Zack
99% hot gas
What are the odds?
Mafia/NOTW Statistics
- Thread starter choxorn
- Start date
If you keep behaving like Pete, I'll keep behaving like Ben.
Ow, my eyes!
vote: Tak
edse
King
Technically the same.
It is actually (the same)2
Zack
99% hot gas
Something that's bugging me -- why is A Long Story counted in all statistics, but None Shall Pass isn't?
Yeah, my standards can be a bit weird sometimes- I think my reasoning there was that It's A Long Story had 11 neutral teams that were all about similar in size and power, while None Shall Pass had basically two town teams and two mafia teams, all of which had to eliminate each other.
Zack
99% hot gas
Wouldn't that be in favor of NSP being counted and A Long Story not? 
The thing is, to deal with all the Wild Ride type games, I one point decided that the town faction + neutral factions that could win with the town had to form the majority, and at some other point, I decided that split town games where multiple townie factions had to completely destroy each other and couldn't win with each other (not like Spaceballs or NOTW 42, where the townie factions were sort of opposed but could still sort of win together) shouldn't count both teams as being town when townies normally share a victory condition with all other townies- either they all win, or they all draw, or they all lose.
I could count it as an all-neutral game, but like I said, the only way I'll count an all-neutral game is if all of the neutral factions are similarly structured (like It's A Long Story, or like Court of the Momus where everyone was on their own).
I could count it as an all-neutral game, but like I said, the only way I'll count an all-neutral game is if all of the neutral factions are similarly structured (like It's A Long Story, or like Court of the Momus where everyone was on their own).
Zack, you need to learn to focus:Wouldn't that be in favor of NSP being counted and A Long Story not?
Disregard everything else.
I was waiting a while to add things to to the queue because KingMorgan kept saying he was going to get stuff for Hymn of Hot and Cold that I needed to count it- I think I've waited long enough for him. I officially declare that game not counted.
Working on The Immortals II now.
Working on The Immortals II now.
What I currently have for Mass Effect.
Visorslash, Takhisis, and KingMorgan count for their first roles (though, other than for Visorslash, the result would be Town/Lost/Didn't Survive Regardless).
Town: 22 (Askthepizzaguy, Autolycus, azzaman333, choxorn, CivGeneral, Daird, Double A, e350tb, edse, Jarrema, Kennigit, KingMorgan, MartinLuther, Mat93, mechaerik, Red Spy, SouthernKing, Sprig, Takhisis, TaliZorah, Visorslash, Yaropolk)
Mafia: 4 (BSmith1068, Frozen In Ice, spaceman98, Winston Hughes)
Won: 4 (BSmith1068, Frozen In Ice, spaceman98, Winston Hughes)
Lost: 22 (Askthepizzaguy, Autolycus, azzaman333, choxorn, CivGeneral, Daird, Double A, e350tb, edse, Jarrema, Kennigit, KingMorgan, MartinLuther, Mat93, mechaerik, Red Spy, SouthernKing, Sprig, Takhisis, TaliZorah, Visorslash, Yaropolk)
Survived: 6 (BSmith1068, Frozen In Ice, Jarrema, spaceman98, TaliZorah, Winston Hughes)
Replaced: 3 (MartinLuther, Mat93, SouthernKing)
I'm not sure if the final night mattered, though, or if the mafia were guaranteed a win after they went into the night with 4 mafia and 5 townies- but among the townies was a roleblocker and a role that could make itself invulnerable, so it looks like it might have still mattered, at least a little bit.
Zack, what can you tell me about this?
Visorslash, Takhisis, and KingMorgan count for their first roles (though, other than for Visorslash, the result would be Town/Lost/Didn't Survive Regardless).
Town: 22 (Askthepizzaguy, Autolycus, azzaman333, choxorn, CivGeneral, Daird, Double A, e350tb, edse, Jarrema, Kennigit, KingMorgan, MartinLuther, Mat93, mechaerik, Red Spy, SouthernKing, Sprig, Takhisis, TaliZorah, Visorslash, Yaropolk)
Mafia: 4 (BSmith1068, Frozen In Ice, spaceman98, Winston Hughes)
Won: 4 (BSmith1068, Frozen In Ice, spaceman98, Winston Hughes)
Lost: 22 (Askthepizzaguy, Autolycus, azzaman333, choxorn, CivGeneral, Daird, Double A, e350tb, edse, Jarrema, Kennigit, KingMorgan, MartinLuther, Mat93, mechaerik, Red Spy, SouthernKing, Sprig, Takhisis, TaliZorah, Visorslash, Yaropolk)
Survived: 6 (BSmith1068, Frozen In Ice, Jarrema, spaceman98, TaliZorah, Winston Hughes)
Replaced: 3 (MartinLuther, Mat93, SouthernKing)
I'm not sure if the final night mattered, though, or if the mafia were guaranteed a win after they went into the night with 4 mafia and 5 townies- but among the townies was a roleblocker and a role that could make itself invulnerable, so it looks like it might have still mattered, at least a little bit.
Zack, what can you tell me about this?
Zack
99% hot gas
I believe what you have listed is correct.
