• We are currently performing site maintenance, parts of civfanatics are currently offline, but will come back online in the coming days. For more updates please see here.

Gnoles?

Kyriakos

Creator
Joined
Oct 15, 2003
Messages
78,122
Location
The Dream
One of my favorite works by Lord Dunsany is the one titled "How Nuth Would Have Practiced His Art Upon The Gnoles". In that story the Gnoles are some sort of forest creature, sentient, living in a building they created, sinister and reclusive, keeping away from sight and horribly fatal to any human that may try to march into its abode.

I would like to ask if anyone here is aware of the history of that term. It seems Dunsany created it in that form, but i suppose there were influences for his idea. Was there any kind of folklore in England on which this creature could have been based upon? Dunsany wrote in the late 19th century and early part of the 20th century, and was a notable influence on Lovecraft, as well as many later fantasy authors.

18th_early_6.jpg
 
I hate them. They kidnapped the woman I'm sworn to protect and may or may not be romantically involved with.
 
Denounce my perspective as clouded by white guilt if you must, GS, but I maintain a certain sympathy for them. I mean, given how European imperialism has raped their land and desecrated their culture, should we really fault them for fighting back by what limited means they still possess?
 
It is an alternate spelling of [wiki]gnoll[/wiki], surely.
 
Aw, I had a whole pseudo-intellectual diatribe lined up...
 
And you're not going to post it, Þorwaldr of Lym?
 
Well, since you asked... :love:

"Gnole", or its modern spelling, "gnoll", is a pejorative term originally referring to a specific African shamanist cult, but that has since expanded into a general slur. Its first written reference occurs in Lord Dunsany's short story, "How Nuth Would Have Practiced His Art Upon The Gnoles" (1912), and reappears in Margaret St. Clair's "The Man Who Sold Rope to the Gnoles" (1951). The word is believed to derive from the Middle English noll, meaning an idiot or drunkard. In both stories, the gnoles are portrayed as shady and sub-human (indeed, in the latter they are not human at all), physically removed from civilized English society, dwelling in a freakish fantasy realm: "the trees themselves were a warning," they "did not wear the wholesome look of those that we plant ourselves" (Dunsany). St. Clair describes their domain as "the very edge of Terra Cognita" in what is clearly an allusion to the 'black continent' stereotype. In both stories, the Europeans cheat these 'lesser' people out of valuable resources: St. Clair's protagonist Mortensen barters rope for precious gems, and Nuth and Tonkers seek to rob the gnoles of emeralds—recall, earlier in the story, mention of valuables that Parisian jewellers "could not match [...] without sending specially to Africa" (Dunsany).

Dunsany evidently never travelled to the continent he wrote about, since the physical description of the gnoles themselves is non-existent; a good literary technique for instilling anxiety and apprehension, but a complete disservice to the historical record. St. Clair is little better, describing them as "a little like a Jerusalem artichoke made of India rubber", with no ears, an anteater-like face, and eyes quite literally resembling gemstones. A much more accurate depiction of the cult comes courtesy of Professor Gareth Gygax, who compiled the first detailed overview in 1977, drawing largely on folktales and personal accounts from regional inhabitants. The "gnolls" themselves (as Gygax spells the term) were apparently either human volunteers in or spiritual manifestations resulting from an animist ritual to aid the tribe in times of war: the end product was what can best be described as "were-hyenas". Unfortunately, even as late as the 1970s, racial prejudice persisted in mainstream academic circles; either as a result of unreliable sources or a personal agenda, Gygax's original compendium and the scholarship that followed it perpetuate the same fear-mongering and sense of White moral superiority as St. Clair and Dunsany's stories: the gnolls are portrayed as savage, sadistic, and inherently chaotic, worshiping a demonic god named Yeenoghu that is completely unknown to indigenous spiritual traditions. Gygax even draws upon St. Clair's prose in his description of gnoll physiology, describing their eyes as blood-red just as she did (admittedly, given the popularity of red eyes as a mark of the demonic, this may be sheer coincidence).

Dissenting schools of thought do exist, and have attempted to rehabilitate the cult's image. St. Clair even offers a slim window for sympathy within her story: Mortensen's death occurs largely by accident, the tragic result of the arrogant European's insensitivity to local culture. Unfortunately, the cult itself is believed to have gone extinct some time during the former half of the Twentieth Century, and thus a truly accurate account of its history and beliefs may be impossible.
 
Funny, I'd never known about the African connection.
 
Aye, its colonialist roots tend to be overlooked even by its own scholarship. It also didn't help that Gygax's alternative spelling further obscured the word's origin; so when a series of adventure role-playing games used his work as inspiration, pop-culture thought it was some made-up fantasy name and all bets were off.
 
I first read the word in the St. Clair story, then a few years later playing WarCraft III. I didn't make the connection at the time.

This reminds of the origin of a South American word for the Devil: 'Mandinga' (mostly used in the River Plate basin). It comes from the name of the Mandinka people in western Africa as far as I can tell, but I'm not sure whether it was used by their enemies, or by themselves, or what. As the yellow fever eliminated most of the formerly enslave black population in the eighteenth century, no one recalls the origin of the name anymore, and, also, idiotical political correctness makes this harder to find or discuss.
 
Thank you both for the information :) Particularly Thorvald with his mico-diatribe on the Gnoles :)

The story by Dunsany is great, in my view, and the mood is excellent in the forest of the shadowy Gnoles.
 
Back
Top Bottom