Frontier Justice [Game Thread]

[Takhisis]

You take that back, outatowner yellabellie!

An' you Akaron or whatever it's spelled like, I's alive because I's a suspicion bait.

 

[Arakhor]

A suspicion bait that has not actually ever come close to being lynched?

One of town's main problems now is that there are several suspects to choose from and only one vote before LYLO.

 

[Takhisis]

Not actually ever come close to being lynched? A few days ago I was almost lynched.

 

[Xym]

Hi. I have been sick and sleeping a lot. /blush
Sorry for the absence.

I will vote after a bit of a reread.

 

[Xym]

I will vote: Omega124.

It might be just me, but though she is rather chatty her posts are fairly content light.
Her current suspect seems to be mat (and that is all), if I am reading right.
Which is weird; he is the one really who has built a case against Omega. Furthermore, I might be blind, but I really do not see him leading town around or going on various witch hunts against town.

I have no idea what to think of Takhisis. :/ The point that he was lynch bait is valid though; he was drawing votes for two days and has one against him today.

I feel that Duff's posts have been fairly content light. I have no idea who he does and does not suspect, aside from Bsmith. Who he seems to have been tunneling most of the game, tbh...

SouthernKing is not around and neither is Bsmith. :/ Which is a shame, really.

Spaceman looks rather good to me, still.
I also have a slight town lean for mat.

^ Both of those two seem to have been providing the most analysis of the alive players and I do not really get any bad vibes from either.

(I think that is everyone...)

Which is of course why you arbitrarily voted for me yesterday, despite claiming that you thought I was the most towny person alive.

Honestly, this is also a good point against Omega.

This avatar stuff is really throwing me off yo.

Ha, me too.

 

[Takhisis]

It'd be easier if you all joined the Unity.

 

[Omega124]

if we're all going to decide and talk on who to vote for before lylo, should we perhaps not be voting as quickly as possible like a lot of people seem to be doing? Seems counter productive, whether it's against me or not against me.

Now, I'm of course opposed to the lynching of myself, because I am a townie, but let's say for the sake of the argument ei am a mafia. Who the hell is my scum buddies? What was my end game with all my votes? How have I, with barely knowing any of your personalities, managed to play you guys all off for so long to survive to this current point?

the only person to actually give an argument this turn is the constant lurker xym, and it's literally "I talk too much", which seems highly hypocritical coming from the guy who was highly inactive. At least I'm putting myself out there, while you're doing absulotely nothing. I forget you're even in the game most of the time! For everyone else who criticized me for bandwagon voting, the last of any good reasons also shows hypcrosity on your ends.

Again, I hold mat is the most likely scum of all the players. I'm not sure on other scum reads. I still kind of suspect Tak as well, but I don't have anything specificll connecting the two. I certainly don't know the last one; I'm guessing one of the lurkers out of xym or SK occupy that slot. We could do a 50/50 chance of lynching one of those two and hope for the best, but I'd perfer not leaving town victory up to luck.

 

[Takhisis]

Why shouldn't we vote this quickly? We don't have a hammer rule.

Why shouldn't we vote you? We do see a glass of wine in front of you.

 

[SouthernKing]

I am very much around.

vote: DuffKilligan for the same reasons as yesterday. He posts enough to barely skim under the radar but, like I said, provides absolutely nothing of substance. I find this incredibly suspicious.

Some of my observations from the rest:
-Takhisis just seems like he's trolling since he has, like I said earlier, some degree of immunity in the form of the hat. It's not a liability yet I don't think, but we should still watch this in case.
-Omega's flinch posts are wordy yeah but I don't believe that a scum would go these lengths of visibility, even in her situation where she's had multiple wagons.
-BSmith and Xym both haven't posted enough for me to really know. That could very well be a sign of scuminess but I don't think we're at that point in the game where we should be lynching on that alone.

 

[Takhisis]

We could vote for Omega so that the Gumbo Campaign game can progress more smoothly… but really, either one or both of DuffKilligan and Omega is fine.

 

[Omega124]

We could vote for Omega so that the Gumbo Campaign game can progress more smoothly… but really, either one or both of DuffKilligan and Omega is fine.

Brb making sure Tak gets the worst role in the game.

 

[DuffKilligan]

vote: DuffKilligan for the same reasons as yesterday. He posts enough to barely skim under the radar but, like I said, provides absolutely nothing of substance. I find this incredibly suspicious.

This statement simply isn't true. I've given my reasons for voting, laid out the candidates who I think are the best target for lynching and have commented on some of tak's behavior. I don't know what else I have to do. The whole "no substance" crap is nonsense, which is why no one agrees with you. Your analysis if anything is very insubstantial as it's essentially rehashing what others think.

 

[Xym]

Well, then, I shall take a look at your (Omega's) previous ten posts.

I also agree that discussion on votes is important; no matter the day.
Further, however, votes can change and it is still not yet halfway through the day phase.

I am going to also look at my other suspects later today.
My mafia leans are Omega, KM, Duff.

Sorry, it is backwards.
Spoilered for space.

Spoiler :

if we're all going to decide and talk on who to vote for before lylo, should we perhaps not be voting as quickly as possible like a lot of people seem to be doing? Seems counter productive, whether it's against me or not against me.

Now, I'm of course opposed to the lynching of myself, because I am a townie, but let's say for the sake of the argument ei am a mafia. Who the hell is my scum buddies? What was my end game with all my votes? How have I, with barely knowing any of your personalities, managed to play you guys all off for so long to survive to this current point?

the only person to actually give an argument this turn is the constant lurker xym, and it's literally "I talk too much", which seems highly hypocritical coming from the guy who was highly inactive. At least I'm putting myself out there, while you're doing absulotely nothing. I forget you're even in the game most of the time! For everyone else who criticized me for bandwagon voting, the last of any good reasons also shows hypcrosity on your ends.

Again, I hold mat is the most likely scum of all the players. I'm not sure on other scum reads. I still kind of suspect Tak as well, but I don't have anything specificll connecting the two. I certainly don't know the last one; I'm guessing one of the lurkers out of xym or SK occupy that slot. We could do a 50/50 chance of lynching one of those two and hope for the best, but I'd perfer not leaving town victory up to luck.

A passionate defense and now prodded, some opinion, however only on Mat (again), Tak which is... not a lot. I do not know what she is attempting to say about Tak. It seems based on Mat certainly being mafia. I do not follow otherwise. The last is 'well, I reckon one of the 'lurkers' is a mafia'. What of the others who are alive? Anything?

I admit my activity this game is abysmal, but I am here now for discussion, if you wish. I would like to reiterate that my accusation was not that you talk too much, but that for the number of posts there is rather little that I see as far as mafia hunting goes. Your defense is based on me being a hypocrite. (Whether I am or not, it does little to address my real point.)

I still hold mat is the most likely scum still alive. Unrelentless in his witch hunts that went nowhere. If we have to choose one, I'd like him.

Tunneling on Mat. We do have to choose one, but providing opinions on a range of suspects and voting for one person is of course not mutually exclusive.

Because then no one wins the vote, and it will just be given randomly.

Hat discussion.

It's to my knowledge that only alive townies get credit for the win, no? And I perfer winning, thank you very much. That's why I'm fighting to not get lynched, so I can get credit for the win. If I get credit for a win dead, by all means lynch me, see I'm a townie, and realize you wasted a lynch and are one step closer to losing. Then again, since I. Pretty certain you're scum yourself, I shouldn't be enabling your wild hunts that end up never going anywhere.

Defense. More accusation of Mat.
There is no mafia hunting here.

Fine you know what, if people seriously think I'm scum buddies with him.

vote:Arakhor

Does that help?

It does not help. You said he was townie a few posts ago! Voting for those you believe town is unhelpful.
No mafia hunting. Defense.

firstly, herself, Tak. Please.

Anyways, idk I thought we all trusted him? Now we don't? I'll be honest, I haven't been paying as much attention to this game; I've been busy setting my own up and doing the ask a trans thread. If we suspect him now, that is news to be tbh. But we can give the hat to someone else. The point I was trying to make, badly it seems, that I'm not in it for personal gain.

This post seems to be largely defense. This also seems 'thread consensus-y', it seems, rather than supplying her own opinion on the matters discussed.
No mafia hunting.

Rithat, so now that a case is building up on me, I'll actually respond.

You know why I wait until people vote before I vote?

1. When I was one of the first voters on R1, people started a bandwagon against me. Most of the bandwagons in fact seem to start when people vote early. So basicilly no matter what the hell I actually do, I'm going to be under suspicion when I vote

2. I really don't know who the hell most of you are. I only have extensive contact with Joan and SK, and some with Tak. Besides that, yeah I'm going to /have/ to rely a lot on how other people read people they're more used to, so I'm not going around making misguided assumptions (see: how spaceman acts n most games). I make my own decisions when it comes down to it, and I stand by the choices I made in terms to lynch, but I really don't work on the same personal knowledge you people do



Because when I was one of the first voters D1' a bandwagon against me formed. Again, it's like I'm just suspicious to you no matter what the hell I actually do.

And if Goldenknight did have anything to say, we really should hear what he has to say before doing any major voting that round. D2 is still pretty low information, and since Joanna didn't do much besides try to haze me into trying to survive the lynch, he really didn't add much usefulness even when he was confirmed town. Golden could have.



I concur with what SK said re myself. You guys are getting way too worked up over a really bad lead with the best evidence being "i change my posting style depending on if I think people are trying to lynch me or not". You really have no good reason to suspect me based on my votes themselves, nor do you have any idea in what my mafia partner would be if I was mafia. It's like the town at this point knows it lost already and is blindly shooting in the dark in a last hope to maybe get a mafia. But I don't wear no pinstripe.

Also, if Tak is even remotely suspected of being mafia, which I do because Tak's end game seems to be seeding as much chaos as possible without actually trying to get noticed, then he /has/ to be eliminated ASAP because if a mafia has the hat, it becomes much harder for the town to win. Honestly I think akanor should have the hat, since he is the most confirmed townie left alive.

If there's two mafia, tbh I think any pairing of mafia has to include mat. He acts like an u relentless attack dog against everyone, who always ends up being a townie at the end. A success rate like that means he probably is a scum himself, and I don't trust him alive. If you guys decide to lynch me, you'll see that I'm a townie (because I am), and there will be yet another victim of mat and his scummy ways. That being said, if there is a chance Tak is mafia, he needs to be eliminated first.

I find it strange that Omega mentions only having extensive contact with Joan, SK and some with Tak, but makes a comment on Spaceman's meta.

I still do not understand the point about Goldenknight.

This is a good point about Tak, and is the post where she notes Arakhor as town lean.
This seems to be the first post accusing Mat.

When I try I'm scum. When I don't try I'm scum. When I flinch I'm scum. When I don't flinch, I'm scum. I mean, some people are going to call me scum either way so

If someone has a serious case I'll respond to it. Until then, I'm going to ignore the peanut gallery of the scumiest townie I've ever met, and the OMGUS hat voter.

More defense.

I do not trust cats with hats. You've seen Lec with a hat? Absulote madcat. Can't deal with him.

Vote:Takhisis

Yep. Keep shooting in the dark. You might hit something eventually.

No real read from these posts.

 

[Takhisis]

Brb making sure Tak gets the worst role in the game.

Right… I'll be a GM too one day…mwahahaha

This statement simply isn't true. I've given my reasons for voting, laid out the candidates who I think are the best target for lynching and have commented on some of tak's behavior. I don't know what else I have to do. The whole "no substance" crap is nonsense, which is why no one agrees with you. Your analysis if anything is very insubstantial as it's essentially rehashing what others think.

How about not focusing on the cat in the hat?

 

[Omega124]

Well, I guess I'm sorry that I don't like to make wild accusations willy nilly. Firstly, fiRandom accusations can turn to lynches, and we are 0 for everything in this game. We have a severe case of being unable to locate the mafia, whomever they are. And if you guys lynch me, you're going to see I'm a townie with an unconventional playing style and be absulotely nowhere.

In re to Arakhor; he was going to be lynched anyways, and I was in second place to boot on the vote tallies. If he did end up for whatever reason being scum, then I would look super scummy for wanting to give him the hat. By contributing to his lynch, my intent was to show I was trying to be altruistic when I wanted to give the hat and if I was wrong and he was scum, then I had nothing to do with it. That message did not seem to come through, which is my bad.

I'm done trying to explain the GoldenKnight thing because it seems like a basic concept that is too hard for you guys to understand. I stand by my actions there, even if "words of confirmed townies are good" is too high of a concept for you to understand

In re on you, using hypcrosity is a bad argument since it really proves nothing on why I'm scum. If you're showing scummy traits yourself, then why aren't you the one who is scum? Because, again, I fear the no talkers way more than the lots talkers.

In re spaceman, it's called "reading other people's posts about him". They say this is normal behavior for him. I can trust them on that.

I think an Omega KM Duff pairing doesn't work because there is clearly no longing collaboration between us. You can probably dig a post of my agreeing with Duff near the beggining of the game, but that's about it. KM and I have been at each other's throats. Pass.

IF I was scum, my likely co conspirators would be SK and Arahkor (you could swap SK with edse). If there's any players I've been working together with in the course of the game, it's those two. However, everyone I named but SK is dead at this point, and they were townie. It's almost it's because I'm not mafia or something along those lines.

 

[Omega124]

Btw I just want to say I'm usually on my iPad while I post these, which has a terrible autocorrect, and there's no editing allowed. Therefore, mistakes I didn't even write get in, which is why a lot of my posts have a bunch of typos. Sorry

 

[Takhisis]

Well, I guess I'm sorry that I don't like to make wild accusations willy nilly.

Returne to them fires o' IOT whence ye camest, evil fiend!

 

[Xym]

Re - iPads, it is okay.

I am less convinced of Omega's mafia-ness, with the more substantial post #435 and SK does bring up a good enough point.

I would like to clarify the three leans I have are not a team together. I have been unable to see connections this game thus far. Apologies for not being clear.

As for the GoldenKnight thing, I should have proofread better. At this point, I believe it is not a good point either way alignment-wise, however your explanation makes sense to me.

I do as well, however with it being so close it is difficult to read those with little content as town or mafia and as you said before (which I agree with), it is difficult to lynch them without taking chances. I would very much like to hear more from them.

I do not believe we understood each other on the hypocrisy. I apologize.

The point on your potential partners is true.

I will Unvote; Vote: KingMorgan for now.

I think vote: Omega124 is a good choice, but I could also very easily lynch BSmith and Mat93.

I must have missed, but why could you lynch these people?

 

[Kennigit]

what's an ipad?

most of my posts I shout at Gus the local reporter to transcribe and send to the presses


granted I always say Gus has two bad ears and nothing in between, maybe I should stop using him

 

[Takhisis]

Kennigit, them outatowners seems ta be postin' from cellphones.