Birdjaguar said:
@Lotus49: It is far simpler to pick the major market swings. Buying the S&P or Total market in March 2003 and selling at the soon-to-be-forthcoming top will net a larger gain without any cost or risk of your frantic day-to-day scramble.
That is precisely the conventional wisdom. Maybe I'm just a rookie, but I find it easier to predict what a few people are going to do, in one particular area, at one particular time, over the very, very near future... rather than try to determine what the whole mob is going to do, 12-18 months out.
Did you call the "exquisite-moment-bottom" in March '03? Where are you calling the top? I'm still waiting - it was supposed to be in Q1 or Q2 of 2005. Then '06. Now '07.
The recovery from the huge down-turn is going to take a considerable amount of time - much longer than the typical cycle, to recover. (Not my words, some guy named O'Neil -founder of I.B.D., several years ago) When everyone is this cautious, I see no reason to bail out, or run for the doors. (Warren Buffet had a quote...)
Slow-down, sure. P:E compression? -Hmmm... remains to be seen. Hey, like I said, I''m a rookie, maybe doomsday is upon us. But, as long as I can make at least a thousand bucks a week trading intra-day, it really doesn't matter (which, if I apply myself, that is a piece of cake).
There are other markets, though. U.S. housing market is not the only thing that makes or loses money in the world. Somebody, somewhere is always making money - and a lot of them are obvious long-term international plays that can't lose.
Index funds are great - IF you're in a bull market. Otherwise, they BLOW. Everybody was hyping index funds back in '03 and '04. Suddenly '05 rolls around, and nobody talks about them anymore. Just like when speculation was the Fed was going to 5.5% or more, CD's were all the rage. Now? See, you guys are chasing the winds more than I am. Ironically.
Every trading day various stocks are taking part in certain moves, for whatever reasons. All I do, is log in, watch them (and TV at the same time, maybe music, maybe have a game window open), and act accordingly. I often exclaim, "It can't be this easy! It CAN'T be...!" -Not exactly a "scramble", as you say.
Or, you could sit around, and watch mutual funds slowly fluctuate, as the sands of time slowly pass away...
18% this year! Hot-diggity DOG!