Tom Clancy

Clancy started going downhill when he left submarines. ;)

In reality, I think the problem was the end of the cold war.
Red October and Cardinal of the Kremlin were great Ryan books. (Cardinal's a little weird to read now). Patriot Games was pretty good too, as Clancy at least decently came up with credible villians with the IRA terrorists, and Clear and Present Danger was enjoyable to read. Finally, Red Storm Rising was great, with real casaulties on all sides, and what I thought were great scenes between the frigates and the subs, sorry Simon.

While I enjoyed the second half of the Sum of All Fears, it displayed signs of the downfall of Clancy which got amplified in most other books.
1. He spent too much time on exposition, a sin most noticeably seen in Executive Orders, where 3/4ths of the book is exposition and stage setting.
2. He raises the stakes to immediatly threaten the entire US/and or world, instead of smaller action stuff of the Ryan series.
3. Even the scale of action is bigger, he constantly downplays US casaulties. The bomb in Sum of All Fears is a semi-dud, only killing thousands. Except for Congress, it seems only Japanese and some American subs go in Debt of Honor, while Executive Orders has justifiably only a few thousand due to Ebola, while there hardly any US casaulties in Saudi Arabia, and hardly any US casaulties fighting the Chinese, I'm trying to remember the last time a US Fighter was even shot down in a Clancy book, I believe it's Sum of All Fears.
 
Answer to AoW:
That is usually what happens in the real world. Hitler's death wasn't much, heck, he killed himself
Yes, Hitler died, but the ending of WWII cannot be called anticlimatic. The Third Reich lost the war in Kursk 1943 but the war didn't end before 1945...

C'mon, what do you expect from a Japanese government that doesn't have armed forces large enough to take on the US. They can't be everywhere at once.
Have you read the book? He spends at least a hundred pages explaining how impregnable the Japanese air defences and missile site is...

The Indians are whimps, and I'm sure their navy was stretched pretty thin, with all of the running around they did in Debt of Honor, I'm sure that the IN was pretty worn. As for the "Army of God," they had nice navigation systems, but the tanks were still old, and what tank owned by a third-world country could take on the Abrams M1A2? Oh, if you read "The Bear and the Dragon," you get more about the Chinese.
One would think the Indians had thought the Americans might shoot at them...
Yes, the tanks were of poor quality, but these huge forces of lousy tanks couldn't even overwhelm a single poorly-equipped American brigade.
The Bear and the Dragon does not really portray armoured battle properly. The destruction of the Chinese forces is perhaps even more anticlimatic...

Oh course the virus kills itself! It isn't an airborne type of virus in the first place. That was a fluke, and it wouldn't work in the real world, like it didn't work there.
Yes, but the Iranians had perfected the virus. They made it airborne, and we know the virus is capable of infecting in eternity. The incubation period of ebola is several days, so it wouldn't kill the victims before it could infect someone else.

As for the american extremists, The Mountain Men, they were just two idiots who thought they could actually do something. What did you expect? For them to brake the road block and rush to Washington? They would've been arrested that way, too.
Yes, but why did Clancy have to spend sooooo many paaaages to explain something that didn't influence the plot at all?
 
I understand there are others that agree with me that Clancy's books aren't all good.

I've heard the names Forsyth and Orwell mentioned by several. I've only read Animal Farm, never 1984 and I've never read any Forsyth. Maybe I should do that...
 
What's great about Forsyth is the details matter. In the Dogs of War, he goes into great detail to explain how the merc forms shadow companies to set up his campaign, but the bits and peices matter. In the Day of the Jackal, virtually all of the book is setup for the main event, including several pages on acquiring ID and a rifle. But, once again, every detail ties together in the final push. It's artful.
 
Back
Top Bottom