The Kingmaker
Alexander
- Joined
- Jan 18, 2004
- Messages
- 1,971
There's something on the order of 30 civilizations that have been previously featured in the series that have yet to return. I've sorted them according to priority below. There's a small handful we could maybe do without, but it would be an absolute shame if the majority of these civs did not return.
Critical Priority - Major civilizations who should already be in the game. Their absence is keenly felt. Need to be DLC, stat!
Mongols - Created the greatest contiguous land empire in history and fundamentally changed the Old World forever.
Babylonians - The lynch pin civ of the ancient Near East. Has been in every game so far with good reason. All the more needed after Sumer's poor showing this time around.
Incas - South America's anchor civ. That continent is unrepresented other than Brazil, and the Aztecs are the lone Pre-Columbian civ.
High Priority - Important civilizations that fill key spots in the game. Ought to be in XP1.
Mayans - We're in sore need of more Pre-Columbian civs.
Ottoman Turks - Another major Middle Eastern power.
Carthaginians - A North African favorite, especially for elephant lovers.
Iroquois - Either them, or another important Native American tribe. The Native Americans are as yet unrepresented.
Koreans - A well-accomplished civ and an important market in the gaming world.
Malians/Songhai - They fill a key spot in Africa. I say make them a multi-leader civ and depict them both.
Khmer - An old favorite that we've been wanting to see since Civ4's XP2. Bring them back!
Moderate Priority - Solid civs, but mostly expansion fodder, but it'll be good to have them back sooner or later.
Byzantines - Another fan favorite.
Celts - Ancient Europe's only representative outside the Mediterranean. Civ5's version was a disgrace. Needs to be tidied up, perhaps a Gaulish civ?
Ethiopians - An ancient and accomplished African civ.
Assyrians - A nice new addition from Civ5's second XP.
Indonesians - Expecting to see them soon as DLC.
Moroccans - Another nice new addition. Tweak them a bit and make them Almoravid or Almohad themed.
Polynesians - They were fun in Civ5, but do need some tidying up to be a bit less blobby.
Dutch - Had a big colonial empire.
Portuguese - Ditto.
Zulus - They're a Civ-mainstay and bound to come back sooner or later.
Low Priority - These could fill some gaps if needed. XP3, anyone?
Austrians - A lot of overlap with the current HRE-themed Germany. Could still be done well, but they're not urgent right now.
Hittites - Haven't seen them since Civ3. Would be good to have them back, but not before all these others above.
Sioux/Shoshone - It would be nice to have another Native American civ, but it needs to be done properly.
Siamese - They're not bad, but I'd prefer the return of the Khmer first. Poor Ramkhamhaeng doesn't get a lot of love.
Swedish - By this point on the list, they're looking like just another mid-tier European power.
No Priority - We can do without these, in my humble opinion.
Danish/Vikings - Considerable overlap with the current portrayal of Norway.
Huns - A very odd inclusion. Shouldn't return unless they make the barbarians playable somehow.
Venetians - Was already very eclectic in Civ5. Ought to be replaced with a multi-leader Italy civ representing both Venice and Florence.
Holy Roman Empire - Shouldn't have ever been separate from Germany/Austria. Currently overlaps with Barbarossa's German civ.
Native Americans - Way too much of a blob civ. Separate and distinct tribes are preferred.
At some point, I may do a second post with my thoughts on never-before-seen civs that merit inclusion too.
Critical Priority - Major civilizations who should already be in the game. Their absence is keenly felt. Need to be DLC, stat!
Mongols - Created the greatest contiguous land empire in history and fundamentally changed the Old World forever.
Babylonians - The lynch pin civ of the ancient Near East. Has been in every game so far with good reason. All the more needed after Sumer's poor showing this time around.
Incas - South America's anchor civ. That continent is unrepresented other than Brazil, and the Aztecs are the lone Pre-Columbian civ.
High Priority - Important civilizations that fill key spots in the game. Ought to be in XP1.
Mayans - We're in sore need of more Pre-Columbian civs.
Ottoman Turks - Another major Middle Eastern power.
Carthaginians - A North African favorite, especially for elephant lovers.
Iroquois - Either them, or another important Native American tribe. The Native Americans are as yet unrepresented.
Koreans - A well-accomplished civ and an important market in the gaming world.
Malians/Songhai - They fill a key spot in Africa. I say make them a multi-leader civ and depict them both.
Khmer - An old favorite that we've been wanting to see since Civ4's XP2. Bring them back!
Moderate Priority - Solid civs, but mostly expansion fodder, but it'll be good to have them back sooner or later.
Byzantines - Another fan favorite.
Celts - Ancient Europe's only representative outside the Mediterranean. Civ5's version was a disgrace. Needs to be tidied up, perhaps a Gaulish civ?
Ethiopians - An ancient and accomplished African civ.
Assyrians - A nice new addition from Civ5's second XP.
Indonesians - Expecting to see them soon as DLC.
Moroccans - Another nice new addition. Tweak them a bit and make them Almoravid or Almohad themed.
Polynesians - They were fun in Civ5, but do need some tidying up to be a bit less blobby.
Dutch - Had a big colonial empire.
Portuguese - Ditto.
Zulus - They're a Civ-mainstay and bound to come back sooner or later.
Low Priority - These could fill some gaps if needed. XP3, anyone?
Austrians - A lot of overlap with the current HRE-themed Germany. Could still be done well, but they're not urgent right now.
Hittites - Haven't seen them since Civ3. Would be good to have them back, but not before all these others above.
Sioux/Shoshone - It would be nice to have another Native American civ, but it needs to be done properly.
Siamese - They're not bad, but I'd prefer the return of the Khmer first. Poor Ramkhamhaeng doesn't get a lot of love.
Swedish - By this point on the list, they're looking like just another mid-tier European power.
No Priority - We can do without these, in my humble opinion.
Danish/Vikings - Considerable overlap with the current portrayal of Norway.
Huns - A very odd inclusion. Shouldn't return unless they make the barbarians playable somehow.
Venetians - Was already very eclectic in Civ5. Ought to be replaced with a multi-leader Italy civ representing both Venice and Florence.
Holy Roman Empire - Shouldn't have ever been separate from Germany/Austria. Currently overlaps with Barbarossa's German civ.
Native Americans - Way too much of a blob civ. Separate and distinct tribes are preferred.
At some point, I may do a second post with my thoughts on never-before-seen civs that merit inclusion too.