National Flags Graded

Bright day
I admit I have not read this thread without torture. Anyway, I believe that it is just wrong to rate flags based on things like prettines. Flags are symbols foremost. Sorry but this thread is just strange IMO.
May all your days be bright.
 
Some of my favorite non-nationals:

oil$shll.gif


ingsoc-c.gif


And my all-time favorite, the American SS Company.

us~assco.gif
 
Guys :rolleyes:, how could you forget...






THE ILSE OF MAN
man.jpg
 
Originally posted by Marla_Singer
Mainly, I don't like their criterias. A flag is created not only to represent a country but also to represent main ideas about it.

Then I fully understand your high ranking of the Canadian Flag then: Plain and Dull. That's Canadians for certain.

I've always known that the three vertical bars as on the French, and many other flags represents a republic, but I never did understand the symbolism of that. Can anyone exaplain?
 
Originally posted by EmpireofVirtue
The webmaster is sick. How can we judge badly a flag simply because it has "too many stars" ?? That's insane !

I can smell biased opinion here. :rolleyes: To quote the page: "Everyone loves stars. Even me. That's why Viet Nam gets such a high grade. Some people, however, are under the mistaken impression that if one star is good, then fifty must be just right."
 
Why do people like the United States flag? It is so stupid. 50 stars is way too many, and the 13 stripes are very annoying to look at. There are way better flags with the same overall design, namely Chile's.

My fav? Taiwan.
 
how could anyone forget the Mississippi state flag? ;)

ms_fi.gif
 
Originally posted by sysyphus
Then I fully understand your high ranking of the Canadian Flag then: Plain and Dull. That's Canadians for certain.

I've always known that the three vertical bars as on the French, and many other flags represents a republic, but I never did understand the symbolism of that. Can anyone exaplain?

Well, this is just "my" top10. At the opposite of the webmaster, I assume it as such and I don't fake "objective" criterias. I've just tried to mix symbolism and aesthetic.

1.
3dflagsdotcom_safri_2fawm.gif

South Africa


South African new flag expresses the diversity of the people of that country. There are 6 colours on that flags and I consider personally that they are brilliantly ordered. Mainly, we can feel that this flag represents the fact that the future of South Africa will be built by everyone together. I like the symbolism of that flag as much as its aesthetic.

2.
3dflagsdotcom_canad_2fawm.gif

Canada


Of course, the symbolism isn't terrific in here. However, we can't deny this flag represents brilliantly the country it's supposed to picture. Who in the world doesn't know that the maple leaf flag is the one of Canada. I like also the funny hidden symbolism of the maple leaf with 11 ends, picturing this way the 11 provinces of the country. It's pretty, it's original, and it pictures well the spirit of the democratic and peaceful country Canada is.

3.
3dflagsdotcom_kenya_2fawm.gif

Kenya


No country pictures better the African pride than the one of Kenya. Many countries in Africa have copied European flags, showing this way how much colonialism has endoctrinated them in the idea of the inferiority of Africa compared to Europe. By the way, that flag doesn't picture weapons like it had been stupidily said, it represents the Massaï traditional Trophy ! The black expresses the people of Africa, the Red represents the blood needed to reach independance, the green represents hope towards the future. And finally, it's underlined with white representing the spirit of Peace. Great flag IMHO.

4.
3dflagsdotcom_uk_2fawm.gif

United Kingdom


Who doesn't know the Union Jack stacking the crosses of Saint Andrew, Saint Patrick and Saint George. That flag expresses perfectly the idea of union. Actually, if we see only the flag, we could believe the country is far more united than it is in real. Moreover, I find it beautiful while waving.

5.
3dflagsdotcom_franc_2fawm.gif

France


I've put the French flag as 7th the first time for politically correct reasons. After all, it's my flag and we can't deny it's subjective to put it on the Top10. Actually, I assume the fact that according to my subjective criterias, I honnestly put it at the 5th place.

The October 1789, at the beginning of the Revolution, La Fayette has inserted the royal white colour between the two traditional colours of Paris : the blue of the "capâ" of Saint Martin and the red of the oriflamme of Saint Denis. Parisians are representing the people in here. The king used to live outside of the main city Paris in Versailles. That flag expresses the fact that now the power is between the people. As such, it expresses the idea of Republic or Democracy (as you will). It's the first tricolour flag and I like those three colours together this way.

If you want to understand the spirit of the French flag, you should know that painting from Delacroix : "Freedom guiding the People"

liberty.jpg



Tomorrow, I'll maybe comment the flag I've put from 6th to 10th. For now, I'm incredibly late so here are those flags :

6. United States
7. Saudi Arabia
8. Sweden
9. Brazil
10. Slovakia
 
Originally posted by De Lorimier
There's only ten provinces in Canada Marla. :)
Gosh you really want me to be insanely late ! Well anyway. ;)

1. Terre-Neuve
2. Ile du Prince-Edouard
3. Nouvelle Ecosse
4. Nouveau Brunswick
5. Quebec
6. Ontario
7. Manitoba
8. Saskatchewan
9. Alberta
10. Colombie Brittanique
11. North-West Territory.

Oops... you're maybe right... my book about geography sucks. They've considered the NW Territory as a Province ! duh ! It's a territory !
 
In no order, my favorites:

so.gif

Somalia. If only the situation there were so simple and pretty as the flag.

fi.gif

Finland. I have a thing for the Scandinavian cross flags. This one is the simplest and most effective.

no-lil.gif

Norway. Of the less-simple Scandinavian flags, this one is the least offensive. The color combinations here actually work for me.

ao.gif

Angola. I love the industralist spin on the hammer and sickle. It's almost funny.

pg.gif

Papua New Guinea. I'm not quite sure what is being depicted on the top, but I like the combination.

mk.gif

Macedonia. I think this speaks for itself.

bt.gif

Bhutan. I don't like this flag as much now that I see the dragon is carrying what appears to be balls (or perhaps has wheels for legs?), but, as with Macedonia, I like the originality.

cx.gif

Chirstmas Islands. Very similar to Papua New Guinea; I find it good-looking in the same way.
 
The saltire, one of the oldest national flags in Europe, and the oldest if our 12th century source is correct in saying it was used by king Ungus of the Picts in the Battle of Athelstaneford against the Angles in the 700s AD:

saltire04.jpg


The Lion Rampant, representing the Scottish crown

rampantflag.jpg



Some Flags based of the Scottish ones:

Most famously, probably, the flag of the civil war Confederacy:

07estunidconfed1860.JPG


The ensign of the Russian Navy (1712-1917):

ru~1712.gif


The flag of Nova Scotia:

ns-lgflag.gif
 
Damn! How could I forget Scotland? From the point of view of pure asthetics, the blue-and-white saltire is perhaps the best simple flag... even topping the French.
 
Pakistan's flag is definitely one of the better flags. The Israeli, Saudi Arabian, India's, and the Quebec flags are good also. However on the whole it seems that the makers of most flags were fairly inept.
 
Back
Top Bottom