HOF Version 3 - "Test Run"

GPS

East Pacific:
IJN DD Ushio sinks US sub
IJN CL Nagara sinks US sub
IJN Val Bomber sinks US sub

Wake Island:
IJN I-boat sinks US Allied Transport
IJN CA sinks US BB Colorado

Vladivostoc:
IJA Army kills Inf Div
City captured

Ceylon:
IJA 14th Army kills CW Static Defense, Flak and Militia
City captured

Mandalay:
IJA Inf Div kills CW Inf Div
IJA Inf Div killed by CW 14th Army

Bay of Bengal:
IJN CA Mogami sinks CW CL Enterprise

Ichang:
IJA Inf Div kills MA CID
City captured
IJA Inf Div kills MA Cannon
IJA Inf Div kills MA Militia
worker captured

Around Chihkiang:
Shot down two fighters

Hanoi:
IJA Inf div kills MA CID
 
Semental,

I hope I didn't give you the wrong impression with my comment. For the record..I thought your viewpoint was reasonable and certainly worth throwing it out for discussion. I just thought that Eric needed to evaluate as he has. As I posted, my only concern was in making a change "midstream". I think Eric's view of adding Benghazi to the Exception List makes very good sense! So...Well DOne Semental!

Sully
 
I have no objection to giving up Benghazi to the Minor Axis. After the early loss of the North-African Army I have no forces left there to protect it (and certainly can't spare any reinforcements from elsewhere...). At the moment it is only getting into That-Guy's and semental's way, so in my opinion it makes sense to give it to Minor Axis.

Perhaps they can do a better job of protecting the poor North-African people from exploitation by the evil imperialistic British Empire! :D

Anyone against it?

Lanzelot
 
Lanz..yes in the middle of a game. That's not the time to make rule changes even if they make sense. Now, if you want to start a new game with revisions...I'm ok with that! After all..this is a Play Test game for Eric to see how changes affect gameplay. By all means..Let's call a Draw :)

Sully
 
aksully said:
Lanz..yes in the middle of a game. That's not the time to make rule changes even if they make sense.
Click to expand...

But the .sav that I just got from Knutis had Benghazi already assigned to MinorAxis?! (I guess semental took Eric's comment as "yes" and then sent the turn where he had accepted the town on to muzbang.)

This means we have two options:
  • Either semental has to send the other .sav, where he didn't take the town, on to muzbang, and then muzbang, Knutis and me have to replay (which is bad, because I just spend 1.5 hours on it this morning)
  • Or we decide that semental just gifts the town back to me next turn and no harm has yet been done?!

I will post my battle report, after we made that decision. (In any case I would hate to replay this turn: it was a lot of tedious micro management and worker mm...)

Lanzelot
 
Well look..it seems to take forever to get one complete turn done in a speedy timeframe so probably not worth sweating it at this point. I don't care at this point. But that is just my take. I would suggest from here on out that we stick with guidelines we have. But that doesn't mean not bringing up stuff as the game goes along. Hope that makes sense to all. Play On!

Sully
 
While major construction work has been done on the home-front and in the factories, the frontline saw no large scale fighting this month. Both sides seem to regroup and recover from the previous blows.

A Submarine sinks US Carrier in the Atlantic.
Bombardment of Moscow area. Tank kills Cav division.
 
aksully said:
Semental,

I hope I didn't give you the wrong impression with my comment. For the record..I thought your viewpoint was reasonable and certainly worth throwing it out for discussion. I just thought that Eric needed to evaluate as he has. As I posted, my only concern was in making a change "midstream". I think Eric's view of adding Benghazi to the Exception List makes very good sense! So...Well DOne Semental!

Sully
Click to expand...

No, I hope That-Guy does not take any offense as I did raze him a bit. It was all meant in fun. It is a short turn and easy to re-do it without harm.

I sent Muzbang both plays so I am not sure which went forward.

It is difficult to handle this in a game as this. Resource sharing is certainly valid to a degree that it does not exceed what would take place. I do not think Bengazi needs to be a special case but if a contested city is undefended and uncaptured then it should be available for control switch. How do you do that I am not sure.
 
Lanzelot said:
But the .sav that I just got from Knutis had Benghazi already assigned to MinorAxis?! (I guess semental took Eric's comment as "yes" and then sent the turn where he had accepted the town on to muzbang.)

This means we have two options:
  • Either semental has to send the other .sav, where he didn't take the town, on to muzbang, and then muzbang, Knutis and me have to replay (which is bad, because I just spend 1.5 hours on it this morning)
  • Or we decide that semental just gifts the town back to me next turn and no harm has yet been done?!

I will post my battle report, after we made that decision. (In any case I would hate to replay this turn: it was a lot of tedious micro management and worker mm...)

Lanzelot
Click to expand...

I sent both turns on but it may not have been clear to Muzbang.

Sorry for mucking the turn up.
 
Yes, i've received 2 files... and i've played the first... so i may be the guilty.
I though it was the same...............

tell me if we have to re-play it
 
I'm wondering, does Formosa count as one of the Japanese home islands, or do I have to ship the oil up to Okinawa? So far I've been taking it to Okinawa.
 
Aug 1942

Tula Liberated!
Tula bombarded by 6 FA, 4 Db, 2 MB
Kalinin Front (9/11) destroys 22nd Panzer div and 1 FD
Rifle army (5/5) kills FD
Rifle army (4/5) kills Inf Div
Rifle army (2/3) kills FA

West of Moscow: LT tank (2/4) kills Flak

N of Leningrad: FA damages Finn 5th div (4/5)

Bucharest- Odessa road cut by DD

Far East:
Peking - Suchow road cut by MB
Peking - Mukden RR damaged by MB
 
semental said:
No, I hope That-Guy does not take any offense as I did raze him a bit. It was all meant in fun. It is a short turn and easy to re-do it without harm.

I sent Muzbang both plays so I am not sure which went forward.

It is difficult to handle this in a game as this. Resource sharing is certainly valid to a degree that it does not exceed what would take place. I do not think Bengazi needs to be a special case but if a contested city is undefended and uncaptured then it should be available for control switch. How do you do that I am not sure.
Click to expand...

Not at all. I understand why you want it, but I hope you understand why I think its best if it stays unavailable for you to capture ;)
 
As we are playing the wrong turn I will give Benghazi back the way I found it. I will put the troops mostly back where they came from.
 
CW Aug 1942 GPS

Operation Amputee cripples German war effort!

Didn't take any action in Egypt this turn due to the mix up.

Home Front:
-Antwerp
Dover guns makes Inf Corp 4/5.
Naval bombardment makes 2/5.
DB destroys military AF.
Marine Corp kills Inf Corp 4/6.
Marine Corp kills Id 2/6.
Marine Div kills flak 3/4.

Antwerp Captured

Marine Corp kills ID 1NW of Antwerp
43rd ID kills coastal guns 4/4.

-Hamburg
Sherman Firefly Div kills Militia 3/4 destroys me109

Hamburg Captured

-Rostock
55th W Lanc Div captures rostock undefended. 3/3.

-Berlin
Flak shoots down HB
MB kills citizens
HB damages me109
Army (2 Sherman Firefly Divs) kills ID
Army kills flak me109 destroyed. 9/9.

Berlin captured. Capital moves to Kiev.

-Koln
56th Inf Div kills flak me109 destroyed 4/5.

Koln captured

-Salzburg
76th ID captures Salzburg undefended.

Salzburg captured.

-Kiel
CW DD destroys coastal fortress.
DD makes Coastal guns 3/4.
DD makes 2/4.
9th Scottish kills coastal guns. 4/4.
44th Inf Div kills Flak. 2/3.

Kiel captured.


Army kills border guard 1SW of Hamburg.

N Africa:
-Oran
Naval bombardment destroys Biplane and me109.
DB makes Inf Corp 2/4.

Lanc destroys road with rubber 1E of Thessaloniki.

SE Asia:
HB redlines ID 2N of Mandalay
MB destroys road 3S of Mandalay

S Pacific:
No Action
 
Captured undefended - Salzburg, Berlin, Rostock, Hamburg

Koln lost MD tank before killing the CW56th ID with one. Captured.

Near Hamburg an MD tank lost to 55th Lanc ID before the Vichy IC kills it (4/5)

Antwerp Siena ID lost to CW Marine Div 3/4

Batumi - Bombed - plane damaged Granary destroyed.

Tobruk - Shelled - ships damaged, Bombing kills citizens and granary. An MD Bomber lost to AA.

Leningrad - shelled fortress.

All cities returned to original owner.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Recursive
  • Locked
New BETA Version - 4.17.8 (December 16, 2024)
5 6 7
Replies
131
Views
26K
Recursive
Recursive
Recursive
  • Locked
New BETA Version - 4.10 (June 25, 2024)
6 7 8
Replies
148
Views
30K
Recursive
Recursive
hokath
Hokath's Changes
8 9 10
Replies
190
Views
34K
hokath
hokath
Recursive
  • Locked
New Version - 4.2.7 (October 30, 2023)
16 17 18
Replies
350
Views
72K
andersw
A
Recursive
  • Locked
New Version - 3.7.12 (August 4, 2023)
13 14 15
Replies
283
Views
58K
Recursive
Recursive
Back
Top Bottom