Eh, Civ V is the strategy game from 2010 I had by far the most enjoyable play time with. Didn't play Napoleon: Total War, but I'd put it ahead of Starcraft II (certainly beats Civ for polish, but not for actual enjoyment in my eyes), and wasn't PvZ a 2009 game?
I would NOT expect Civ V to win many "strategy game of the year awards" because it simply did have issues, but I'd be shocked if it didn't win a few. However polarizing it is, a good number of people love the game - and that's because the game is actually pretty damned fun to play.