Apparently I should post here that I intend to host a game sometime. I intend to base the roles off of D&D classes, and like the smurf game, there will be hp. That being said, lynches will always result in a death that day, unlike the smurf game. Night-time attacks will be heavily favoured towards the attacker (generally scum), but will technically be solved by rolling the dice like a D&D game (host will make all rolls in secret). For those familiar with D&D, scum will get chances for surprise attacks, backstabs and/or powerful spells to really make that first round of combat go their way, potentially even killing weaker roles before they get a chance to defend at all.