With a week left for the votes, lets see where our close races are at (as of Oct 24th). If you haven't looked at these proposals yet, you should absolutely do so, as every vote matters at the moment.
VP Congress Session 1: The Close Races
- Thread starter Stalker0
- Start date
If they have ten more to yes I think they should pass. Trying out is better than stagnating. If they will be unpopular or wrong we can vote them out in the next session, I think that's one of the reasons VP congress was made. 10 seems like a solid advantage anyway. I wouldn't call that close if they are only 60 or 70 votes cast in total. Even with 100 votes that's a convincing 10% point lead.
In case of Brazil changes, to my regret, it is ten votes for no advantage, currently 22.9% point lead to no, so they should not be passed. Same with free warrior for tradition (as of now).
In case of Brazil changes, to my regret, it is ten votes for no advantage, currently 22.9% point lead to no, so they should not be passed. Same with free warrior for tradition (as of now).
Last edited:
Currently if a proposal even has 1 more vote than any others, it will pass. On a straight completely even tie, Recursive breaks the tie.
Sure, simple majority is okay. I just meant, there's enough community support for it to be accepted as a win if we have 10%. I think devs should reserve the right to choose if there's really tight voting and sensible arguments to both sides.
Rekk
Deity
- Joined
- Dec 9, 2017
- Messages
- 2,725
Are you suggesting that a change should be implemented even if only 10 (or 10% of?) voters support it?
No, I suggest that's a comfortable majority for it to be clear support.
While most of these threads have solidifed.
(10) Make Paper Maker Make Paper Proposals https://forums.civfanatics.com/threads/10-make-paper-maker-make-paper-proposals.679957/
is down to a TWO VOTE MARGIN!!!!! So if you haven't voted yet, go and vote!!!!
(10) Make Paper Maker Make Paper Proposals https://forums.civfanatics.com/threads/10-make-paper-maker-make-paper-proposals.679957/
is down to a TWO VOTE MARGIN!!!!! So if you haven't voted yet, go and vote!!!!
I've just reduced it to one vote margin
Perhaps we should have ranked voting, but requiring a supermajority to pass, but requires it being proposed by one of the three leaders of the world council, but only after Fertilizer is researched, to ensure the correct answer is picked and implemented.
