Hi, I played your Two towers scenario and downloaded the other one. I would have preffered the Nazgul to be independent of Mordor, because many people just like going around without having too much of a headache. Its fun to actually watch the war. Can you tell me how I would do this in the editor?
Other than that I played with Isengard and it really was very fun.
I hope eventually people will make more units,etc... for your scenarios. Anyway there is a lot of commonality between the RoTK and TTT. I am not too interested about the Fellowship of the Ring, however if you could do something that involves that huge battle in the beggining of the Fellowship that will be interesting. Is that from the Hobbit or something? I read none of the books.
The hobbits are far too powerful in their fighting capabilities. I suggest you give them other capabilites. Maybe they should be able to see 5 spaces away or something. You might want to integrate the ring in some way. I don't know how good the Civ3 editor is, but with Civ2 you could make something happen when Frodo would die.
Anyway well done, keep updating! (Oh also, loading times are excellent. <1 minute)