After playing my first games I have to say I’m in utter amazement how they could release such an unpolished and unfinished product… I’m sorry some of these issues and faceplants have been mentioned before… this is just a small selection of the numerous issues it took little time to identify...
Challenge
- First game (gemini), far from being a great Civ player, quit at turn 150 being more than double points ahead number two , having just received my second affinity point… *sigh* restart... Second game (second highest difficulty) – rage quit after taking enemy capital not losing one soldier on turn 120. Almost double points. I have 7 cities, most have 2-3 .
- “Hello, my name is purity one Explorer. I will camp outside every nest on the planet until the stoopied aliens leave, and then I will burn it with no retaliation. Because I just turned into a God, not sure why this godhood does not extent to my friends in marine clothing over there - but still… fire it up”
- On Gemini, I thought my three cruisers should soften up the defences of my nearest enemy’s capital. To my utter surprise, three (3!) volleys brought the city down to zero, and a CARVER I keept as backup as a ship could just take the city. Mine and their main army did not exchange a bullet… (I actually replayed the turn, there was ZERO way that the my enemy could hinder me from taking the capital in that first turn of war. Even if I declared war and let him move first, two cruisers and two marines were more than enough…
UI
- I spent 20 min trying to locate the option to show what my city just built, no avail, this most obvious information does not exist.
- I can hardly see what hexes my population is working from the gigantic icons cluttering the city interface. I actually never access the ciry screen any more, except for one reason… trade route availability (*sigh* see further down)
- (update: seems i might be wrong on this) You can’t search for buildings or units on the research screen… A CTRL-F function would suffice…
- Still I can’t see if my damn artillery can fire on the evildoers BEFORE I set up. *sigh*
- I can’t see the damned miasma… and I got 20/20 vision… In orbital view I’ve missed a couple of launches of repulsers due to this.
- No warning on either Explorers or workers will DIE in miasma before they finish their task... You will have to gauge if they have enough health left, and then remember to check EVERY TURN
- And worst of all – workers lack radio… “Sir, I’m close to death here, mind if I go to the hospital to heal up and finish this later?”… They just work themselves to death.
Trade routes & stations
- I have no clue what stations are for. They are almost always a worse choice than a normal trade route. I did not really like city states (until the PLUS maps solved my main issues) but this is a gigantic disappointment. It’s just a wasted tile that kills your ability to settle where you want for some unknown reason… and they are kinda ugly... A station the size of a city....
- Don’t even get me started on trade routes… a brand new city can produce a Tacjet or marine on standard speed in 1 turn after the third vessel is built… Balancing people, balancing…
- Trade route updating… all the time… every turn…
- (also seem to be wrong on this, but this is minor point) Not stating previous trade route (are you effing kidding me)
- When building a vessel, I first need to press the city to see if I have room for more trade vessels or convoys. No info on the production screen.
- No info if there is anyone I can trade with BEFORE I build a vessel or a convoy. Especially in the early game, wasting time building a vessel or convoy just to find out that I can trade with no one is almost a rage quit.
- Trade depot and Autoplant… all you need….
Other:
- Most sad - wonders… are not wonders…. Almost all are really boring and pointless. The feeling when you GE rushed Notre Dame or fought your neighbour over Stonehedge… all gone. Or that epic feeling when you finished Liberty as Poland and still managed to grab the Hanging Gardens, what memories of joy. Or getting the Weather Paradigm in AC - NOW the fuuuun starts! *siiigh*
- A victory picture… Most disappointing ending since the last Batman movie...
- Is there any point to use diplomacy? Sorry, I can’t see any... in any game so far.
But – I still enjoy it. But in my mind, this is as broken as Civ5 was on release, maybe even more. And with Civ5 I stayed away for 2 years until I found the energy to go back.
Ok, I’ll end rant here… Firaxis… Please fix above in a patch. If you wait until a DLC or something an avid fan having played every game since Civ1 will be lost.