[Mini] Ashes to Ashes

[Darth Feather]

You are not going to believe it, but I didn't check it and was really under the impression there was only one scum and serious nightfases with killing scum.

 

[spaceman98]

Greetings. So far, I can't see anything obviously scummy. Darth Feather's actions are suspicious, but you would think that scum would be especially careful about reading the rules, given that they don't want to stand out. S/He could be trying to seem uninformed, but in doing so, s/he has placed hir self into the spotlight, a bad place for scum to be.

 

[Visorslash]

Going to end the round 24 hours from now at 8pm GMT + 10.

Seems unfair to only give 24 hours of discussion.

 

[Jarrema]

We have four-way tie...

what happens in case of a tie at the end of day?

 

[topsecret]

I suppose it's too late for me to join?

 

[Buddhafish]

Well we already have roles so I say yes.

And we need more discussion. And some clarification on the rules of ties.

 

[Darth Feather]

IIRC Visor usually uses no-lynch as tiebreaker.
So that's bad especially if there are two scumbags.

 

[spaceman98]

Vote: Jarrema
Let's force a tie, hmm?

If you are correct about Visor's tie policy, this post is very scummy: SK deliberately made a tie, leading to no lynch. Remember that on day one, the town has a vengeful vigilante kill if a townie is lynched, so if the mafia can waste day 1 on a no lynch tie, they greatly benefit. vote: SK

 

[Jarrema]

IIRC Visor usually uses no-lynch as tiebreaker.
So that's bad especially if there are two scumbags.

It would be not bad. It would just mean that day 1 repeats... (as there is no night kill)

 

[Jarrema]

Oops.
Spaceman is right, there would be difference. I forgot about vig power
(I admit rules are unusual; it is easy to forget something)

therefore, unvote, vote: Southernking. Both because of his behavior, and because we need a clear leader

 

[SouthernKing]

Unvote; Vote: SouthernKing
I'm a jester.

 

[Darth Feather]

ok, I honestly doubt SK is a maffiosi.

Why? Because if so, he is either put in the lead or thrown over the edge by a scumbuddy. But unless I self-vote, there is not going to be another candidate, so we might be better to take a shot at him.

 

[Visorslash]

I normally use no lynch as a tie breaker but here it is unapplicable.

NEW RULE:If no majority is reaches, day continues for another 24 hours. It's pretty much the same as a no lynch, as the mafia cannot kill, and the lynched townie only gets a kill when lynched.

Therefore, if by 8pm tonight, there is no clear target, then you have another 24 hours.

Tally:
4 SK (Buddha, Jarema, SK, spaceman)
1 Buddha (Darth)

 

[spaceman98]

ok, I honestly doubt SK is a maffiosi.

Why? Because if so, he is either put in the lead or thrown over the edge by a scumbuddy. But unless I self-vote, there is not going to be another candidate, so we might be better to take a shot at him.

First, how is you self voting going to give us another candidate, given that you are already voting for Buddhafish and have no votes on you? Also, there are two Mafiosi in this setup, which means you could be the second mafia (also, bussing may be possible).

SK is almost certainly not a jester, since in this game, we only have 5 people, and 2 of them are scum. If he's a jester, there are only two townies and the town is distracted. Moreover, their is only one way for the jester to die: the town vige kill, if the town votes for a townie on the first day. This is unlikely (2/5 probability if SK is jester), and if the kill hits the jester, this will mean an instant scum victory. This creates an OP jester, OP mafia and a terribly unbalanced setup. Visor is a sufficiently skilled GM that s/he would not do something like that. Thus, we lynch SK and I fos: Darth Feather

 

[spaceman98]

Wait, but DF also brought to our attention that

IIRC Visor usually uses no-lynch as tiebreaker.

, i.e. the evidence used to charge SK. Hence, I am not sure about hir yet

 

[SouthernKing]

Wait, but DF also brought to our attention that , i.e. the evidence used to charge SK. Hence, I am not sure about hir yet

Are we talking SK as in serial killer or SK as in yours truly?
Because I can tell you, I am a jester. I intentionally tried tied it up with a bad excuse because I knew that would garner some attention, and now I am role claiming.

 

[spaceman98]

As I said, if you are a jester, then this set up is already unwinnable for the town.

 

[spaceman98]

and was unwinnable from the start

 

[Visorslash]

End Day 1

Early wickets led to an all out collapse as Australia slupmed to a low total. Could their bowlers save their chances, and the Ashes?
​

'Night' 1 will end 24 hours from this post at 10:00 PM GMT +10.

Alive 4/5:
1. Jarrema
2. Spaceman98
3. Buddhafish
4. Darth Feather

Dead 1/5:
5. SouthernKing

SouthernKing has been lynched! He was a Townie!

He gets a vengeful lynch.

I will give him 24 hours to make a decision. You may continue to discuss possible targets, etc.

 

[Visorslash]

End Night 1

Australia collapse in the final session to lose the Ashes once more.
​

Alive 3/5:
1. Jarrema
3. Buddhafish
4. Darth Feather

Dead 2/5:
5. SouthernKing
2. Spaceman98

Spaceman98 has been killed! He was a Townie!

The mafia win!
Congratulations to Jarrema (regular mafia) and Buddhafish (Mafia Godfather).

http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/i4TXRvUDGTD

Quicktopic for the mafia.