Large Mafia Game- The Dinner Party

Why would Seon be wogged? He voted for Kennigit yesterday.

You have to be missing several votes in a row for me to consider wogging.
 
Why would Seon be wogged? He voted for Kennigit yesterday.

You have to be missing several votes in a row for me to consider wogging.

I believe that vote for Kennigit was his first vote all game.
 
So... Seon is active enough to stay un-Woged? :(
Unvote; vote: Seon
 
okay srsly jarrema.

What a deep reason!
FoS: Mechaerik
now, this is in a response to an early on vote by mechaerik. Nothing really in and of itself.
So, there are two weak reasons for voting for bestrfcplayer...
First, what Joecoolio wrote.
Second, bestrfcplayer is jumping into reason-less bandwagon.
So, vote: bestrfcplayer

yeesh. Namedrop #1. Let's look at what snrub thinks.


Maybe there are two mafia teams? and one of them did not sent night order?
or maybe there is a SK, or a vigilante on the town side? And he decided not to kill this night?
Or maybe two killers chose the same target?
or second target was protected?
or...

possibilities are almost limitless

Not really. This is just misleading people.

Yeah, I think so. But we don't have too much traces to analyze
Misleading any vanilla--he is still hinting there are even traces to analyze. This is after Nictel says jarrema's analysis (previous post) is a bit much.

I still believe, as I have from the start, that the mafia will try to interject little misleading posts here and there. I mean, a mafia could just lurk the entire game and send in orders during the night, but I think some players respect that it would just make the game not very fun. I think some of the mafia would feel obligated to post, and some would avoid bandwagons as that is the most obvious way of getting exposed. So, the result is little misleading posts scattered about.

Who knows. Maybe the mafia know why the meals are broken up as it is, or what is "really" going on. But no vanilla townie is ever going to know why without either more clear hints in the updates or some power townie role talking. A vanilla townie has no reason to analyze anything.

I would like to hear Choxorn defense, as well as GamezRule opinion

My gosh, namedropping #2 and #3. "Yeah, I don't want to stand out, so I'll hear what other people's opinions are". Both choxorn and Gamezrule were subsequently nightkilled eventually iirc. A mafia would know this and happily try to make a post that emphasizes fighting between townies.

We do not have much clues, so we should not throw away those that we have.
vote: Takhisis

Are you protecting a fellow inactive scum, Jarrema? Or just your ally Skwink Caesar?
This is a little discussion with takhisis, where takhisis is criticising skwink for saying lynch the inactives (since a mafia would just say that). So, jarrema as an active enough scum, is willing to lynch inactives.
Perfect information syndrome?

As I speculated earlier, and as Zack pointed out, there is a lot of other possibilities - SK, vigilante, second mafia family, profesor Avkvaard himself, etc.
Vote: Landlubber

He quoted landlubber here when landlubber says the mafia has two kills and calls Perfect information syndrome. For cereals bro? That isn't hard. And man, name drop #4 "as zack pointed out there are many possibilites". No there really isn't.
So... Seon is active enough to stay un-Woged? :(
Unvote; vote: Seon

Name drop #5 onto Seon. ATPG hasn't really shown any "preference" to WOG or not WOG. I know that is a problem in some games, but ATPG very clearly said the least active person would be wogged each day---1 wog a day at the most (if I am remembering this correctly). Yet he acts as if Seon is getting special treatment.

Autolycus for jumping into silly wagon

Has jarrema made a single post in this thread that isn't "let me very noticeably make a name drop on someone and just hide around".

Jarrema has done made it clear in these posts that he either believes that there are possibilities out there the vanilla townies can "figure out" what is going on (hint: I don't think any vanilla townie can figure out the twist at this point. There is literally no information) or he is just really being a scum.

I just can't see you as a vanilla townie. You name drop on people asking for their opinions or their defense (see choxorn, etc). Any vanilla townie inherently knows there is no defense. The vanilla townies strength is just pure numbers. There is no defense to be made, no real case to make, etc.
 
unvote, vote: Jarrema

Seon still has to go, but that case seriously floats my boat. Vote one or the other, people.
 
The name-dropping is a humongous psychological scum tell. You know your moves are bad, so you make sure you have the cover of a bad-move-making townie or three at all times (and here's the key) that everyone knows it. And you snuggle up to townie opinions. AND YOU VOTE FOR "PIS" -- I swear twice as many scum vote for that as actually commit it.

For a no-reveals game this is an excellent case.
 
My earlier result was a hasty vote when ATPG started looking at his WoG stick, but voting for Jarrema seems like a sensible thing to do now.
 
vote:Kennigit for making a tl;dr post.
 
Is that really the best you can do, Joe?
 
Yup, my argument is no better than anything anyone else has put forward.
 
Okay, then vote:joecoolyo until you make a real case for a vote other than RNG.

Okay.

Takhisis, one cat stew coming right up!
I don't have any connection with Takhisis if that is what you are getting at. I do wish he would put a vote in amongst all the talk as well. But I'd like to know why you think he is worthy of the lynch today when Autolycus would be a good candidate too.
Two votes within twenty minutes? And tying teh vote? Scumwaggoooon!
Well for starters, as I've just said in a different context, I seem to get Autolycus lynched a lot lately, and I'm always wrong. If he's going to be lynched for the next little while, I want someone else to do it. I'm starting to get a complex and I can't even imagine what he must be thinking.
C'mon, there's better reasons than that for a non-Auto vote. In fact, why do you have to clarify at all?
Renata said:
Second, Takhisis' lack of vote today really does puzzle me.
You know I have a life and that I have classes on Fridays.
Renata said:
Third, I challenged him yesterday by MSN over the end-of-day voting from yesterday. I had all three of you, him and Camikaze as mafia together, it was a lovely house of cards. He didn't like it -- DC most scummy of the options (same as you said), of course you and Camikaze wouldn't vote for Camikaze or him, yadda yadda.

But he also didn't like it when I removed him from the picture entirely and suggested just you and Camikaze acting to save Camikaze. If he's mafia and neither of you are, you'd think he'd jump at that idea. So if he is mafia, I think one of you two is as well. But the lynch-pin is Takhisis.
How about lynch-pinious Takhisis not being a scummer at all, period?
Renata said:
Anyway, posts since my last one have changed my mind again. I think I want to go with happy bandwagoner Seon, there. He has six posts this game. Three were prior to a 2-week absence, all were fluff. Then he comments a single time, again fluff, no vote, before disappearing for a further ten days.

During yesterday's phase he made a no-account vote on Kennigit; today he makes one on Takhisis.

Why aren't you dead yet, Seon? You were only a teensy bit more functional than Neverwonagame, but now that WOGs are in play, here you are, voting all of a sudden.

vote: Seon

He needs to go now.
O' course, Seon may be crazy but he aint' silly. He ain't gonna get himself WoG'd if he can help it.
 
Okay, then vote:joecoolyo until you make a real case for a vote other than RNG.

I would make a case, if there were any evidence to base a case on. As of now, there is really nothing.
 
yeah, that is true Joe, and basically what I have said. Hence I think I've been the most consistent person at voting for people for trying to imply there is relevance (attacked people over meals, vigilantes, etc). A vanilla townie simply cannot get any information.

but you surely cannot think I am a scum.
 
So, you vote for someone but you have no evidence to make a case on. Basicaly it's either an RNG vote or you got careless as a scum. I'm not budging.
 
Jarrema 4 (Kennigit, Renata, Arakhor, mechaerik)
taillesskangaru 2 (robbiecon, autolycus)
Nictel 2 (NarutoAvatar, Romanichine)
Takhisis 2 (Seon, BSmith)
BSmith 1 (Camikaze)
robbiecon 1 (taillesskangaru)
Seon 1 (Jarrema)
Yoshiegg 1 (Nictel)
Kennigit 1 (Joecoolyo)
Joecoolyo 1 (Takhisis)
Francis 1 (Winston)



I think this is the tally. Giddy-yup. Here comes the writeup.

Also, those I warned about the WOG voted this round, so no WOGs today. 17/19 voted. Those who didn't vote voted last round, though they'll get prods tomorrow if they don't vote twice in a row.
 
Day Six




Professor Askvaard: "Okay, have we any idea who is guilty?"


Most everyone decided it was a wise idea to point fingers. Unfortunately, the fingers seemed to be pointed in many different directions. There was no consensus.


Professor Askvaard: "Come on, seriously?"


Kennigit: "I think Jarrema did it, and here's why!"


And Kennigit began quoting Jarrema and dissecting his quotes. He finished in authoritative fashion.


Kennigit: "And that, my friends, is how you coax a cat down from the branch of a tree using only a teaspoon of peanut butter and a tinfoil hat!"


Some of the other guests agreed with this attempt at reasoning. Jarrema, however, simply shook his head, and silently accepted his fate.


Askvaard: "Any last words, Jarrema?"


Jarrema: "Nope! I think Kennigit's case speaks for itself. At least now I get to sit down."


Askvaard dropped the prop noose around Jarrema's neck, and playfully gave it a yank, spilling Jarrema's soup on the carpet.


Askvaard: "Now, we shall see if you have caught the dreaded murderers. Everyone, take your places!"








"Alive" - (18/36)

Autolycus- SOUP
Kennigit- SOUP
Nictel- SOUP
Renata- SOUP
robbiecon- SOUP
taillesskangaru- SOUP
Takhisis- SOUP

BSmith- CHICKEN
Mechaerik- CHICKEN
NarutoAvatarDBZ- CHICKEN
Romanichine- CHICKEN
Seon- CHICKEN
Winston Hughes- CHICKEN

Arakhor- BEEF
Camikaze- BEEF
Joecoolyo- BEEF
Save Ferris- BEEF
Yoshiegg737- BEEF



"Dead" - (17/36)

The Bake- BEEF
mgsmuhammed- BEEF
Bestrfcplayer- BEEF

GamezRule- SOUP
Skwink Caesar- CHICKEN
classical_hero- CHICKEN
Choxorn- SOUP
Red_Spy- CHICKEN
CivGeneral- CHICKEN

General Olaf- SOUP
Earthling- CHICKEN
Zack- BEEF
civplayah- SOUP
Darth Caesar- BEEF
johnhughthom- BEEF
landlubber- BEEF

Jarrema- SOUP


Wrath of the party host - (1/36)

Neverwonagame3- CHICKEN





Begin Night Seven
 
Back
Top Bottom