Mars Attacks!! The Mafia Game

I do agree that sprig seemed to do alot in the beginning but none of it has ever been confirmed

I'll Vote: Sprig to add to the pressure to reveal his source of bad info

You both should have worked out which character I am right? I have made it clear early on that I had been in contact with 3 different prophets (4 on the second night).

You both know that the Mafia desperately want me killed since I am in the best position of collate information and therefore, If you are trying to start a bandwagon against me, you look like scum.

It was obviously clear to almost everybody that there had to be some false prophet amongst them in a mafia game this size, it was unfortunate that roman had to be used to test the reliablity of the prophets but so it was needed.

As for the False prophet, it is our Lt General friend that happens to be a little nuke crazy. I ask him to reveal himself publically or else I will have no choice but do it myself.
 
Read the thread.
I have. You didn't say anything in-thread about outing your false prophet/Martian since saying this on page 8:
Well that is dissappointing but after my conversations with Roman not alltogether unexpected. :sad:

Now it is time to question the validity of a certain scanner.

I wanted an explanation of why you didn't appear to be making an effort to do anything about a potential Martian, who claims to be a scanner. How long will you wait until you out your false prophet/Martian yourself?
 
I have. You didn't say anything in-thread about outing your false prophet/Martian since saying this on page 8

Why do you assume that false prophet = Martian?

I wanted an explanation of why you didn't appear to be making an effort to do anything about a potential Martian, who claims to be a scanner. How long will you wait until you out your false prophet/Martian yourself?

If I knew that the false prohet was potentially a Martian I would have done something more about it (other than what I have already done in the background). But as it stands he is less likely to be a martian compared to others such as yourself.
 
Why do you assume that false prophet = Martian?
The backslash means "or", not "is equal to". With the small amount of information you have given us, there is no way to determine if your source is a false prophet or a Martian, so I included both of the known possibilities when referring to your source.
 
The backslash means "or", not "is equal to". With the small amount of information you have given us, there is no way to determine if your source is a false prophet or a Martian, so I included both of the known possibilities when referring to your source.

But what do you want to know? you want to test him by lynch to see if he is martian or not?
 
But what do you want to know? you want to test him by lynch to see if he is martian or not?
All I need to know is that something is being done about this issue. I brought attention to it because I noticed that you had not mentioned it since the beginning of yesterday.

If you don't mind me asking: if this guy is a false prophet, does that mean his result is always guilty or that it is always the opposite of the true result? If it's the latter, then he's as good as a real investigator now that we know that he's a false prophet.
 
All I need to know is that something is being done about this issue. I brought attention to it because I noticed that you had not mentioned it since the beginning of yesterday.

If you don't mind me asking: if this guy is a false prophet, does that mean his result is always guilty or that it is always the opposite of the true result? If it's the latter, then he's as good as a real investigator now that we know that he's a false prophet.

We belive that he is mad (based on his character) and all hits are false positive. but we are not sure. We can't be sure unless another prophet scans a martian at the same time. So far all his results have come up as a threat to national Security.
 
Well if he really is a false prophet then he is of no use to us anyways

So let me get this straight, you are happy to lynch an innocent because he is no use to you?

Should we lynch you because you are no use to us? in fact you are at the moment more dangerous to us than anyone else because at the moment you are voting to lynch me. Who happens to be the closest thing to a confirmed townie we have.

You seem far too comfortable with that.
 
remake20 4 (Darth Caesar; link16; landlubber; dcmort93; johnhughthom; Reiser; Firestorm; choxorn)
Takhisis 1 (Autolycus)
sprig 1 (remake20)
Autolycus 1 (Takhisis)
link16 4 (sprig; musical-mafia; classical_hero; Arakhor)
civplayah 1 (Winston Hughes)
johnhughthom 2 (Nictel; Kennigit)

Abstain (civplayah; Love; robbiecon; Cull)

GM - can you clarify that this is correct and that there hasn't been a mistake? I don't want to to start making assumptions based on somthing that is incorrect. I want to highlight this again because I think there needs clarification .

If we assume that this table is correct. Then we have to assume that my vote was nullified somehow or someone is able to manipulate other peoples votes.

If someone is able to manipulate votes then you should be careful how you vote.

Also I want to point out that both landlubber and dcmort93 have failed to vote townlike twice.
 
Unvote Vote: Abstain and in any mafia game there are townies that don't vote like a townie because everyone is going to have a differing opinion on who they think is innocent or not
 
Nonono dcmort-- I think we have a very good list of landlubber/johnhughthom/civplayah/you that we can be testing one by one. So far the defenses have been

"I never survive until the end (which frustrates many mafia players, but unfortunately has no relevance to an individual game at one particular time; no defense)"

"you're consistent in voting Kennigit (no defense)"
and "I made a mistake (no defense)."

Everyone makes mistakes in voting, but the point of voting to lynch is to get you to make testable claims/connections. Force someone else to defend you or you to do something about it. Best example I have is the beatles mafia game, where like second day I bandwagoned vote with someone who was mafia; I got lynched for it as an innocent.

If you have a bland vanilla role and you die, then so be it. Vanilla innocents rarely effect the game in my experience, except for the mass lukrers/amount of lurkers these games typically have who aren't even there to say they are a bland innocent.
 
SUNDOWN, DAY FOUR

The town dragged johnhughthom to the brink.
'Show yourself! Show yourself!'
'Ack?' 'I mean… me?' said johnhughthom as he saw that Mitch was drawing his trusty 90mm-caliber SMG from pocket.
'He's a Martian!! Get him!! cried one of the Norrises.
As Mitch started shooting, johnhughthom jumped down the mountain and rolled down quite a bit. In the end he was still.
'Surely he's dead, ain't he…?' Said Byron.
'Hells yeah. Let's go sleep.'

Spoiler :
Johnhughthom is a Martian dressed as a human!!
lisamarie.jpg

Vote tally:
civplayah: wideyedwanderer; Autolycus; Winston Hughes (3)
Arakhor: musical-mafia; civplayah (2)
johnhughthom: Kennigit; taillesskangaru; Nictel; Darth Caesar; sprig (7)
sprig: Arakhor; landlubber; flamingzaroc121 (3)

Abstain: Darth Caesar; dcmort93​
It is now NIGHT FOUR.
Send me Night orders!!!
I'm sending Day Action results as fast as I can, the server's just come back online (update took an hour to make)
Dawn in 24 hours, give or take.
 
Not yet, as I might have a replacement.
 
Yes, everyone just vote civplayah because he never talks so he's not useful anyway.

I'm getting sick and tired of mafia games because I never make it to the end. Because of this stuff. If I get eliminated in this, I'll only be in two games, even though I was in nearly five about a week ago. These haven't been fun lately so maybe I should just not sign up for any more. That way you guys won't have the pleasure of voting for me every game.

I've played in several games with you so far, and your behavior is very consistent from game to game, as far as I can tell. It doesn't matter to me whether you're quiet or not, but it doesn't mean you can't be mafia, as we both know from recent games. :)


EDIT: And yeah, CFC was sooo slow yesterday. I couldn't check it at all.
 
Back
Top Bottom