Puppeteer
Emperor
I'm starting to suspect that I went for a bad deal, as I am now waiting for mine to arrive in the mail from EA- they already have my money, so they have no incentive to ship it fast.
It's a tough call. Some product launches don't have enough product available for the demand on day 1, and sometimes shippers strive to deliver product preorders on the day of release (Amazon.com and Harry Potter books jump to mind here). Other times I think preorders are just a gimmick to grab cash early and lock in the business. Unfortunately you can't tell until after launch. In this case it looks like there's plenty of product for retail demand, and the preorders don't seem to be trying hard to deliver as soon as an eager buyer wants.
On the other hand, from my point of view distributors are getting pretty good at judging demand and getting enough product out there for release day. Even the Harry Potter books I mentioned, the preording was nice, but it's not like there was a shortage of books at the brick-and-mortar stores, either. The Wii console is the only recent product I can think of that it probably would have been better to preorder.
But I wouldn't go so far as to call it a bad deal as long as you get it a couple of days after release. If they drag their butts more than that I'd start griping.