M-16 and AK-47

Bugfatty300

Buddha Squirrel
Joined
Dec 26, 2003
Messages
10,368
Location
NC
The M-16 assault rifle

Several years after World War II, a revolution infantry fighting rifles was taking place. The German MP43 had sat new standards for the oncoming assault rifle era. In the mid-1950s, NATO standardized the .308 (7.62x51mm) cartridge the involved nations began developing selective fire weapons that could hold 20 or more rounds such as Spain’s venerable M58, Belgium’s famed FN FAL, Germany's revered G3 and America’s infamous M-14. The Soviet Union, who also retained a 7.62 cartridge, had for some time earlier obtained their own deadly assault rifle, the AK-47.

Early on, it became clear to the U.S. Army that the 7.62x51 was too powerful to be effective in the automatic rifle role and most M-14s were converted to semi-automatic rifles. Painful lessons learned in Korea pressed U.S. Army officials to introduce a new light, accurate rifle capable of a high rate of fire that fired a small high-velocity bullet. The Army’s intentions was not to increase the firepower of individual soldiers but to increase the chances of hitting a target.

In 1957, Eugene Stoner, a skilled engineer who worked for the Armalite aircraft company was hired by the U.S. Army to design and build a light weight .22 caliber rifle to replace the M-14 assault rifle. Stoner had already designed and built the AR-10 rifle to compete with the new series of 7.62 NATO rifles but it his design had come to late and the only country to adopt the AR-10 was Sudan.

Stoner simply converted the existing AR-10 into incorporate the newly developed .223 (5.56x45mm) cartridge and was renamed the AR-15. Prototypes were sent to the Army for testing. After moths of testing the Continental Army Command Board recommended that the AR-15 replace the M-14. How ever the AR-15 was rejected by the Army.

The SAS on the other hand saw the AR-15 as the ideal jungle weapon and adopted it in the early 1960s for use in the Borneo campaign as well as the Oman and Aden operations.

This might have been the end of the M-16 but the sudden increase of U.S. involvement in the Vietnam conflict raised the issue once more. In 1962 several thousand AR-15s were sent to Vietnam to be tested by U.S. Special forces and Air Force guards. They became instantly popular among Americans and Vietnamese who were able to get their hands on one. Field-test results were so impressive that the Secretary of Defense, Robert McNamara ordered 20,000 AR-15s to arm portions of U.S. soldiers and their Vietnamese allies.

Around this time the Armalite sold the manufacturing license to the Colt company which began producing the M-16 for the Armed Services.

From its first introduction into Vietnam in 1962 until 1966 the rifle, now termed the M-16, enjoyed a reputation of an extremely lethal and dependable weapon among the soldiers using it in combat. But in 1966 when 100,000 M-16s were shipped to Vietnam to replace the M-14s being used by the Army and Marines. Reports of jamming and failure began to flood the U.S. Army ordinance department. Most of the rifles were never issued with cleaning kits and at the same the U.S. army changed its cartridge powder to a less clean powder that caused excess fouling and carbon build up. The jamming rifles were blamed on irresponsible soldiers who did not maintain the rifles properly. As simple as these problems and their solutions were, the effects were devastating.

To add to this the chamber of the M-16 had went from chromed to plain steel which caused the most basic jam for M-16. Cartridge casings would become wedged tightly in the chamber of the barrel. This then required the soldier to take a cleaning rod and insert it into the muzzle end of the barrel and force the fired cartridge from the chamber. Then the rifle would fire 2 or 3 more times before the bewildered soldier had to repeat the process. (Fighting a modern war with a muzzle loader! Oh joy!)

Reports of dead soldiers still clutching their jammed M-16 with the cleaning rod shoved down the barrel began reach congress which forced the armed services to take action. The Colt company then began chroming the chambers of the M-16 and a cleaner burning ball powder used in artillery shells replaced the new powder. These modifications apparently did the trick since jam reports all but evaporated. By 1967 and 68 the M-16 the rifle again began to live up to its old reputation of reliability and the malfunctions ceased. New improvements were added and the M-16A1 was created which improved the original M-16.

The M-16 and its cartridge quickly developed a reputation for lethality. This is generally caused by the hypervelocity .223 bullet that exits the muzzle at 3,200 feet per second (fps) or 988 meter per second (mps). The wounds caused to the abdomen and chest create what is known aq hydrostatic shock or hydro shock.

Several versions of the M-16 were produced and tested in Vietnam. The CAR-15 (Later adopted as the M4) was the carbine version of the AR-15. Some M-16s were modified with a 40mm M-203 grenade launcher under the barrel to increase the fire power of the individual soldier. Also issued in the 1970s were the “banana” 30 round magazines to replace the square 20 round magazines. The 30 round magazines had previously been restricted to use by special forces.

The success of M-16 and its new cartridge had a huge effect on the international community. In 1974 the Soviet Union even developed their own version of the 5.56mm. The 5.45x39mm was incorporated it into their new AK-74 rifle which saw extensive use in Afghanistan. In the late 70s NATO replaced the 7.62x51mm with the 5.56x45mm SS109 cartridge.

In 1981 the U.S. army developed the M-16A1E1 (the modern M-16). This was apparently the most successful version. Copies and versions of the M-16A1E1 are in use by the Canadian, Dutch, Kuwaiti, Columbian, Filipino, Danish and Israeli armed forces. Many under the name of the Diemico C7A1 (Canadian M-16A1E1 version). They are also the weapons of choice for the Special Air Services operating in Afghanistan and Iraq.

Further improvements led to the adoption of the M-16A2 in 1985 by the U.S. armed forces and is still the standard American infantry rifle. Further versions include the M-16A3 and M-16EZ.

Like the Soviets with the AK-47, the M-16 can be found in abundance where ever U.S. was politically or militarily involved. This is especially true in South East Asia where the U.S. left behind hundreds of thousands of M-16s to the South Vietnamese government. After the fall of Saigon in 1975, the rifles were scattered across the region. Many have turned up in South and Central America in the hands of leftist guerrillas. Some U.S./Vietnam vintage rifles have even wound up in the hands of both Israeli settlers and Palestinians terrorist in the 1980s. The M-16 has seen action in almost all armed conflicts since 1967. From Angola to the Falklands war, to the Yom Kippur war.

The Cons

The M-16 has several major disadvantages. The .223 bullet is too light for accurate shooting beyond 300 meters. Even the modern M-16s are sometimes susceptible to sand. In 1962 the M-16 was seen as ’too small’ by most soldiers especially compared to the massive M-14. Yet compared today’s generation of assault rifles the M-16 is too big. Almost 40” long. This defect has really made itself felt in Iraq. The M-16 is too big to be used effectively in vehicles and APCs. The M4 Carbine is generally the favored because of its compact size. like-wise the M-16 design is 50 years old and is slowly being fazed out by most developed militaries for more modern assault rifles, such as the Israeli IMI Tavor.
 

Attachments

  • M-16.JPG
    M-16.JPG
    156.2 KB · Views: 1,285
The Russians can lay claim to developing the first true assault rifle over the Germans. The relatively unknown Federov Automat of 1916 was a selective fire shoulder arm of good design and was used by both sides during the Russian revolution but production was ceased under communist rule. During World War II, the Germans had developed a variety of selective fire ’assault rifles.’ The FG42 parachutists rifle, the Stug44, the VG1-5. As well as a new cartridge, the 7.92x33 Kurz. Simply the 7.92x57mm cartridge with a shortened casing. The advancing Red Army noticed the cartridge as well as the new rifles that fired them.

During the war the Soviets hastily developed the SKS and the new 7.62x39mm M1943 cartridge to go with it but it had come to late to see action. The SKS lived a short life in the hands of the Red Army who replaced it with a new rifle designed by a talented soldier/inventor named Mikhail Kalashnikov who came up with the idea while recovering from wounds in a hospital.

The new rifle was named the Kalashnikova Automat model 47 or simply the AK-47. The rifle first went into production in 1949 and entered service with the Soviet military in 1951. It was a robust and highly reliable design. This was greatly due to the fact that Kalashnikov had designed the AK-47 with idea that moving parts should be loosely fitted given more room.

Later the Soviets produced the AKM which was made from stampings rather than the expensive milling for the AK-47. This is the most common version of the AK-47. The soviets also produced the AKS-47 which featured a folding stock.

The AK-47 first saw action during the Eastern European revolts of the 1950s. This is also were the west first became aware of the new weapon. At the time the standard American rifle was still the post-war M-1 Garand. Needless to say the U.S. and the NATO nations viewed the AK-47 with skepticism.

The Soviets strictly withheld the AK-47 from Warsaw Pact nations and their communist allies to the east for some years after it had entered Soviet service. The first foreign copies of the AK-47 were made in China in the late-1950s. 50 million copies and versions of the AK-47 have been produced around the world, in fact very few AK-47s were actually made. Although virtually all developed nations discard the AK-47 in favor of western assault rifles it has become favorite of 3rd world nations, guerilla fighters and terrorists organizations and is still the service rifle of most Eastern European nations.

The first AK-47s began to seep into North Vietnam around the mid-1960s. Before then the North Vietnamese relied on a hodge-podge of vintage Japanese, American, French and old Soviet weapons and the occasionally captured M-16 (when its ammo was readily available.) Most were of inferior Chinese manufacture compared to the higher quality Soviet versions. Yet the North Vietnamese army and Vietcong made good use of them.

In the early 70s, the Soviet Union recognized the effectiveness of the 5.56x45mm cartridge and developed their own, the 5.45x39mm and converted the AKM design to fire it and it was called the AK-74 and replaced the AK-47 as the standard Red Army rifle. The AK-74 had several advantages over the AKM-47. Including modern plastic magazines and improves accuracy. The AK-74 was used extensively in Afghanistan where the 5.45mm quickly earned the name ‘poison bullet’ by Afghan guerillas because of the hydro shock wounds it caused.

In the early 80s, the AKSU-74 was introduced into the Afghanistan conflict. The AKSU is a sized down AK-74 submachine gun or carbine that featured a bell-shaped flash hider.

Countless versions of the AK-47 have been developed in attempts to modernize the aging AK-47 design. The Israeli IMI Galil is a descendant of the AK-47. Further attempts to modernize the AK-47 design include converting some to the 5.56x45mm round such as the Zastava M80 and the Kalashnikov AK-100 series rifles have been pretty successful, greatly increasing the accuracy. The Chinese have even developed a bull-pup version of the AK-47.

The AK-47 is with-out a doubt the most stolen rifle design in history. Millions of AK-47 knock-offs have been made with-out license in countries around the world. A true AK-47. Today In the United States a Romanian SAR imported copy of the AK-47 cost about $200 - $300.

The AK-47 has since become the hands-down symbol of terrorism and 3rd world violence. 56 years after designing the AK-47, Mikhail Kalashnikov expressed his regret when he said that he wished he had invented a lawnmower instead. But maintaining that his intentions were to make Russia a safer place after seeing the horrors done to it during 2nd World War.


The Cons

The AK-47 has several major limitations. The AK-47 is especially susceptible to over-heating in full automatic mode sometimes even in extended semi-automatic mode and has a unusually high rate of ‘cook-offs’ (Chambered rounds that go off because of the over-heating) which can be quite hazardous the person using it. The most serious drawback to the AK-47 is its low muzzle velocity of 2,340 fps. (710 meters per second) This results in a looping trajectory that requires a clumsy adjustment for accuracy at ranges beyond 300 meters. The AK-47 is also a little heavy compared to the M-16 and modern European weapons.
 

Attachments

  • avtoma5[1].jpg
    avtoma5[1].jpg
    86.1 KB · Views: 1,290
Very informative and a nice comparison between the two.
 
I've heard of the AK47 known as the USSR's hand held nuclear weapon. Since WW2 its probably got the distinction of killing the most human beings in the world.
 
Very nicely done. I myself would choose the M-16, I cannot stand the orange color.
 
that XM177 looks an awful lot like the M4 Carbine.

"The CAR-15 (Later adopted as the M4) was the carbine version of the AR-15."

The XM177 was the prototype of the Car-15. So yeah. They are the same gun except for a few minor changes.

But the picture is actually an M4. I couldn't find a very good picture of an original XM177. But they look almost exactly the same.
 
If I had to choose between an AK and a M-16. I would have to with the M-16. As good as the AK-47 is in toughness and ease of use I think its limitations outweigh the M-16s.

The M-16 has a far better balance between reliability, firepower and accuracy.

that XM177 looks an awful lot like the M4 Carbine.

I believe the XM177 was the Vietnam test version of the Colt Commando and the M4.
 
eugene stoner and kalashnikov actually were good friends

what sucks about the m16 is it only operates in burst, thats why the m4 and car15 are gaining in popularity
 
they met after the Cold war to talk about there guns and stoner said that a 10 round mag was good until the AK came out

One things strange about the AK-47
If you went to any south american country dealing with drugs you could be shot at with an Ak-47 used in the Cuban Missle Crisis or Bay of Pigs
 
Good Article and Awesome Pictures. :goodjob:
 
AMAZING article and comparisons!!! :D
One small correction, in Russian it is "Avtomat Kalashnikova" (Kalashnikovs automatic rifle) :).
 
The M16A2, as currently issued to US Marines, is accurate out to 550 meters against point targets (individual people) and to 800m against area targets (vehicles or groups of people. Now that the ACOG sight is being issued, I've heard reports of hits on enemy soldiers at 700 meters using the M-16. Using an M-16 fitted with a heavy, free-floated barrel, and shooting 80 grain match bullets (instead of the 62 grain bullets in the M855 Nato Ball ammo), I've shot accurately at 1000 yards with an M16.

I've never fired the AK-47, but understand it's range is much more limited than the M16's. While I was deployed to Iraq, several of our patrols were shot at, from ranges as close as 50 yards, but no Marines were hit. I attribute this to extremely poor marksmanship skill of Iraqis, rather than a flaw in the AK, though the notch type rear sight and short sight radius on the AK do make it harder to aim precisely. The Iraqis do shoot their AKs into the air a lot, and hit the sky every time, though.

The Marine Corps has decided against the M4, and will instead go with the M16-A4--basically an A2 with a flat-top receiver, and a handguard with modular accessory rails, but retaining the 20" barrel.

DogmaDog
 
Back
Top Bottom