NOTW XL: Return of the Baron (Game Thread)

[The Bake]

Skooma Addict and Choxorn are obviously scummy in my eyes.

Wierd reason to vote for someone Skooma and Choxorn, after Kennigit just gave good eviedence for that both me and Takisis may be scummy. Im not implying that I'm scummy, but I see the error of my voting, I do.

 

[choxorn]

So wait, we're scummy, because we voted for someone Kennigit said was really scummy when he also said two other people were less scummy, you being one of them?

Flawless logic, there.

 

[Winston Hughes]

Why is the fact that Kennigit scanned me as wishing to harm those who oppose the innocents being ignored here? Can anyone explain how that could possibly be the PG of an anti-town role?

I mean, seriously, have a go at working that out, re-read my roleclaim, and you'll see just how poorly conceived this present bandwagon is.

With reference to verifiable facts (TFA's report of being attacked with fire on the first night, Nictel and BananaLee's subsequent experience of the same, and Renata's inquiries on my behalf), I've explained exactly what I am, and what I've been up to. That's a damn sight more than anybody else has put up. I've got nothing to hide, and I'll answer any question posed to me with total honesty. Go ahead and try me.

 

[Kennigit]

I'd really like to wait until robbiecon shows up and explains what he can do, either to me in private or in the thread. Now would be a really good time for a jailer roleblock.

I'm just going to assume there a 4 wolves (well, 3 wolves and 1 cat) and 4 cultists for a game of 30 (8 scum). Perhaps there is only 7 scum. But we know there is 1 more wolf and a cultist since 2kills happened last night.

People need to distinguish between "Kennigit says this" and "the factually, undistupitable vote tallies from the past." It's not a matter of me saying "choxorn is innocent", its a matter of him lynching both cultists AND wolves, as well as voting for rhawn mutliple times (making it very unliekly he was rahwns wolfmate). Same goes for bananalee, nictel, etc.

I really wish I sent in my order for a scan yesterday. Really irks me off that I could have info.

To clarify, my scan is getting people drunk at my inn and they blabber away. It's drunk talk, and the Gm has been somewhat funny about it. So winston, you really are seeming very scummy to me still trying to play it off so assertively that my scan strongly indicates you're pro innocent--you drunkenly described some "spells for the department of defense" and are after what you drunkenly consider to be "menaces to scoiety". You're using the same knee-jerk tone you used when I said romanichine was a scummy voter and romanichine's tone hiding behind you (that I called "weasily").

But since you seem to be accounted for in night actions and you didn't know the nature of my scan, so I'll have to lay off the pressure even if I don't like what you're doing. I will unvote and change my vote to takhisis for the time being then.

Southern king is probably scum since he hasn't been wogged. His last post in the thread voted for BSmith, so he isn't cult at least. Could be a wolf.

So of those who haven't voted against the cult, we have winston, takhisis, and the bake. Takhisis's scan (essentially kill the circus) was quite different from romanichine's scan (wants to be left alone) so I dunno, he doesn't quite seem cultish. Nothing seems to be magically hinted about him.

will post a scummary on takhisis later (I'm coining the term scummary btw).

 

[Kennigit]

Um, I know I'm pulling a walltexter in this day but w/e. Need to highlight this info since southern king was missed in the BSmith tally.

Southern King actually voted for BSmith when BSmith was lynched (post 428), so he is unlikely cult.

This repeats info in previous post but since that's a walltexter, need to highlight this new developement.

 

[Winston Hughes]

Something to bear in mind:

On at least one of the lynches (that of rhawn) there's a strong chance that scummers bussed their team mate. I recall it seeming clear from fairly early in the day that he was a villain, and that someone had scanned him as such.

 

[Nictel]

Unless the fireball thrower somehow perished.. Doesn't Winston have a good alibi? Also if he throws fireballs he can't be killing people..

Either The Bake or Takhisis are far better candidates in my opinion.

 

[Skooma Addict]

That's one of the worst reasons for a vote that I've ever seen.

Nah, I can think of one worse.

Skooma Addict and Choxorn are obviously scummy in my eyes.

Wierd reason to vote for someone Skooma and Choxorn, after Kennigit just gave good eviedence for that both me and Takisis may be scummy. Im not implying that I'm scummy, but I see the error of my voting, I do.

I missed the bit about testing for the department of defense. Winston

Lets go with Takhisis.

 

[Kennigit]

unvote; vote The Bake
damnit why doth the thread not like me. I'm bad at this. Takhisis probably isn't a werecat; he voted to lynch rhawn (post 464) He has consistently gone after nictel the thief and yet he was willing to change his vote for rhawn the wolf when nictel still could have been lynched.

His voting has not been anti-cult but he has gone against cdpwane here when there wasnt really any context that needed him to challenge a possible cult teammate. Other posts he feigns ignorance of the cult though and if you search him early on in the thread he really made no acknowledgement of the cult (despite OP saying there is a cult) and goes out of his way to talk about wolves (Suggesting this is wolf city, etc).

whatevs. I give up. The Bake has 7 posts in the thread, nothing special, etc. No anti-cult, no nothing. Except poor logic.

I'm gonna say southern king is last wolf and the bake is a cult.

Takhisis please show up. Elaborate why you want the circus dead.

 

[choxorn]

But there are two wolfs left- if Southern King is one, who is the other?

I'll unvote Winston Hughes and vote The Bake, then, and continue to shamelessly follow Kennigit.

 

[The Bake]

unvote; vote: The Bake

 

[Kennigit]

But there are two wolfs left- if Southern King is one, who is the other?

I'll unvote Winston Hughes and vote The Bake, then, and continue to shamelessly follow Kennigit.

I dunno. Other people should say what they know....

also what the bake?????

 

[Takhisis]

unvote; vote: The Bake

What the f-?

Nictel, Aiolos, a posthumously proven townie, has asked that you give me my effing trident back again. Instead of that, not only do I not have a trident, but also my ore has been stolen. Ore can be used to 'bribe' people into changing their votes, have you been doing this, Mr. Nictel? The Bake voting for himself could certainly be a case of this.

I will take that bloody knife if you will.

 

[choxorn]

I don't think that's why TheBake is voting for himself, I think it only shows up in the tally (which is why Roman was shown voting for himself when he wasn't yesterday)

 

[Kennigit]

Takhsisis, you shouldn't really get items if you want to kill the circus.

What have you been doing?

 

[Winston Hughes]

The Bake

If he's got nothing more to say, it's a fair bet that whatever else he could say wouldn't make him look any more innocent.

Edit: Kennigit gets the items.

 

[Nictel]

What the f-?

Nictel, Aiolos, a posthumously proven townie, has asked that you give me my effing trident back again. Instead of that, not only do I not have a trident, but also my ore has been stolen. Ore can be used to 'bribe' people into changing their votes, have you been doing this, Mr. Nictel? The Bake voting for himself could certainly be a case of this.

I will take that bloody knife if you will.

Maybe we should lynch Takhisis tomorrow, I mean this case isn't even logical anymore. What you think he got a PM saying "Yo, see this shiny ore? Now go make a post in which you vote for yourself!" Yeah that works!

Rather look at last days update. See how ROMANCHINE is in capitals next to his own name? Yeah. Bribing shows up big time.

 

[Autolycus]

Votes ended at 7 pm yesterday, so choxorn had the last legal vote. In a few hours, I'll post the write-up. Here's the vote tally so you can check any errors.

Accusations
The Bake: 2 Nictel, choxorn
Winston Hughes:1 Kennigit
Skooma:1 The Bake
Takhisis:1 Skooma

Knife
The Bake:1 The Bake
Nictel:1 Nictel
Kennigit:1 Kennigit

Ore(1)
Nictel:1 Nictel
Kennigit:1 Kennigit

 

[Kennigit]

right before choxorn I voted the bake as well.

 

[Autolycus]

End Day 9​

It had been a fractious day, with accusations tossed out against almost half the remaining people. The sun was just beginning to set when the trapeze artist hauled off and slugged the strong man. The Bake stumbled backwards and grabbed the knife from where it had lain most of the day. He grabbed it and brandished it menacingly at choxorn. The slave stepped up behind him and put him into a full nelson and then continued to crank the neck until the spine broke with an audible pop. The knife fell from The Bake's lifeless hands, and was left where it lay. Nictel stalked over and grabbed the piece of ore, daring anyone to challenge him. A search of The Bake's tent revealed that

Spoiler :

The Bake was merely a member of The Circus!!!

Circus 3/15
Animal Feeder Takhisis
Juggler BananaLee
Trapeze Artist choxorn


Town 6/15
Adept Winston Hughes
Innkeeper Kennigit
Jailer robbiecon
Shepherd Southern King
Slave Nictel
Wheat Farmer Skooma


Dead
Mayor Town
Irma/ Sonny Town
RingMaster Circus
Bearded Lady landlubber, murdered night 1 Werewolf
Acrobat classical_hero, lynched day 2 Circus
Urchin civplayah, murdered night 2 Angel of the Balance
Clown cpdwane, lynched day 3 Cultist of Aeron
Blacksmith atpg, murdered night 3 Town
Mermaid Earthling, lynched day 4 Circus!!
Lovely Assistant Zack, murdered night 4 Circus!!
Fortune Teller Seon, mauled night 4 Circus!!!
Tight-Rope Walker red_spy, lynched day 5 Circus!!
Merman Methos, murdered night 5 Circus!!!
School Teacher Bsmith, lynched day 6 Demon of Mammon!!!
Magician Renata, murdered night 6 Circus!!
Miner ThAmo, mauled night 6 Town!!!
Matchmaker rhawn lynched Day 7 Werewolf!!
Seamstress General Olaf mauled Night 7 Town!!
Orphan TFA murdered night 7 Town!!!
Acolyte Romanichine lynched Day 8 Cultist of Cernunnos and Agares!!
Banana Plantation Owner Aiolos , murdered Night 8 Town
Contortionist Camikaze, mauled night 8 Circus!!
Unicyclist mythmonster2, WOGged night 8 Circus!!!
Strong Man The Bake, lynched day 9 Circus!!

Begin Night 9
Night ends in 27.5 hours at 8 pm EDT 5/23/2011​

Accusations
The Bake: 2 Nictel, choxorn
Winston Hughes:1 Kennigit (Invalid format on shift to the Bake)
Skooma:1 The Bake
Takhisis:1 Skooma

Knife
The Bake:1 The Bake
Nictel:1 Nictel
Kennigit:1 Kennigit

Ore(1)
Nictel:1 Nictel
Kennigit:1 Kennigit