Mafia/NOTW Statistics

[choxorn]

Well, maybe I'm already not following my own arbitrary rules anyway.

I'd say that the Wild Ride type games with a minority townie or 5 townies/2 2-man mafia teams/1 SK weren't really balanced, but this was.

Perhaps I can invoke arbitrary rules, but only when I want to invoke arbitrary rules.

 

[choxorn]

Alright, I'll count KotoR Mafia, even if it is weird.

Now I just need to wade through the mess of replacements in that game...

I'll add it and Starcraft to the database as soon as I have time to.

 

[Takhisis]

What the blazes do you mean it's weird? Is it because I followed Arakhor's spelling and called it a lightsabre?

 

[choxorn]

Waded through all of the Replacemnts and WoG's in KotOR Mafia:

Replacements:
Backwards Logic replaced BigTin
johnhughtom (II) replaced SouthernKing
Beefy replaced Darth Caesar
DaveShack (II) replaced Optical
NinjaCow replaced Visorslash
NinjaCow (II) replaced JR48Fan
SamSniped (II) replaced robbiecon
Gone 3 the Celt (II) replaced Winston Hughes

john, Dave, Sam, Celt, and NinjaCow will all count as their first roles, although for NinjaCow they're both town and for Celt they're both Neutral.

WoG's: Beefy, Xenoneb, dcmort

Mat had the innocent VC in his role PM, so I'll count him as a townie even if he had neutral alignment, and similarly, I'll count BL/BigTin as a neutral.

This leaves me with:

Town: 22 (Zack, choxorn, MartinLuther, mechaerik, BSmith1068, Verarde, Darth Caesar, Beefy187, dcmort93, Double A, Jarrema, Mergle, Mat93, The Black Knigh, Xenoneb, Dumanios, NedimNapoleon, NinjaCow64, Earthling, Visorslash, JR48Fan, johnhughthom)

Neutral: 11 (Buddhafish, BigTin, Backwards Logic, SamSniped, topsecret, bestrfcplayer, Kennigit, Gone 3 the Celt, JoanK, Winston Hughes, DaveShack)

Mafia: 10 (SouthernKing, Dreadnought, classical hero, askthepizzaguy, spaceman98, Red Spy, Optical, atheotes, CivGeneral, robbiecon)

Won: 17 (Zack, choxorn, MartinLuther, mechaerik, BSmith1068, Verarde, Double A, Jarrema, Mergle, Mat93, The Black Knigh, Dumanios, NedimNapoleon, NinjaCow64, Earthling, johnhughthom, Backwards Logic)

Lost: 15 (Buddhafish, SamSniped, topsecret, bestrfcplayer, Kennigit, Gone 3 the Celt, JoanK, DaveShack, Dreadnought, classical hero, askthepizzaguy, spaceman98, Red Spy, atheotes, CivGeneral)

Survived: 9 (mechaerik, Buddhafish, Backwards Logic, BSmith1068, Verarde, topsecret, Jarrema, Mergle, TheBlackKnigh)

Replaced: 8 (BigTin, SouthernKing, Darth Caesar, Optical, Visorslash, JR48Fan, robbiecon, Winston Hughes)

WoG'ed: 3 (Beefy187, Xenoneb, dcmort93)

At least I'm pretty sure that's right.

 

[Takhisis]

Erm… something, although as I fell ill on the same day the game ended I never got round to checking who'd fulfilled their PGs and such, I'll do it as an epilogue at some point. I think.

 

[topsecret]

Erm… something, although as I fell ill on the same day the game ended I never got round to checking who'd fulfilled their PGs and such, I'll do it as an epilogue at some point. I think.

I fulfilled mine

 

[Buddhafish]

As did I.

 

[Takhisis]

I should ask my talley slave Arakhor to do the checking.

 

[Backwards Logic]

Do I win twice for winning with the town and as the top-money earning neutral?

 

[Takhisis]

No, as you only had one VC to fulfil (which you did).

 

[choxorn]

Starcraft Mafia:

Town: 13 (Zack, choxorn, Mat93, topsecret, Buddhafish, NinjaCow64, DaveShack, SamSniped, MartinLuther, spaceman98, GhostWriter16, Jarrema, johnhughthom)

Mafia: 6 (Warman, Gone 3 the Celt, Verarde, BSmith1068, BigTin, Kennigit)

Won: 3 (BSmith1068, BigTin, Kennigit)

Lost: 15 (Warman, Gone 3 the Celt, Verarde, Zack, choxorn, Mat93, topsecret, Buddhafish, NinjaCow64, SamSniped, MartinLuther, spaceman98, GhostWriter16, Jarrema, johnhughthom)

Survived: 2 (Kennigit, Zack)

Replaced: 1 (DaveShack)

 

[JohannaK]

I can give ye the stats for Hypnotoad Mafia..

 

[choxorn]

Very Wild Ride fails the "majority town" thing and doesn't meet any of the exceptions to that rule. I won't count it.

For Hypnotoad:

I think I'll have to call JoanK Neutral, although that was one of the weirdest roles ever.

Although Zack didn't bother to tally it, NinjaCow would have been the final lynch, so I'll count him as dead.

Town: 9 (Buddhafish, MartinLuther, NinjaCow64, Mat93, Jarema, topsecret, azzaman333, BigTin, Dumanios)

Neutral: 1 (JoanK)

Won: 1 (JoanK)

Lost: 9 (Buddhafish, MartinLuther, NinjaCow64, Mat93, Jarema, topsecret, azzaman333, BigTin, Dumanios)

Survived: 7 (JoanK, Buddhafish, MartinLuther, Jarema, topsecret, azzaman333, Dumanios)

 

[Zack]

I think I'll have to call JoanK Neutral, although that was one of the weirdest roles ever.

I have a reputation to maintain here.

 

[choxorn]

And you continue to maintain it, by never running out of weird roles.

 

[Zack]

And you continue to maintain it, by never running out of weird roles.

I could make Zack mafias until the end of time.

 

[JohannaK]

NEUTRAL? Then where's the Mafia?

I WAS MAFIAAAAAAAAA!!!!
I WANNA BE IN THE MAFIA STATS, AND I WANNA HAVE AN 80% WINS. Right now if I were considered Mafia in this game, I'd have 4 games and 75%!

 

[choxorn]

Well, the last time I had a weird role against 9 townies, I counted it neutral, and yours couldn't even kill. I don't really see how I could count you mafia.

Don't worry, you'll get your fifth game as mafia eventually.

 

[JohannaK]

Butbutbut...

YOU ARE A MEANIE MEAN EVIL PERSON!!!!

 

[Earthling]

Verarde should probably count as survived in Starcraft Mafia - that seems consistent with other games. The last death before the end of the game writeup was the lynch of johnhughthom.