SIP does give you the fish, no guarantee you'll get them if you move. It will be a slowish start but once you've got workboats out you'll be able to grow and expand reasonably quickly. I'd probably go SIP, build workboats, research mining>BW and coincide first worker with BW. You might find a better starting city location, you might not and just lose turns going back to where you started.
Archipelago may be easy but its likely to be different to the standard (research HbR, chop HAs, research miltrad, whip cuirassiers) game.