A Tale of One City [Game Thread]

It was directed towards landlubber.

Funnily enough, "I don't think [BigTin] is scum" is why people want me lynched!
 
Gah. I know I'm not looking too good, and I have an explanation; I suck at playing townie, specifically trying to form cases that make sense to anyone but me. At least for the past few games. Maybe I'm just having an off-week.
Anyway, it appears that Zack's the top suspect (behind myself, of course). I recognize that the vote jumping really won't help my case any, but I'm going to do it regardless.
Unvote, vote: Zack.
 
Jesus Christ Zack, what the hell was that?

I was about to make another post defending you, since before this two page outbreak it really did seem like you just happened to post the wrong thing at the wrong time.

But then this, two pages of quadruple posting and raging. I'm no Mafia expert, but that sir, isn't something that can be easily defended.

I'm still not going to vote to lynch you, since I don't think you're scum, but you're not going to catch me crying if you do end up lynched.
 
I'm still not going to vote to lynch you, since I don't think you're scum, but you're not going to catch me crying if you do end up lynched.

wswQ1.png
 
After this game, I'm just going to go into johnhughthom's patented "apathy and snide remarks" play style.

:mad:

Guess I'll have to take yours.

Wah, wah, boo hoo, everybody metagames me. I'm not playing mafia again it sucks.....

Wait 2 minutes....

Hi guys, I'm back! Whats been happenin?

:p

Vote: Zack
 
After I'm lynched and turn up innocent, lynch these people at some point:

  • landlubber
  • askthepizzaguy

Look at these people closely:

  • BSmith1068
  • Mergle
  • Jarrema
  • Anyone who voted for neither NinjaCow nor BigTin whom I haven't already listed

No more likely townie (aka "hey mafia, kill these people") lists.
 
Gah. I know I'm not looking too good, and I have an explanation; I suck at playing townie, specifically trying to form cases that make sense to anyone but me. At least for the past few games. Maybe I'm just having an off-week.
Anyway, it appears that Zack's the top suspect (behind myself, of course). I recognize that the vote jumping really won't help my case any, but I'm going to do it regardless.
Unvote, vote: Zack.
(bolded for emphasis)

"I really don't actually suspect Zack at all, but he's the leading candidate, so I'll vote for him to save myself."
 
For the host's convenience:



Zack: 9 (ATPG, General Olaf, Jarrema, JoanK, Darth Caesar, Mergle, landlubber, DaveShack, JHT)

landlubber: 6 (choxorn, BSmith, Zack, Kennigit, Verarde, Yoshiegg)
 
Gah, no editing means I keep making strings of posts.

Anyways, I suspect that at least one of the remaining mafia are both active contributors to and avid readers of the thread. The last two kills have been noted as likely townies by both myself and Pizzadude.
 
Anyways, I suspect that at least one of the remaining mafia are both active contributors to and avid readers of the thread. The last two kills have been noted as likely townies by both myself and Pizzadude.

mafia wouldn't need a list of "likely townies", they know everyone's alignment soooo I don't get this post.
 
mafia wouldn't need a list of "likely townies", they know everyone's alignment soooo I don't get this post.

The same reason they'd want to kill someone who's been scanned innocent. Typically mafia like killing people everyone thinks is townie, and leaving people everyone suspects alive.
 
Day 4 is over

The people had chosen Zack this day. When they began to hang Zack, they were sure he'd turn out to be mafia and they had made a good choice. They were wrong.

Spoiler :
Zack was lynched, he was innocent!


Spoiler :
Zack: 9 (ATPG, General Olaf, Jarrema, JoanK, Darth Caesar, Mergle, landlubber, DaveShack, JHT)

landlubber: 6 (choxorn, BSmith, Zack, Kennigit, Verarde, Yoshiegg)


Living

1) General Olaf
2) DaveShack
3) MjM
4)
5) Verarde
6) Mergle
7) landlubber
8)
9)
10) choxorn
11) CELTICEMPIRE
12) Kennigit
13) BSmith1068
14) LordNwahs6
15) Jarrema
16)
17)
18) askthepizzaguy
19) Joecoolyo
20)
21) JoanK
22) Darth Caesar
23)
24) Yoshiegg737
25) johnhughthom

Dead

1) Red_Spy --Lynched day 1 --Innocent
2) Classical_Hero --Killed night 1 --Innocent
3) Ninjacow64 --Lynched day 2--Mafia
4) MoreEpicThanYou --killed night 1--Innocent
5) BigTin --Lynched day 3-- Mafia
6) Diana Abnoba --Killed night 3-- Innocent
7) Zack --lynched day 4-- Innocent

Night 5 ends in 24 hours
 
<ahem>

Called it, along with 5 other people.

atpg...tsk tsk tsk.

ATPG and landlubber are both tied for #1 now in my suspect list.

Zack, we love you.
 
Yeah. ATPG and landlubber need to go next.

I'm glad I came off of you Zack. Just sorry that not enough others did as well.
 
:smug:

Spoiler :
For the record, I would not in a million years act that way as mafia; it would be pure idiocy. Like I would really come in late in the day and say "BigTin is probably innocent" when he's my mafia buddy and I know he's getting lynched. Are you kidding me? I would jump on the bandwagon, I'm not an idiot!

And I typically try to masquerade as a helpful townie when I'm mafia, but I never pretend to try to be this helpful. It's way too risky, as evidenced here.
 
Well, that wasn't too surprising.

ATPG, you have some 'splainin to do.
 
Back
Top Bottom