Ugh... From an innocent player's standpoint while watching from the sidelines, it was extremely tough to watch all of the other innocents seemingly stumbling around with no direction.
It was a good thing the Silent Ash whacked me and Renata when they did, since between the two of us we were
thisclose to uncovering the whole plot. As she mentioned I had civplayah pegged, and instead of TLO the plan was going to be to flip it onto civplayah that day when it was revealed TLO was important, but she had to leave and I wasn't going to get enough votes to pull it off with what, 2, 3 hours remaining in the day. When Stee got killed at night I was really,
really hoping someone,
anyone would connect the dots back to Beefy. If there's anything veteran players know, it's that Stee, if anything, is a liability, even when innocent (for those who doubt me go back to Renata's XXIII War Party game where he faked scanning a guilty party innocent while being innocent himself). Quite simply, he's not someone you waste a night kill on (no offense Stee...). Beefy being new to the forums and all wouldn't have known this, plus coupled with the fact it was pretty well known he and Stee had been working together from day one to keep the power going so killing him makes sense as to not accidentally reveal something to him he shouldn't have. Throw in another metagame thought where at least one of the two electricians were bad and it was painfully obvious he was guilty. Stuck in Pi was close, but between him being VDF and the timing of his accusation made the legitimacy of his claim suspect.
Catharsis - you did a helluva job roleplaying, probably
too well. I mentioned to Renata right before our combined deaths that you were a prophet of some sort based totally on your role play. I don't know if the bad guys figured it out too and had you killed because of it or for some other reason but on Day 3 I was planning on contacting you.
The lynch of DE was... I don't know where to begin. Morale had gone up after he'd used his ability the first time, so it obviously did something positive. I'm a little surprised no one made the connection that the reason morale continued to drop was the effect of innocents dying and the generator issues that soon followed. The penalty from these circumstances was far greater than what DE's ability could reverse which is why it continued to drop (at least from my point of view as a lurker at this point - Frozen please clarify). Plus throw it the fact a third party had not revealed itself as a threat by this point due to there being only one method of kill and that he'd used his ability three times and not just once led me to believe DE was innocent and not of a second non-Silent Ash team.
As for the two new-comers (CCRunner and Stuck in Pi), because there had been no secondary threat outside of the Silent Ash, I would have pushed extremely hard to lynch both of them had choxorn/rhawn not gotten a rifle to snipe one of them. Again, from a metagame standpoint, you don't have 30 players and only one 'bad guy' side that has three team members.
The strange stone was a nice twist though, something I hadn't considered. I figured it was
bad, just to what extent I had no idea of.
I'm very curious as to what the point of my ability was. Yes, it helped get Seon's plane put back together (which I had no intention of completing fyi, and it was a huge shock when Seon managed to complete it himself), but other than that would reinforcing the doors to anywhere actually have made a difference? For the record, since I knew the generator was needed to keep morale up I was reinforcing that when I got killed. Afterward I was planning on reinforcing the external door based on the premise if it was wasn't important in some way it wouldn't be in the game. Now we know the Commander Frozen had just blown the door up anyway, would reinforcing it actually have done anything? Ditto the other doors - what was behind each of them? Would hacking them down have opened up new abilities/items to people?
Ugh... It feels good to get all of that off of my chest...
Congrats to Sprig for winning, though you owe DE a big thank-you note (

). Auto doesn't get caught lying, Strange Stone isn't revealed and subsequently voted to you because you were sick, etc, etc. Hell, just surviving this madness is a feat in itself - watching the innocent's self-destruct was painful to say the least and to stay out of the crossfire is quite the accomplishment.
Thanks to Frozen for hosting a very well conceived game. There were some pretty interesting ideas in here which I think will make a presence or two in upcoming games, and the write-ups, aside from the occasional pronoun shift (

) were entertaining as well. Good job! I do have one question game set-up related: What was the point of preventing CCRunner and Stuck in Pi from viewing the thread if when they joined they were allowed to go back to page one and read the whole thing anyway? I'd like to think the group of players we have would respect a rule forbidding them to read all the pages prior to their arrival and would have to rely on prior events coming from other players. Sure it couldn't be enforced, but I think if a rule was implented it would be followed. I assume Vandal Warlord was supposed to fulfill the role of informing them of what went on while they were away, but his apparent inactivity would have prevented this (was he inactive? I couldn't really tell from the thread alone. My apologies to him if he were active behind the scenes).