Are CDs dying?

aimeeandbeatles

watermelon
Joined
Apr 5, 2007
Messages
20,112
I just moved and while waiting for the internet people this morning I was sorting through some old scans and I found this which I had meant to post earlier. It appears in the Chronicle Herald (Nova Scotia paper) on November 18.

Spoiler :
img001wl.jpg


What do you think?
 
I hope this does not mean a future of lossy MP3s.

Also, I can't operate an MP3 player. I tried all sorts of ones in the store. My fingers are too big and clumsy. This is why I still use a portable CD player.
 
I haven't been to a mall in years, do they still have music stores where you can buy music? (in the form of CD's or whatever). To be honest, I haven't even noticed if places like Best Buy, Fry's, or even Target still carry CD's. I know they still carry DVD's. I think the articles is premature calling for the death of DVD's. Downloading movies over the internet still requires hefty bandwidth.

This is actually kind of interesting in a way, although sad for the music stores. It's interesting because there is no hard object that replaces CD's. Before you had 8-tracks replacing vinyl. Then cassettes replacing 8-tracks. Then CD's replacing cassettes. And now nothing replacing CD's. By nothing I mean digital downloads over the internet.

It's kind of sad for the music stores like I said. I spent many hours just browsing music store selections of CD's (and cassettes before that) back in the 90's. I never got into the vinyl craze. I do have 3 vinyl records, but I don't actually own a record player.

As for CD's I still use them in my car. My car doesn't have the ability to play MP3's, and I don't own an MP3 player. In my car I usually listen to the classical public radio station, or if I'm in the mood for metal I'll put in a CD (my car has a 6 disc changer). At home I listen to either my MP3's on itunes, or youtube, or Pandora. But I expect to be using my CD's in one way or another for many years to come.

Interestingly, I don't even remember when stores stopped carrying cassettes. I didn't even notice. I haven't used a cassette tape in many years. I haven nothing that can play cassette tapes. Both cassette players on my 18 year old stereo are broken. I still have many cassette tapes in my closet, however.
 
I just noticed today, yes Target does still sell CD's. Although they don't have very many of them. A lot of them seem to be bargain CD's. In some ways it is nice to actually "own" something. I have never bought music online, but I'm under the impression you don't really own it, and you are restricted in how you use it. The problem I had with CD's is I'd always drop the CD case on the asphalt on the way to my car, and I have like 20 or 25 broken cases right now. :( I try to keep my stuff in good condition, but I also like to listen to it.
 
Yes, CDs are dying, and interestingly enough, vinyl is making a rebound. A lot of old bands are reissuing their albums on vinyl, and a lot of new bands are exclusively releasing new albums on vinyl (no CD), and both of them are packaging the vinyl with codes for MP3 downloads of the album. I think it's very cool; vinyl for quality listening at home, and mp3 for on the go and ipod listening. CD's are only useful to me as a form of hard backup to my music, and even that is better satisfied with my ipod or external HD.
 
Re: the loss of CD's

Good riddance, welcome to the future.

Re: the reemergence of vinyl

Thank goodness, a welcomed slice of the past.

CD's generally have bad sound quality anyway. If you want a physical version, vinyl is much higher quality (although most people don't have a good enough sound system to hear the difference). And if you want a convenient version, MP3's are much better. CD's currently occupy an IMO unnecessary middle ground between the two.
 
back in my day you had cassette tapes, and you could conveniently copy from one cassette tape to another. Ahhh, those were the days. You didn't have to worry about the RIAA finding your bootleg cassette tapes and suing you for $100,000. I have not downloaded any music since they started suing people. I also don't buy CD's because I'm cheap, and I'm not interested in music like i used to be. If only I could illegally download music without fear of prosecution...
 
Interestingly, Tom Petty said just recently that he believes the future is in Blu-Ray (he came on Twitter to answer fan questions and that was one of the answers). What do you people think of it.

EDIT: This appeared in the December 8 issue of R.S. which I purchased. I hope it is ok to post it if not could a mod please inform me.

It is the 3rd question talking about digital media.

Spoiler :
rs1145.png
 
Blu-Ray is the future for movies absolutely, but for music? I don't see it. They never started using DVD's for music instead of CD's and I don't see that jump happening this time either.
 
Well some artists (T.P., for example) have embraced it. I dont think it seems to be taken much seriously though. I think there's potential.
 
I like CDs because they are tangible and you can say to yourself with confidance "ahh yes I own this album!". When it's an MP3 download you don't get that same satisfaction as you do with teh CD. Especially if the album cover has a good piece of art on it. I buy CDs from musicians who i rate highly, everybody else gets the electronic download treatment.

I am yet to buy a vinyl. My parents have plenty of them and i think they're beautiful.
 
I don't know if CDs are dying. They probably are due to digital download. I love buying CDs. They're much cheaper and easier to carry, etc., than vinyl, but they have the physical, material quality that digital download lacks. I still buy a lot of CDs because they are pretty cheap, often cheaper than on iTunes.
 
I am yet to buy a vinyl. My parents have plenty of them and i think they're beautiful.

Get some. They are so worth it; record player/speakers are the best gift I've ever received.
 
I was never really into music so never bought CD's. I dont like the idea of movies going downloadable only though, they'd probably make it so we can only rent them.
 
CD's will never die, and the comeback of vinyl, sorta proves that.

A digital copy is not lossy! A CD is a digital copy! A DVD is a digital copy. A blu-ray is a digital copy! A vinyl is a copy! It is the means of reading the copy and transferring it to speakers that produces the sound variances.

A magnetic tape is lossy, because the magnetic properties can change. Digital reproduction when it comes to "playing" can be lossy, because the firmware or hardware can add interference.

Attempting to set the digital record straight. BTW, if you change bit rates and "change" the quality, that is not a copy, but a change in format, ie "creating" a new and different copy.
 
Tucked in a corner of today's Truro Daily News, there was also a piece about it. However my scanner is still lost* or I would scan it.

* actually, I found it & know where it is. It is just inaccessible because there are too many boxes in front of it to get it out safely.
 
Back
Top Bottom