Medieval writings on chivalry and knightly virtue

LightSpectra

me autem minui
Joined
Mar 31, 2007
Messages
5,518
Location
Vendée
I'm going to analyze the Heliand for the class I'm taking on Charlemagne, and I'd like maybe some writings about the ideal of knighthood from the High/Late Middle Ages to compare it with (to contrast the evolution of the form). Any suggestions?
 
During my active years in the Society for Creative Anachronism, I took an Ithra course on courtly love. One of the things we were taught was how to flirt (yes, the men had a particular way to do it, as well). I realized how accustomed I'd become to the Middle Ages mindset when I was going through one of the exercises, and got really embarrassed because the guys in the class all whooped and hollered when I flashed my ankle! :eek:

There are ideals of courage and honor that knights are supposed to uphold in battle and in love. Are you writing about all of it, or just one aspect?
 
In his brief history of the Teutonic Order, William Urban included several neat sections on the "flowering of chivalry in Prussia" in the late 14th century. Unfortunately, the book isn't footnoted very well (does have a good bibliography in the back at least), so I dunno how much help it'd be to you.
 
There are ideals of courage and honor that knights are supposed to uphold in battle and in love. Are you writing about all of it, or just one aspect?

All of it, insofar that it was derived from or developed upon the model from the Frankish Empire.

Thank you all for the suggestions thus far.
 
I've attached something I did a while back.

The footnotes may be useful in your searches

Interesting the article should focus on the Black Prince. He is considered representative of the decline of that era. His manner and conduct towards defeated princes and lords was chivalrous, but his treatment of peasants and townspeople unashamedly didn't fit the mold. The core of his army were commoners who fought dismounted, and with his father, were leading proponents in the practice of total war in the context of the late (or is it high ?) middle ages.
 
Well, from my own work and lectures and stuff, this idea of "chivalry" had never really applied to the plebs. Much like a modern "gentleman's code", being a "cheval" was being part of a rather exclusive club where treatment of each other bordered on the ludicrous.
 
Well, from my own work and lectures and stuff, this idea of "chivalry" had never really applied to the plebs. Much like a modern "gentleman's code", being a "cheval" was being part of a rather exclusive club where treatment of each other bordered on the ludicrous.
Seems oddly similar to the Samurai, that.
 
Most people have compared "bushido" and "chivalry" and in some ways, yes, they are similar.
But I can argue that the life of peasants in Japan probably wouldn't be that much different from the life of peasants in medieval Europe, the point being, similarities between the two "codes" is actually rather.. pedestrian.
 
There are some fairly interesting examples of medieval writing one can take a gander at.

Wolfram von Eschenbach's "Parzifal" is kind of an epitome of 13th c. courtly culture and ideals, otherwise dealing with the Holy Grail and what constitutes a "perfect knight", i.e. Parzifal/Perlesvaus/Percival. (Though Eschenbach's claim of being an analphabet only proud of his ability to beat people up and disparaging his own verse making is most likely a joke.)

Chrêtien de Troyes "Li Conte de Graal" is French, earlier (original?), but similarly themed as Eschenbach's.

Jean de Joinville's autobiography, which has the title "The Life of St Louis" (well, the saint was king of France and Jean's cousin so that explains the title) gives a lot of set-piece anecdotes about French upper-crust sentiments, while actually being bloody entertaining. (Like Joinville commenting on the chivalric qualities of a battle being fought only with "noble" weapons like lances and swords.)

Courtly love is otoh the specific domain of the Occitan trobadour poetry. With additional themes like Betran de Born praising warfare as a noble endeavor, or Peir Vidal boasting of his martial abilities, the political poetry (Peir Cardenal demanding the duke of Toulouse take up arms and drive the two enemies out, the French and the Muslims, in "Far Sirventes"), and the downright smutty stuff (Bertrand de Ventadorn in order to propel a ship filled with virgins becalmed on the sea promising not just to fart the sails into life, but also to :):):):) [edit: OK: "defecate" then? Oh the Horrors of the Body that so plague in particular the Americans!;)] into them if necessary).

Not that the Occitans would necessarily have had much truck with the "chevalerie" of the northern barbarians, instead flaunting their own (strangely similar in someways, less so in others perhaps) concept of "paratge".

Secondary literature, while old by now, I still find Georges Duby entertaining. Maybe try his "William Marshall The Best Knight in the World"?

Reading up on the religious knightly orders as a special case of chivalric culture would also seem reasonable to me.:)
 
Very helpful! Thank you.
 
Back
Top Bottom