What is a christian?

HannibalBarka

We are Free
Joined
May 14, 2003
Messages
3,956
Location
Paris, France
I didn't know that this was still on topic, I really thought all what I call "christians" (some one who recognize Jesus as God or the son of God) recognize other what I call "christians" as being "christians". Apparently it is not the case when you read through the "Missionnaries in Iraq" thread since a lot of "christian" a seeing the Catholics as non-christian??????

So how you'll define a Christian?
By the way for me, every one that recognizes Jesus as God, the Son of God is christian, every other thing is cosmetics.
 
a christian is someone who believes that Chrst died for them and forgave thier sins, and all they have to do is ask to be forgiven. While it would be great if they believed God created the earth, and jesys rose again, the important thing is they must know that Jesus died for us, and they only need to ask. the second part is usually the hardest thing for people to accept. they think they have to be a good person or do more good things than bad things. that's wrong. everyone is able to accept christ. saddam hussien could be a christian if he accpted Jesus as his savior. Osama Bin Landen, Hitler, etc. etc. every person looking at this page can be a christian. BUT they have to realize that Jesus died for them, and all they need to do is admit it, and believe it.
 
I believe that Jesus lived and died and was a very special man who taught some good stuff. I dont believe any of the miracles or god stuff though so I'm non-Christian.
 
it can't go both ways. he claimed he was the son of God. he was either right or wrong about that. He claimed that he died to forgive all of us. He was either right or wrong about that. He said that he was the only way to eternal life. he was either right or wrong about that. He was either the son of God or a lunatic. you can't pick part of both
 
So among the different Christian sects (sorry if the word sect hurts some one, It is not intended, but I don't know another word) do you consider them being Christian or no:
Catholics, JW, Copts, Othodox, Presbytarian, Anglicans, Mormons (?), etc
 
I took the 12 step program, and Ive been Christianity free now for almost 25 years (pauses for applause). However, I believe that Jesus was the son of god. So am I. So is everybody.
 
I would say that anyone who believes Jesus of Nazareth was the son of God and that died for our sins, is a christian.

A true christian is someone who lives by his teachings, I guess. I don't think there are too many true christians around, if any.

One group of Christians claiming another group of Christians is wrong is rather laughable.
 
@ bholed
No. The primary criterion in the threads so far is the believe in Jesus above all else. He is only one of the many facets in the hierarchy of Catholic belief.
 
A Christian in the year 2004 is someone who believes and acts according to the word of preachers who interpret the message of Jesus Christ according to their own indoctrination or agendas within the Christian faith.
 
Originally posted by Achinz
@ bholed
No. The primary criterion in the threads so far is the believe in Jesus above all else. He is only one of the many facets in the hierarchy of Catholic belief.

=======

Still unsure what your point is caller?
As far I understand things Catholic are Christians the same as
Protestant's no more or less.
Both believe in JC as being the Son of God.
 
'Christian' has a rather large range of interpretations - here are some of them, and the reasons they have been refuted.

Christian has been used to refer to anyone who incorporates Christ into their religion. Thus Mormans, JWs and even Hari Krishnas call/have called themselves Christian. For differing interpretations about Christs role in relation to God, however, people that would call themselves mainstream Christians would not call these other groups Christians. Christian based sects, perhaps

Christian is used for anyone who adheres to the Christian religion. ie, believe in the centrality of Christ, recognise the concpet of the trinity, and give some sort of authority to the scriptures. Or they simply go to a church that deos these things. Or just go to a church. This is where it becomes hazy.

Is a Christian defined through adherence to a series of rules, rituals, traditions, and creeds, or defined by a personal faith?

Historically, this is the cause of the Protestant/Catholic split. Other doctrinal issues are involved, of course, but these were the basic reasons for the reformation.

Thus in modern times, both Catholics and Protestants view the others versions of Christianity with suspicion.

There are real Christians in both, and frauds in both. It comes down, as Stapel suggested above, to whether someone ultimately practices what they preach. Whether you see that around will largely depend on the society you live in.
 
Oddly enough, many Christian friends have suggested that I am secretly Christian because I live by a strong code of ethics although I deny the existence of anything supernatural.
 
Originally posted by col
Oddly enough, many Christian friends have suggested that I am secretly Christian because I live by a strong code of ethics although I deny the existence of anything supernatural.

Yes, ethical athiests (is that a correct definition?) is one reason that I like to remember this quote of John Newton's (the guy who wrote Amazing Grace).

"If I ever reach heaven I expect to find three wonders there: first, to meet some I had not thought to see there; second, to miss some I had expected to see there; and third, the greatest wonder of all, to find myself there."

Its a top quote, and I think it almost fits into my theology :)
 
Originally posted by col
Oddly enough, many Christian friends have suggested that I am secretly Christian because I live by a strong code of ethics although I deny the existence of anything supernatural.

My mom used to call people good christians whether they were christian or not, depending on how they lived their life. I'm sure she'd clump you in the same group.
 
Back
Top Bottom