Originally posted by cavemanf16
Personally, I think the Americans should have been given a UU of 'Militia Soldier' as a special unit. After all, the F-15 comes too late in the game, isn't that useful, and really isn't a special unit in real life. The Soviets had the more powerful Mig-29 available during the Cold War that could outperform the F-15 anyways, so I'm not sure why the F-15 was chosen as the special unit.
So my thought is give the Americans an early version of the Infantryman that has 2 movement points, and is between a Rifleman and an Infantry unit in defense/offense capabilities. That would at least give the Americans a boost in the middle game, as having Expansionist and Industrious as Civ traits sucks after the opening moves part of the game. Once into the Industrial Age, I find myself bartering away whatever I can just to keep my American civ current with the Scientific and Religious Civ's.
If you look at the stats of the F-15 and Jet Fighter you will notice that the a/d/m are both 8/4/6 giving the F-15 no edge in air to air combat.
The adv of the F-15 is that it has 2 higher in bombard than a normal jet fighter effectively making it an air-superiority weapon as well as a mediocre (at best) bomber.
IMHO the F-15 could be better. It has less impact on gameplay than other UUs in thier 'appropriate' era. If you like gigantic world wars in industrial - late era games, the F-15 is adequate (nothing more).
It seems when they were making the UUs they tried to tailor it to the civ it belonged too. It would only make sense that the Americans would have a later-game air superiority weapon, thats what the Americans have been doing since WW2.
As far as the Mig 29 vs F-15, this is very debatable. IMHO, the edge is going to go to the F-15 here ... in RL it has proven its worth in combat over the Mig 29 and every other soviet fighter it has encountered. America also trains thier pilots well, with the latest technology, making them arguably the best in the world. Therefore IMHO the F-15 should have a *slight* advantage in attack, one point or two points extra max (imho).
The UU I would have liked to seen for the Americans is an air-refueling tanker. For every air-refueling plane in your fleet, you get to make one unlimited range bombing attack on a one - to - one basis. This might throw balance off a bit though =(
It would be nice to have a 'militia' like infantry that moves 2 spaces ... but its not very American. Since they were making an attempt to be somewhat historically accurate with UUs, an American unit of this type wouldnt make sense (whether it adds balance or not). America has never had a unit of that type in its history ... in fact American militia of old has performed miserably (like most militia) on most accounts.
As far as keeping up with the scientific and religous civs, well, thats why you have an F-15
IMHO the Russians should get the indust era tank (T-34) over the German Panzer. Germans could get a a fast moving Infantry(indust era), perhaps showing Germany's ability to swallow and hold land.
-Cannibis Sativa
"Shop smart, shop S-Mart"