(IS THIS A BUG) Original Cities Requesting to Join Another Civ

[Koenig]

In my current game (marathon) I have at least two of my cities, which I built with my settlers, requesting to join another civ as if they were conquered cities. In one case a city I built on a small island is requesting to rejoin the Chinese, my vassal. In another case a city I built on former Roman land (neutral at the time because I razed everything to the ground) is requesting to rejoin the Romans, also my vassal.

Another Issue in this Particular Game
In the year 1995, out of nowhere, I get a first time greeting message from Darius who heretofore I've not seen at all nor can I spot where he is on the map. A colony the AI created?

Save attached. If you need the city names in question I'll have to get back in game and write them down and post back here.

 

[ERLoft]

Yep, I get those too. Pretty funny that in my current game, Conventry is only 10 or so tiles removed from my capital, yet every so often they request to join my neighbor Russian vassal. Same for a couple of my other cities. I'm not sure it's a bug, but it is kind of annoying to regularly have to deny their request to leave my country.

As to the second bit, yes, that'd be an AI created colony. They do it too. In my current game Augustus Caesar has created a vassal - Julius Caesar!

Then again, the vassal I created (I'm Churchill) was Roosevelt!

 

[H&K]

It is a bug. I wouldnt mind so much if the city that "wants to Join Colony" acualy had any % of that nationality I regualy get cities that I culture bloomed on the Boarders asking to join a nation that are not at all.
Maybe in these situations a message on the lines of below would be better

Your domestic Minister thinks it would greatly benifet both Nations, if City X was allowed to Join your Vassal Nation Y

 

[ainwood]

Can you please provide city names? Although I'm inclined to say "not a bug". I checked a few cities, and they do have significant foreign culture / nationality. I think that 'spread culture' espionage missions can affect this.

 

[CloudedSun]

This may also be the domestic advisor being over-enthusiastic. The same one who regularly tells you to build granaries, or universities, or whatever.

I think it has to do with the fact that any city reasonably close to one of your vassals can be liberated to them, regardless of culture. It's how you can expand one of your colonies. Trouble is the domestic advisor always pops up telling you about this. I normally just turn it off.

 

[DemonMaster]

I played RTW the other day and after a while Wake, Midway and Pearl Harbour all wants to join france.

If you skip the game technique behind this and think of the story here, they rather belong to France that have lost everything but one city in southern pacific than me that have only lost one city (Guam).

 

[Koenig]

Can you please provide city names? Although I'm inclined to say "not a bug". I checked a few cities, and they do have significant foreign culture / nationality. I think that 'spread culture' espionage missions can affect this.

Lets look at this one city which is the first one to exhibit this behavior: Izmir. It is on a small island south of the Ottoman mainland. The only other city on this island is owned by the Mayans. The Mayans also have a couple of other cities near by also on small islands. I checked a 1846 save which is close to the time I settled Izmir. It is 100% Ottoman yet within a very few turns of planting it was requesting to join the Chinese. In the save I uploaded it is 69% Ottoman and 39% Mayan yet it still requests to join the Chinese. Got to be a bug.

 

[ainwood]

Well, more saves would help - especially ones which show the requests to revolt.

I'll make it as 'is this a bug', but without saves, it might be hard to demonstrate anything conclusive.

 

[Chaos_BF1942]

Well, more saves would help - especially ones which show the requests to revolt.

I'll make it as 'is this a bug', but without saves, it might be hard to demonstrate anything conclusive.

I don't have a save, but I had afew cities that want to join my Japanese vassal, and when the French caputred one of my minor island cities (Buffalo), when I took it back it asked me if I want to liberated it to the Japanese, I build that city there around 400+ years ago and had no Japanese culture (that I could see). It seem to be random, so would probably be hard to get a save with them asking to revolt.