How did they find out you can't breathe in space?

Joined
Dec 31, 2000
Messages
1,174
Location
Back in the village
This question occured to me while watching an episode of Star Trek: Voyager. How did they ever find out that you can't breathe in space? How did they find out what happens?
I've asked this question to a mate, and he thought that was a damn good question.
 
Well they knew there wasn't any atmosphere up there, and quite obviously you can't breath if there's no atmosphere.
 
well, since "space" is empty, there isnt anything you can breathe in when you exhale. I see it similar to drowning, when you "dry drown" and your lungs are empty and sealed and you simply suffocate.

But since it is a vacuum, its being pulled out.
 
Observable fact 1: There is no air in space.
Observable fact 2: You breathe air.

Logical conclusion: You can't breathe in space.

You don't have to actually try things to know they're true.
 
Darn, you're disillusioning me! OK, in a Sci-Fi film I saw the head of a person exploding because her spacesuit ripped. Is that fiction or based on facts?
 
That's true enough. Since there's no air in space, there is no air pressure, so your internal hydrostatic pressure which normally prevents you from being crushed by the atmosphere actually blows you apart.
 
I'm guessing the hard way... ;)
 
i'd figure that at some point they threw a monkey out the spaceship window to make sure that all that theory about "breathing air" and "no air in space" was correct.
ofcourse maybe that's the evolutionary step between monkeys and humans.
i assume there's been someone who's gone up in space and had a spacesuit problem and died from suffication, though you'll never know cause all that stuff gets covered up by the respective governments.
 
Halcyon said:
Observable fact 1: There is no air in space.
Observable fact 2: You breathe air.

Logical conclusion: You can't breathe in space.

You don't have to actually try things to know they're true.
:lol:
I just imagine the poor mouse being sent out of the shuttle by minus -100 degrees and exploding in the space. And then, the astronaut saying : "Ok... it's proven we can't breathe in space".
 
the mormegil said:
The same happens if you bring up deep deep water fish up to the surface. *splat*

Ok, that was a bit cruel! Now you gave me an urge to bring a deep water fish up to the surface....
 
Stefan Haertel said:
This question occured to me while watching an episode of Star Trek: Voyager. How did they ever find out that you can't breathe in space? How did they find out what happens?
I've asked this question to a mate, and he thought that was a damn good question.

Simple and known far before space travel. The farther they got from sea level wether hiking in the mountains or flying at high altitudes it became harder to breathe just to name an obvious reason.
 
They could have figured it out in Newton's time by looking at the escape velocity (i.e. the speed required to break free of the Earth's gravity) of oxygen and thinking, hmm, that's a bit quick, eh? Dunno if they did that though, since the mass of oxygen wasn't worked out yet (?). 1800's at least, they could've done it.
 
This is from Bad Astronomy under his bit about the movie Mission to Mars

The human body holds a lot of heat, and it would take a long time to freeze. Have you ever found yourself literally freezing solid when you go outside on a winter's day? No, of course not. Yet losing heat by transferring it to cold air is far faster than doing so by simply radiating it away, as you would in space. If it takes a long time in frigid air, it would take even longer in frigid space.

His face would not get icky, either; at least, not right away. There is no air in space. Despite what movies like ``Outland'' would have you believe, you wouldn't explode if exposed to space. The air would rush out of your lungs explosively, which could damage your lungs and throat. But your skin and vascular system would contain your blood fairly well, protecting it against the vacuum, so your blood would not boil. After a long time, the cells would freeze, and the expanding ice crystals (water expands when it freezes) would rupture the cells, making you look a pretty good mess. But that would take hours, or longer, not seconds. Oddly though, a human can survive several seconds of pure vacuum. ``2001: A Space Odyssey'' had a scene like this; the astronaut had to go from his pod to the airlock without his helmet. I don't think he would look as nicely coiffed after the incident as he did in the movie, but the scene was largely accurate. Ironically, as Arthur C. Clarke has pointed out, in Earth orbit, your biggest problem is sunburn! Exposure to the UV light of the Sun would fry your skin in minutes, giving you a very bad sunburn.
 
Lakuta, assuming you're thinking of the first dog in space, died up there. The Russians never had any sort of plan for bringing down safely, it was simply a test to see if something could live up there at all.
 
Back
Top Bottom