the second one they could be Seafaring,because from the beging the greeks were a people of the sea,not only because Athens and Corinth had a great navy power but because the Greeks were traveling by sea in every known or unknown place were they founded new cities and spread their culture.The Comercial trait is based on that,on their continues journeys round the world so even this trait (Comercial) is fine.Militaristic could also be a right trait because as said Sparta and Macedonia were mostly military forces,and not only them.However i vote Scientific-Seafaring.
 
Originally posted by Revolutionary


actually they changed Carthage traits to Ind/Sea in C3C so they are no longer share the same triats
good, but now do any civs share traits? like greece & korea?
 
alright, I haven tread through the thread, but here my thoughts-

A)the traits of Scientific, and seafaing accuratley describe the Greeks all through there history- from pre classical times, of the great Minoan mareitime empire based on Crete to the thousand "black ship" (so named for the use of tar and pitch on the bottom to make them wter tight) that set sale from the Mycenaean lands to seige Troy, to the great AThenian navies- even after the great conquests of Alexandetr, the Greeks stayed a greaty sea power, domitinating all sea trade east of Carthage, and even Alexander the great was responsible for, amoung his other great seige weapons, a mighty seige ships- and indeed, it was his navy that had a direct impact of the seige, and conquest of the "unconqourable" island city of Tyre on the levantine coast.

after Alxanders death, and the era of hellinzation of the east was usherd in, the Greek successor kingdoms oftgen engaged in a cold war like build up of hevey ships, of which the Ptolomies were most successful, even at one time building a ship so lage, that it recieved the name "40" as its ship class- this said, a "Trireme" meant "3" and was a refernce to either hom many ore levals were on ench side, or, referred to a slightlly differnt ship, with one leval of ores, that were so large it needed three to work it- the 40 was likelly a meeting of the two concepts...

I also really dont think why I would have to explain the scientific merits of the Greeks...
--------------------------------------------------------------
now, as soem of you may notice, the traits of scientific and seafaring overlap that of the Byzantines- my suggestion is to make the Byzantines either Sci-Commercial, which is a very accurate portray of the Byzantine empire, Relgios, or even better, Sci- Relgious, as such wonders as the hagia Sophia, and the huge amount of of monistaires in the Byzantine empire certainlyl give a physical reason, not to many the many court intrigues based on religion, and the many Imperial edicts regarding the subject
 
Yes. Make the Byzantines Sci/Com, and the Greeks Sci/Sea. Of course, the Byzantine's UU is a boat. I still think the Greeks should be religious, but that does not seem to be common sentiment.
 
my own trait suggestion is instead of a stat bonus, give the Cataphract an HP bonus of one
 
Top Bottom