Ask a Muslim

Status
Not open for further replies.
A more controversial question now:
Are the Hindus justified in asking for these three (and only these three) places of worship back, so that the Mosque may be shifted somewhere else and a temple built on that spot? These three temples are as important to us as the Kaba is to Muslims.


My personal opinion is that the people should vote and if they decide that these Mosques are vile symbols of hated invaders then they should be demolished. If they vote to keep the mosques then so be it. I also think it would be appropriate for the Israelis to do the same with the Temple of Solomon.
 
In my experience, I've never known of a case of a woman being forced to wear the Niqab (face veil). *All* of the people I have known in my life who wear the Niqab are girls who themselves choose to do so, oftentimes to the great consternation of their parents.

Then you are not vary experienced. In the Shi'a portions of Iraq it is common for women who do not where a face veil to have acid thrown into their faces. This of course results in massive facial injuries and perminent scaring.

It is barbarous, of course, but very common. In Iran women can legally be beaten in the streets for failing to wear a face veil while acid to the face is also popular in parts of Pakistan. Fear is what keeps most of the women wearing veils. Not personal choice.
 
The Niqab (face veil) is *not* mandatory in Islam. However, Hijab (headscarf) definitely *is* mandatory. As for why Muslim women wear the Hijab (headscarf), this is as a sign of modesty, chastity, and piety. Even religious Jewish and Christian women cover their hair, which is a commandment in the Old Testament. The typical covering of a religious Muslim woman is fairly the same as a Christian nun. A Muslim female covering her body properly is considered a defense of her honor, chastity, and morality. We believe that women dressing in a revealing manner is immoral, unchaste, and obscene, which leads to the degradation of the very social fabric of society.

Why doesn't all this apply to muslim men??
 
Why doesn't all this apply to muslim men??
Probably the reason why men don't wear mini-skirts and other feminine modes of dress...
 
So, basically, the women don't have to wear the face veil.
Thank you. :)

More Questions

Would a muslim woman ever dress like a woman in the united states? (Ex. Jeans, t-shirt, sandals/flip-flops)

Do Muslims think that women showing skin is wrong?
 
This whole covering someone's body or face from various religions just seems to be a cover up as a mean to prevent their counterparts that they are attracted phisically. This also sound like having sex is a sin, or just the fact that you can have 'sexual thoughts' is a sin just blow my mind away.

How are you suposed to have offspring if you don't have sex, if you are not physically attracted to someone? Isn't having a familly and lots of kids written in those holy books to be a good muslim, christian.. whatever religions?
 
FranciscoHernan said:
Probably the reason why men don't wear mini-skirts and other feminine modes of dress...

No he already explained that Islam does not recognize men and women as equals. The temptation for lust posed by males is less than the temptation of lust posed by females, so "logically" women must wear the proper clothing to conceal themselves (or their objects of shame 'awrah').

As quoted by Sheikh Muhammed Salih Al-Munajjid:
"One of the things that people misunderstand is when they say that 'Islam is the religion of equality'. What they should say (instead) is that Islam is the religion of justice."
Justice...according to the moral standards established by the prophet Muhammad.
 
No he already explained that Islam does not recognize men and women as equals. The temptation for lust posed by males is less than the temptation of lust posed by females, so "logically" women must wear the proper clothing to conceal themselves (or their objects of shame 'awrah').


I really need to understand the bold part.
 
I really need to understand the bold part.

What is the misunderstanding? According to Islam it is the female body that causes the temptation therefore it is incumbent upon the female to conceal herself. It is not right for the female to burden the male by revealing her 'awrah. 'Awrah basically signifies the body parts that need to be covered.

Muhammad said women are awrah:

Kanz-el-'Ummal, Vol. 22, Hadith No. 858

Ali reported the Prophet saying: 'Women have ten ('awrah). When she gets married, the husband covers one, and when she dies the grave covers the ten.


According to Sayyid Sabiq's Fiqh-us-Sunnah. op. cit. vol.1. pp. 125-127

It has been agreed among jurists on the basis of the Qur'an and Sunnah that 'awrah for the woman is defined as the whole body except for the face and hands. For the man, the 'awrah is defined as the area between the navel and the knees.

I am sure Salah-Al-Din will agree that to satisfy the total requirements of the Islamic veiling fatwa as per Holy Quran and Sunna, women should wear clothing to cover her beauty so that they can be protected from the hands of the weak and sick hearts in the Muslim society. It is the women that are the source of temptation while the innocent man plays the role of the victim.

As far as I am concerned veiling women will never solve the problem of weak men with sick hearts. Men should learn to respect women as human beings and to achieve that, men should wear the veils and burqas around their own sick hearts.
 
I am actually not sure where the number 72 came from. I just searched Quran for "heaven", "houri", "martyr" and there is no mention of a number. In Quran it is generally said that believers will get appropriate houris, this does not mean plurality, and for couples they are the appropriate ones for each other (as well as their family). There are hordes of verses describing the heaven, but I'll just post a few relevant examples:

38:50 - Gardens of Eternity, whose doors will (ever) be open to them; 38:51 - Therein will they recline (at ease): therein can they call (at pleasure) for fruit in abundance, and (delicious) drink; 38:52 - And beside them will be chaste women restraining their glances, (companions) of equal age.

13:23 - Gardens of perpetual bliss: they shall enter there, as well as the righteous among their fathers, their spouses, and their offspring: and angels shall enter unto them from every gate (with the salutation):


Once a muslim asked Muhammad that he liked his camel very much, and would he be given a camel as good as it in heaven. Muhammad replied that Allah gives each believer the reward they wish (or something like that - I am quoting my 6th grade religion classes here). So it is easy to get adolescents into the cause by promising 72 houris in heaven, as most adolescents will like; and also point out that martyrs go to heaven and hand him some weapons. Very simple and efficient recruitment.

Excellent question, and I'm glad you asked it.

In fact, there are a multitude of rewards that we are told about in the Quran and the Prophetic Sayings. The 72 virgins promised are but *one* of the many rewards promised. Although there are dozens of verses in the Quran about Paradise and its rewards, only five of them mention the virgins. The rest mention other rewards in Paradise.

Amongst all of these rewards in Paradise, the *greatest* reward in Paradise is to see the Face of Allah, which means to be in the Glory of God's presence and to be in His good pleasure. Allah describes Paradise by saying:

"Allah has promised the men and women of the believers Gardens with rivers flowing under them, remaining in them timelessly, forever, and fine dwellings in the Gardens of Eden. But the greatest bliss is the Good Pleasure of Allah: that is the supreme felicity."
(Quran, 9:72)

It is said in the Islamic lore that the Greatest of all rewards is to be in the presence of God in Paradise, and this will make people forget all other rewards...that is how great it will be.

There are many materialistic rewards that are offered to the believers in Paradise, and these are definitely mentioned in the Quran and the Prophetic Sayings. Let us look at one of the Prophetic Sayings in which Allah gives these materialistic rewards to the People of Paradise, and then Allah asks them:

"Are you well pleased now?" They would say: "Why should we not be pleased, O Lord, when You have given us what you have not given to any of your creations?" He (Allah) would, however, say: "May I not give you something even more excellent than that?" And they would say: "O Lord, what thing can be more excellent than this?" And He (Allah) would say: "I shall cause My Pleasure to alight upon you and I shall never be afterwards annoyed with you." (Saheeh Muslim, Book 040, Hadith Number 6787)

The Quran uses materialistic rewards like 72 virgins simply as an encouragement to do good on this earth, and it is the only type of reward that people can understand and relate to.

You have tried to portray the Islamic Paradise as non-spiritual, but this is not the case whatsoever. In one of the descriptions of Paradise, the Prophet (s) said of the People of Paradise: "There would be no dissension amongst them and no enmity in their hearts. Their hearts would be like one heart, glorifying Allah morning and evening." (Saheeh Muslim, Book 040, Hadith Number 6797)

So most of the time would be spent in spiritual bliss and prayer. The carnal rewards mentioned are so that people on this earth can relate to Paradise, and thereby strive for it. A Muslim man is commanded, for example, to lower his gaze and to refrain from looking at women on the street. In fact, if he looks at them (i.e. "checks them out"), it is said that he loses virgins in Paradise as a punishment. So the basic principle is that you are getting rewarded in Paradise for the sacrifices and struggles you had on earth. This is something noble, not something disgusting.

For a life of austerity and struggle, you get rewarded in Paradise. This is only fair. Muslims, like I've said, should not listen to music, mix with the opposite gender, etc etc...these are all very tough things to do, and the encouragement is given with materialistic things in Paradise. Many of the things forbidden to us in this life are promised to us in Paradise (in a sin-less form) if we just give it up here. So the *reason* that Allah promised men these virgins is because men must not womanize in this life. The same is the case with wine: it is forbidden in this life, but it is promised in the next life as a compensation. But the wine of Paradise will have its sin removed from it, and so will the sin from the women be removed.



First of all, the Prophet (s) said that a believing woman who gets Paradise will be made 7,000 times more beautiful than the Hooris (virgins).

Secondly, the women should not complain at all, because Allah has promised them a great reward in Paradise, so great that they can't possibly be ungrateful. Allah says:

"And whoever does good deeds--whether male or female--and is a believer: these shall enter the Garden (of Paradise), and they shall not be dealt with an iota unjustly." (Quran, 4:194)

"I will not waste the work of a worker among you, whether male or female..." (Quran, 3:195)

"Whoever does good--whether male or female--and is a believer: We will most certainly make him live a happy life, and We will most certainly give them their reward for the best of what they did." (Quran, 16:97)

"Enter the garden, you and your wives; you [all] shall be made happy." (Quran, 43:70)

There are some women who wonder why Allah has promised men these Hoor and not the females. Allah reassures them:

"I have prepared for My righteous slaves (such excellent things) as no eye has ever seen, nor an ear has ever heard nor a human heart can ever think of." (Saheeh Bukhari, Volumn 009, Book 093, Hadith Number 589)

---------------------

Sexual fulfillment is considered a basic need and necessity. Therefore, it would not be appropriate for Allah to have left out mention of this in the rewards for Paradise. Likewise, other essential needs and necessities--such as food--have been mentioned in the descriptions of Paradise. Luxurious foods await the believers. The basic principle, again, is to eat sparingly on this earth (without gluttony) and get luxurious food in Paradise as a result. The sheer chastity and modesty that Islam commands its believers in regards to sex necessitates that the Muslims be rewarded in this category in the next life, and this is why Allah has promised the believers such rewards.

It should be noted that 72 virgins were promised the martyrs in battle. This was because men were forced to leave their wives behind and risk their lives for the defense of justice. Many of the men did not wish to leave their wives behind and had a difficult time controlling their sexual urge for months. Therefore, this promise was made to them: that their sacrifice would not go unanswered. There is a story in one of the Prophetic Sayings about a very ugly man who finally gets married to a woman, and somehow he managed to get one of the most beautiful girls in the city! Everyone is shocked that such an ugly man got such a pretty girl, and the guy is of course elated when the two are wed. Unfortunately, he is called off to battle right after the wedding, even before the first marriage night. He dies in battle. The people feel pity on him saying "what a shame" since he left behind such a wife, but the Prophet (s) smiles and says that one of the virgins of Paradise is greeting this soldier and this is his reward for his sacrifice.

The reason that the Quran and Prophetic Sayings did not mention women getting male virgins, is because this would contradict the extra level of modesty that is demanded of women in Islam. The Quran and Prophetic Sayings are shy when it comes to women, in this department, as it is not considered appropriate. This may seem strange to people of a Western culture in which these things are openly discussed, but this is not the case for Muslim cultures.
Good answer, thanks. :) If I have any more follow up questions later, I'll post them.
 
Do Muslims believe in the ten commandments?

Yes. The Christians believe that Christianity is a continuation of the Judaic tradition, but that Christianity superceded Judaism. The Muslims agree with this, but say that Islam is the continuation of them both and superceded both of them. Therefore, we believe in the revelations and scriptures sent to the past prophets, but we believe that they have been abrogated and superceded by the Revelation sent to Prophet Muhammad (s).

Nonetheless, the spirit of the Ten Commandments lives on and in fact pretty much all of these laws can be found somewhere or the other in the Quran.

Then you are not vary experienced. In the Shi'a portions of Iraq it is common for women who do not where a face veil to have acid thrown into their faces. This of course results in massive facial injuries and perminent scaring.

It is barbarous, of course, but very common. In Iran women can legally be beaten in the streets for failing to wear a face veil while acid to the face is also popular in parts of Pakistan. Fear is what keeps most of the women wearing veils. Not personal choice.

This is an outright lie and a botching of the truth by the silly West who do not understand the East. Yes, it *is* very much true that there are many cases of acid throwing in Pakistan. (I've never heard of it in Iran.) However, this has nothing at all to do with the face veil and this is simply the Western bias to insert their own agenda into events.

The practise of throwing acid on the face of women is done by two groups of people: (1) spurned lovers and (2) husbands who fear that their wives are cheating. The former is usually more often the case, in which a man's advances are rejected by the woman. There has been case after case of men whose marriage proposals are rejected and then they will retaliate by disfiguring the beauty of the woman they proposed to. It is a sadistic revenge.

In most parts of Pakistan and Iran, the face veil is not commonly worn anyways, so your assumption that *this* is the reason is silly. What sense does it make that a man will pour acid on the face of a woman because she doesn't want to wear the face veil? This is nonsense; if husbands in this country wield such immense power and control over their subjugated wives, then surely simply commanding his wife to wear the face veil would be enough, and it makes no sense that he would resort to throwing acid. Instead, acid throwing is done by people whose goal is to completely disfigure the face of the woman and ruin her life as a form of revenge for spurning their love or (supposed) cheating.

This practise of burning the face of women is illegal in both Iran and Pakistan. Furthermore, it is completely Haram (forbidden) in the Islamic faith. It has nothing at all do with religion, but it has to do with backwards and uneducated people. In fact, there have been many cases of acid throwing done by Hindus in India; does this mean that it has anything to do with Hinduism? No. It is simply a barbaric practise done by some bitter people. In both India and Pakistan, there are groups working to bring an end to this abhorrent practise. Unfortunately, the corruption in the police and judicial system in both countries leads to ineffectivity and the practise continues unabated.

-------------------

More to come, Allah Willing.
 
Then you are not vary experienced. In the Shi'a portions of Iraq it is common for women who do not where a face veil to have acid thrown into their faces. This of course results in massive facial injuries and perminent scaring.

Er, no. Link me a news story where you read this.

It is barbarous, of course, but very common. In Iran women can legally be beaten in the streets for failing to wear a face veil while acid to the face is also popular in parts of Pakistan.

Really? Apparently these women, at a government polling location, missed that memo.

Fear is what keeps most of the women wearing veils. Not personal choice.

Laws in Saudi Arabia and Afghanistan (still?). Fear on the part of the latter. Salah-Al-Din was wrong to say it is an ancient tradition.

The older generation of Saudi women — our mothers and grandmothers — did not know the abaya and have only become familiar with it in recent years. Saudi women used to wear a piece of material or cloth to cover their hair; once that was put on, they then went to work — in the fields, at home or wherever — without experiencing any ethical, social or religious problems.

http://arabnews.com/?page=7&section=0&article=77694&d=6&m=11&y=2006

Then again, it's Saudi Arabia....
 
Yes, the fact the practice of this barbaric is mainly in former India (Pakistan, India and Bangladesh) because reasons which Salah-Al-Din mentioned.
 
So, basically, the women don't have to wear the face veil.

No. It is optional.

Would a muslim woman ever dress like a woman in the united states? (Ex. Jeans, t-shirt, sandals/flip-flops)

If the jeans were *extra* loose and the shirt covered her completely to the wrists, then there is nothing wrong in this. Sandals/flip-flops are permissible.

Do Muslims think that women showing skin is wrong?

Yes, we find it morally abhorrent.

Why doesn't all this apply to muslim men??

I'm saying why doesn't modesty apply to muslim men?

Modesty does very much apply to men in Islam. Men are enjoined to be modest. In fact, it is said that Prophet Muhammad (s) had more sexual modesty than a shy virgin woman.

However, man and woman are physically different. Woman's most sexually attractive part is her body, including her breasts and curves. Therefore, the focus in Islam is to cover these parts with loose clothing. As for the man, the most sexually attractive part of the man is considered the jawline, and it is considered sexually immodest for a man not to cover this up with his beard. Therefore, Muslim men are enjoined in the religion to grow out big beards as a sign of modesty. Muslim men are also strictly commanded to cover their private parts (obviously).

As for covering of the head, this is enjoined on both men and women. Men wear turbans and women wear the Hijab (headscarf). Both are advised to wear loose clothing.

But special emphasis is given to women because it is they who are known to "go crazy" in this aspect. An unbiased view of our society today confirms this. It is woman's body that is exploited on every street corner, on every magazine rack, and on every billboard. Nobody could intelligently ask why there is a focus on women in this matter. The evidence is obvious: one simply has to look outside in which it is naked women everywhere.

In fact, it was only very recently that men started "catching up" in this respect, but even still, they are way behind. But Islam warned about this period, in which men would start acting like women, and therefore advised that when this time came, that men should also covering up strictly. Indeed, whenever there is fear of Fitnah (evil), then the Muslim is warned to be extra cautious.

Probably the reason why men don't wear mini-skirts and other feminine modes of dress...

Exactly.

Solutions are given in Islam for problems that *exist*, not pure ideological banter. In society, it is women that are half-naked all over the place and not men. If you go to work, it is men who are dressed in suit and tie, without any part of their bodies exposed. Men do not have low necks showing their cleavage. On the other hand, even the woman's business suit is sexualized, and she has a low neck exposing her cleavage, and her calves and legs are exposed. The suit itself is designed tightly so that it clings to her body and is form-fitting.

Therefore, Islam was practical and its emphasis is on practical problems that exist. It is women that are the major problem when it comes to physical displays of sexual immodesty and therefore they are advised with extra caution in this regards. Men are warned too; however, not as much as emphasis is put in this warning, since it is not needed.

This whole covering someone's body or face from various religions just seems to be a cover up as a mean to prevent their counterparts that they are attracted phisically. This also sound like having sex is a sin, or just the fact that you can have 'sexual thoughts' is a sin just blow my mind away.

How are you suposed to have offspring if you don't have sex, if you are not physically attracted to someone? Isn't having a familly and lots of kids written in those holy books to be a good muslim, christian.. whatever religions?

It is very sanctimonious for a people who come from a culture that thinks about sex all day long to say that men should just not think evil thoughts. Is it not this forum that has a "babe thread"? This Western society has collapsed into sexual immodesty and social degradation. Therefore, they are obviously doing something wrong. Islam has the solution to this. Do not lecture about how "Muslim men" should have self-control so there should not be any need for Muslim women to cover up. For your information, Muslim men are enjoined in the Quran to lower their gaze away from looking at stranger women and to show self-control. But not everyone in the society is Muslim. There are non-Muslims, as well as non-practising Muslims.

There is no way to create a society in which women can be showing "T&A" and the men just show "self-control" and everything is hunky-dory. If you can show me one such society in all of history, then I will give you all of my father's possessions as a concession to my defeat. The fact of the matter is that whenever women show their stuff in any society, that society spirals down into a state of moral degradation.

Is it not America in which 90% of men and women have pre-marital affairs? Is it not America that has one of the highest rates of bastard children being born, so much so that the very meaning of bastard has been lost? Is it not America that the family unit is destroyed, and the divorce rate is sky-high and there are broken families. The destruction of the family unit is a result and consequence of the sexual immodesty and obscenity that is so prevalent in the society.

If America and the West had a working society to compare to the Muslim model, then fine and well. Then maybe I would concede that there could be a society in which women can show off their "T&A" and everything works out fine. But since there is no such society that has ever existed in *all* of history, then I think it's safe to say that women covering up is an important part of morality and the social fabric of a society.

The West has won the race in technology and wealth, but they have lost the war of morality, and they are seeped into moral degradation and disarray.

I assume that a woman doesn't keep herself covered in front of her husband, so it wouldn't impede sexual attraction.

In fact, both husband and wife are encouraged to sexually attract each other. Both are encouraged to "adorn themselves" in an attractive manner inside the house. Again, Islam simply discourages all sexuality outside of marriage. But inside marriage, sexuality is encouraged as something very healthy and productive, as it creates stable marriages and therefore stable family structures. On the other hand, sexuality outside of marriage leads to the destruction of stable marriages and then leads to broken families.


No he already explained that Islam does not recognize men and women as equals.

Your language is designed to be sarcastic in nature. I do not appreciate this.

I clearly said that Islam recognizes men and women as spiritual equals. However, there are certain matters which differ due to the basic differences in men and women.

It is not right for the female to burden the male by revealing her 'awrah. '

Once again, your sarcastic use of language is a bit...annoying. You used the word "burden" simply to impart to your sentence an anti-Islamic flavor. Is it tongue-in-cheek.

The fact is that religious and moral societies have always advised their women to dress modestly. You can use whatever language you want to describe it, but this is the case. Why in the world do Christian nuns dress like they do? In fact, Christian nuns dress pretty much *exactly* like Muslim women are advised to dress: in loose outer garments and with a headscarf. So why do people have such a big issue with Muslim women but somehow they look upto and respect nuns?


I am sure Salah-Al-Din will agree that to satisfy the total requirements of the Islamic veiling fatwa as per Holy Quran and Sunna, women should wear clothing to cover her beauty so that they can be protected from the hands of the weak and sick hearts in the Muslim society. It is the women that are the source of temptation while the innocent man plays the role of the victim.

No, Salah-Al-Din does not agree with you. Who says the men are portrayed as innocent and who play the role of victim? Far from it. In fact, the man who looks at women and checks them out is condemned in the harshest tones in the Islamic canon. It is said that molten lava will be poured into his eyes in the Next Life. If Islam were saying that the man is the victim, then why would the punishment for checking out a woman be molten lava in the eyes?

Therefore, Islam's stance is that the woman showing off her body is sinning and the man looking at her is sinning. Both are in a load of trouble. Neither are innocent victims. It is the same as the case with prostitution: a woman prostitute is to be condemned, but the man who buys her is also to be condemned.

As far as I am concerned veiling women will never solve the problem of weak men with sick hearts. Men should learn to respect women as human beings and to achieve that, men should wear the veils and burqas around their own sick hearts.

In fact, Muslim men are enjoined and ordained to purify their hearts and to refrain from looking at women in that manner. In fact, there are even religious "recipes" and prayers that are used to cure a man's sexual drive when it comes to stranger women.

You say that veiling women will not cover the problem for weak men and sick hearts...firstly, I'd like to say that Islam would consider most of the men on this forum to be in that category. The babe thread is just one example. The society of the west is full of such men, so I do not see how they can sanctimoniously imply that it is only Muslim men who are such.

Secondly--and I will bold this part--you say that it would not solve the problem if women cover up. But indeed it does! A woman who covers herself up cannot be looked at it the same lustful manner. Your logic is like saying that police officers shouldn't wear bullet proof vests because it doesn't solve the problem of bad guys with guns and bullets. Yes, wearing the protective vest won't eliminate bad guys off the streets, but it would certainly protect that particular police officer from being shot and wounded. The Muslim woman covering her body is therefore a defensive mechanism that most definitely protects herself from harm, even if it does not eliminate the bad guys off the streets.

To conclude, Islam ordains that both men and women dress and look modest, and it enjoins on BOTH to lower their gaze and refrain from looking at the other and thinking vile thoughts.

Take care and apologies if I sounded harsh.
 
Laws in Saudi Arabia and Afghanistan (still?). Fear on the part of the latter. Salah-Al-Din was wrong to say it is an ancient tradition.

Fear is an emotional word, designed to conjur up certain images.

All societies have a dress code and laws. In America, the law is that women must cover up their breasts and cannot expose nipples in public. Do we then say that women in America cover up their breasts because of fear? Or rather, do we say that women cover up their breasts because of the law?

Most American women grow up with this idea that you can't expose your breasts in public and therefore it is a non-issue. I don't think many American women are crying about this, or even think about this twice. The same is the case with Saudi women. They grew up with this modesty and therefore it is not an issue.

It should also be noted that face veil is *not* mandatory in Iran, Saudi Arabia, or Pakistan. In both Iran and Saudi Arabia, the law simply stipulates that women need to cover their heads. I've been to Saudi three times, and I saw plenty of women showing their faces. As for Pakistan, it doesn't even have a law that says you need a headscarf.
 
People try to make Muslim society sound bad and evil, but yet these people should recognize the good as well. If you see how well the family unit in Muslim (and Eastern) families works, you will be surprised to see how broken the family unit is in most (but not all) Western families (in comparison to the former). In Muslim families, kids don't tell their parents to shut up, slam doors, and rebel like they do in the West. In Muslim families, the parents don't keep praying that their kids turn 18 so that they move out. On the contrary, they hope that their kids continue to live with them. Parents aren't forced to live in nursing homes. Children do not live in single-parent families. When parents say something, the children respect this and obey it, even when the children are grown and adult. It is in the West that people have children outside of marriage and thereby no stable nuclear family exists for the illegitimate children. The wholesome family unit exists in the East, not in the West.

Obviously, these are stereotypes and generalizations. I'm sure that there are families in the West who have excellent family units. However, the general rule of thumb is that the West has more broken families than the East, and the sexual laxity and lewdness in society is one of the main causes of this.
 
I have to admit I feel inferior to you, Salah-Al-Din. You know the Qur'an better than me and you have answers to everything. I am afraid of posting in this thread now, even though I think the parity of a fundamentalist and a secularist would be interesting.

For the past week, I have been reading the Qur'an in my free time. I have lived with more thought and care. You were right to say I was lax about many things. :( I have sworn off drinking and other things. I won't give up music though :)

I never claimed to speak for all Muslims. I cannot accept that I'm unable to speak as a Muslim though. :(

You called the cultural of Afghanistan backwards. Do you believe those men worship Allah too? Do you not think that they view how they practice Islam as the correct interpretation? And do you in turn not believe that they see you as incorrect?

Why are you right and they wrong? Do not quote text to me. The Qur'an says many things and you can take many meanings away from me. Why is your view more correct than theirs?

And for me, why is your view more correct than mine? When I talk to God, I know that I am alright. When you talk to God, I assume you feel the same. Why can I not speak for Allah as I know Him?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom