NOTW XXI: A Return to Foxford

I don't think we can trust it to be honest. We won't ever know if his ''cats'' are lying or telling the truth, making him useless as far as I see it. There's also the fact that he was so strongly motivated for killing Adrogans. All those rumours...
 
As far as I can see, D'art got an innocent killed. If he hadn't screwed up, we wouldn't have one less innocent. Thus, I vote for D'Artagnan59, especially since he may just be a false prophet misguiding us otherwise.
 
Hmph. They could still be useful.

Think of it in a different way as if they said someone was innocent.

*brings out cat*

Black-Cat-1.jpg


This is the cat I talked to that night. Kill me, and you'll see I'm innocent. Kill me, my cats will die.
 
Without my husband around anymore, I can take your cats in and make sure they are well fed. I can also turna deaf ear to whatever they have to say. They may have an agenda all their own.
 
Hey guys, sorry, I'll have to drop outta this. Can't get on as much as I'd like.
 
Hmmm. I might get a little lost But I'll join
 
Kill me. I'm a sick old lady that can barely walk. I only have my cats.

May I be reborn as one of the kittens in my bearing cat's litter.
 
I'm sorry D'Artagnan59 but we can't have an unpredictable "prophet".
 
I will not jump into another bandwagon. Mostly because i think D'Artagnan is innocent.

But i wont vote at anyone else. I'll Abstain
 
I do not think D'Artagnan is a wolf. She is just an old lady who believes her cats are talking to her. If the wolves can not murder someone last night why should we have to kill someone when there is no evidence there is even a wolf still in town. I shall be a part of this. There may have only been one wolf left and he might have left town. Is anyone missing?

Leave D'Artagnan alone and leave her to her cats. Her prophecies may be false. Chalk it up as senility or plain craziness but that is not enough reason to kill someone.

I vote for NOBODY
 
The cripple listens to the heated discussion about D'Artagnan and her cats.

"Lying cats *cough*. Maybe D'Artagnan is just an *cough* old fool. Maybe *cough* she is something else trying to misguide us."

"I cannot pass *cough* judgement into either direction, without all the facts, so I *cough*cough* shall abstain for now."
 
D'Artagnan. He's either a wolf or too stupid to live. And I've no great suspicions of anyone else (except marginally against Jhoniten).
 
D'Artagnan59, I wouldn't be surprised if your innocent, but we can't have false prophets running around spewing out erroneous information.
 
I suspected the old woman's words were false, but I followed them to catch a false prophet in a lie. But I didn't stop to consider that a false prophet isn't necessarily a wolf. I'm leaning towards that now, but I guess I'm too late to turn this around now, so better join the majority saying D'Artagnan. But my true suspicions lie elsewhere.
 
Back
Top Bottom