Well my opinion of him has went up. I had 2 +6 theater squares in my game. Can't complain about that, one was a little later, however. And I forgot about the aesthetics card until late. Whoops. I never really use that card until today. Not that it mattered, I really didn't have room for all those great people.
Carnival is okay I guess. I ran some numbers on a standard size map epic speed game. A solid boost of 26 great people points. Not great, but it is for 5 great people.
engineer 126+3=129 actual 155/difference 26
merchant 676+11=687 actual 714/difference 27 (just finished a market and game didn't update GM points/turn)
writer: 467+26=493 actual 519/difference 26
artist: 554.4+20= 574.4 actual 600.4/difference 26
musician: 600.4+7= 607.4 actual 633.4/difference 26
I protected my initial +6/+12 theater, even to the point of not putting a seaside resort. I was very good about not chopping rainforest. Though my production sucked all game since I concentrated so much on theater squares and wonders.
My start. I did bump up rainfall to wet, couldn't resist. I almost never play on that map setting.
My victory time was not as fast as I expected. Cree put up a fair amount of cultural resistance. The crazy adjacencies are kind of fun, but the small cities and lack of production weren't. I did knock out the rainforest by the campus in my capital for seaside resorts, but for the most part I kept nearly all the rainforest I started with except ones needed to place districts/wonders.
Ranking: Pericles is still my fastest, followed by Australia, Kongo, America, Spain (yeah I know, it was a weird game), Poland, Khmer, and then Pedro/Brazil. I'm not listing the slower times. I give him a B+ for cultural victory, a C- for everything else.