Panda
Metal head
B5 of course, unless the cylons from BSG get there first. 
Intergalactic War
- Thread starter nc-1701
- Start date
Evil Tyrant
Eccentric Dictator
Nah, I'll just throw the user against a wall with my hand device before he even gets close enough to even use it. In fact, I might keep the whip as a souvenir of fools who dared to defy a god.
Masquerouge
Deity
With your "hand device". Sounds more kinky than scary.
I guess it depends on when exactly we're taking the snapshot of the Universes, something the OP didn't address.
Why do you assume we should use the Star Wars Universe at the time of the motion pictures?
If we do that, then in all fairness you have to use the StarGate universe at the time of the motion picture... and in the motion picture there is only one goau'ld left in the Universe, who gets killed, and no mention of the Ori
Yes I id state that in the OP
Star Wars -Beggining of ROTJ aka Episode VI
Stargate -2006 aka Season 10
Star Trek -~2370 aka DS9/Voyager era
Evil Tyrant
Eccentric Dictator
Well, it is also used for torture, so if you are intersted in that sort of thing, yeah it is kind of kinky.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hand_device
Masquerouge
Deity
Ah
I apologize...Then yeah, the Star Wars universe is not in good shape at the end of Episode VI, since it's just emerging from a major galactic war.
'Tis unfair!
vikingruler
King
Star Gate would kick the asses of the other universes. the Asgard and Ori are so much more powerful technologically then anything that Star Wars and Star Trek can throw out them. The Jedi and Sith would be negated by the Nox, the Replicators would eat and take over any ship or vehicle they came in contact with, and Earth has a pretty powerful fleet on their hands as well. Also, you are probably forgetting the massive amount of Jaffa left in the galaxy, they could easily match the strength of the empire.
Yuri2356
Test Screening
He said begining of 6, meaning the DS2 is still waiting to be finished, Vader and the Emperor both Live, and Empire is very much intact.Ah
Then yeah, the Star Wars universe is not in good shape at the end of Episode VI, since it's just emerging from a major galactic war.
'Tis unfair!
Cheezy the Wiz
Socialist In A Hurry
When has the force ever had a major effect? I can't even think of a single time Jedi/Sith have turned the tide in a major battle. Not to mention that in Atack of The Clones Jedi were dropping like flies...
@El_Machinae Excellent point 8472 pwns all
Ever played Knights of the Old Republic? Bastila's Battle Meditation gave her control over half the Sith fleet! I'd call that powerful. Or how about how Jedi/Sith can see the future? I'd say The Force gives Star Wars folks a great advantage over the other two.
Well that's a game so it's not canon
As we see in Episode IV the future cannot be seen with great accuracy. Luke sees the future, but we never experiance the future that he sees.Also how do you plan on stopping the Borg a Cube is 3km to a side an ISD is 1.5km long
A cube has high capacity shields, transwarp, A variety of high-yield diruptors, and torpedos, and they can beam through shields to assimilate the crew/knowledge of other species after which they adapt to every weapon they have. Oh, did I mention their are 30,000 thousend Borg ships?
Murky
Deity
Death Star pwns all.
It take forever to shoot. The Borg will simply beam over en masse and start assimilating (See the movie First Contact), or Species 8472 will use a planet destroyer to obliterate it.
The Death Star was blown up by one freaking single seat (plus droid) fighter firing one shot.
Self-propelled city capable of intergalactic travel (Atlantis) FTW!
crabapple
I am watching
Warning Stargate Atlantis Season 3 finale, First Strike
So Stargate wins hands down
Spoiler :
So Stargate wins hands down
I need a frame of reference:
Drones can take apart a Goauld battlecruiser, sure, but I have no idea how much a battlecruiser can normally take. IIRC, a few have been blown up by nukes, no? Has one ever been taken down via ship-to-ship battle, and what did the opponents use to take one down?
What has taken down a drone?
It should be known that StarWar's weapons show to be many orders of magnitude more powerful that StarTrek's (save the 8472 planet busting)
Warning Stargate Atlantis Season 3 finale, First Strike
Spoiler :
So Stargate wins hands down
Well, ST & SW don't have gates so... it wouldn't do a whole lot.
crabapple
I am watching
eh the Ancient created the gates and I see no reason why they cant create them in the whatever universe they are sent to do battle, and then the replicators can create the weapon
Yeeek
Seizing The Day
Is there a single thing as cool as a lightsaber in either Startrek or Stargate? No, thanks you very much!
crabapple
I am watching
Yuri2356
Test Screening
Wrong.Well that's a game so it's not canon
The plot lines of SW games are cannon, unless explicitly stated otherwise, or when in direct contradiction to the Movies. As are the EU novels, Comics, and other materials. Such is the policy in place.
When has a Borg Cube demonstrated firepower comparable to an ISD? (As per Base-Delta-Zero) And in terms of material stength, have the Borg ever managed to build a ship the size of a small moon, capable of surviving over 1000gs of acceleration? The Empire most certainly did.Also how do you plan on stopping the Borg a Cube is 3km to a side an ISD is 1.5km long
Here we see numerous examples of things that interfere with the operation of Transporters, including high-power energy fields (Like... oh... I don't know... The shields of a warship.) They also have trouble beaming through large volumes of dense material, which Wars ships have in ample supply in the form of armour.
Also note how the DS2 was ablt to fire repeatedly during the battle, destroying numerous rebel capital ships, and the surface of either Death Star was covered in thousands of Gun batteries. (DS2's weren't working yet, but the first station showed us these surface guns in battle)
As for 8472, their Planet-Killing weapon relies on inducing some manner of chain reaction in the target material (Evidenced by the fact that the planet they fired it on didn't explode until seconds after the beam had ceased) There's no way of knowing the amount of direct energy input, which would be all they'd have to work with to break down a Wars ship's shields. Meanwhile, they'd be getting quite thorougly exploded by high volumes of tubolaser fire.
...entirely due to the influence of the Force. If anyone other than Luke had taken that shot, or if luke had relied on his computer, he'd have died in that trench and the Rebellion would have ended that day. (Proof - The other X-Wing pilot who used his computer to make the shot. He failed.)
It's not like a Stargate will just pop into existance out of nothing. They'd have to deliver it, just like any other weapon, and thus be faced with the Imperial fleet. The weapon does not become viable unless the navy is already defeated, at which time the weapon's existance is moot.