Questions about Jews, Judaism and so on.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Funny you should ask. I'm going to a Jewish wedding in less than an hour and was wondering a few things:
1) Would I be expected to go to the Kabbalat Panim?
2) How long should I expect it to last?
 
I had a good time. Wearing a yamulke was fun. I was wondering about one thing though. The main rabbi was talking about how great the couple was together and said something along the lines of "[another rabbi] said that perhaps their souls were wed in a previous [Hebrew word]." Can you tell me anything about this?
 
I have a quick question and then a comment.

Do you have knowledge of when the Catholic church became "enemy" of the Jews?

My comment is Origen hints at re-incarnation in his writings, but so far in my readings he has not expounded on it. The Gnostics also use the Aons to read that way. And Origen was familiar with them also.
 
IMO There was a "period" that God did not compel Moses to write about on Mt. Sinai. This would be the creation of "the lights". Paul refers to them as "bodies" celestial. I tend to just use the word angel.

Now some people explain that the soul originates from these Aon ages. Now G-d breathed into Adam the Breath of Life and "man" became a living soul. I was derided that I said the body is able to contain a soul as that the soul is a biological phenomenon. I say that God creates a new soul upon the first breath each and every human takes. This being God in us, an immortal soul that will last for eternity. Your thoughts?
 
In the wedding ceremony, they talked a lot about the bonds of marriage being eternal. How does this work with the concept of Gigul?

How many Jews believe in reincarnation?

What are some alternative theories of the afterlife? Which are most common? Which do you personally accept?
 
random
1. Eternal refers to one's life, basically just means that your wife is THE partner for life.
Divorce is VERY discouraged, simply because you don't know until you try all you can.
It's much easier to discard minor "family problems" than look for another wife.
Of course, if the case is hopeless...
2. Reincarnation is a very complicated topic to begin with.
I've heard quite a few diverse opinions, so I'm rather confused.
But yeah, it does happen, though under unclear rules.
3. We don't know until we're there, when it's too late to share with others.
The "rule" that I stick too is this:
All righteous are immediately granted "Paradise", which in reality is soul given closeness to God, both intellectual (as if) and spiritual.
All normal people get "cleaned", then admitted too.
Jews don't believe in eternal punishment, except for VERY bad people (dunno, Hitler?).
Typically, it's said that an average person won't stay in the "wash machine" for more than 11 months.
Also, since paradise isn't physical (nor even resembles it), so is the "cleaning room".
Sorry, but NO devils cooking a soul for breakfast.:lol::eek::lol:
More so, I'm quite in line with a version that describes both Paradise and Hell as our own opinion of our past life: Hell being the SHAME the soul feels for all it did wrong, while the reward for good deeds is the understanding HOW REALLY good they are.
Something like that.:D
 
Ok, I have a question and my outlet has been closed.

I have been thinking about Genesis 1, so the question will follow with commentary. I would also like to ask When was Creation "finished"?

Has God limited Himself to just the first 6 days, or can creation continue? If there are no signs that creation goes on (or are there?), does that mean God is hands off now?

Commentary:

G-d started things rolling with our earth and everything that was not our earth. There was no big bang, because that would imply chaos. The earth and the heavens were perfect, but had no form nor life nor G-d. Time had not even been instituted. There was water (H2O from now on).

Earth, heaven, H2O, and then came light. This light is not light, but G-d and knowledge. This is when G-d infused Himself into the creation. G-d separated the known from the unknown and called it day. This is logic. Time is not day and night. Day and night is the ability to know and to learn the unknown. It is the ability for the body to be awake and to rest. Could this be the literal interpretation of the literal first Day. This day consist of twelve hours to be and twelve hours to "rest" The brain never rest, but the body needs to.

The body takes a rest and then functions, thus the day starts in the evening and finishes in the evening. The second Day G-d separated H2O from the earth's H2O. This is the protective covering that would allow a perfect creation to exist in perfection.

The third day G-d left the H2O in one place and allowed dry land to appear. Scientifically the plates would be lifted up and they would have "rested" on the H2O. The viewable H2O is called Seas. Note that time and mountains were never mentioned. There is no sun, there are no stars, there is no rotation. There is no "space". Then right before the next day, G-d planted the grass, herbs, and trees, that contain "seed" in themselves.

He then set the rotation and put the stars and planets to distinguish between the day and night. It was after the "fact" that they were used to distinguish between light and darkness. The sun, moon, and stars did not "start" time, but they were put in place to "enable" signs, seasons, days, and years. IMO they were designed for that purpose, but not necessarily used (the 4th day) for that purpose. Just now, the sun was sending it's rays, and the flora was providing carbon monoxide and H2O was providing the balance needed to sustain life. BTW, O was in abundance also.

The twelth hour of the 5th day "saw" a universe, flora, and G-d added fowl and sea creatures. I would like to point out, still no mountains, and no "passage" of time.

Spoiler :
Gap theory claims for there to be a "gap" in time. I propose that time did not need to be until death and "sin" existed. While day and night are a passage of life and rest it does not have to be a passage of time. The big issue is decay. Can time be figured out today if there was no decay before "human" time began? What constitutes the ability to figure this out? Carbon dating is not used on things assumed to be over 10,000 years and radiometric is not used on things assuming to be less than 10,000 years. Why? What happened that skews the testing? Now the "un"logical answer is G-d did it. Why? If G-d did it, it means He is mean and did it just to throw scientist off. If G-d did not "purposely" do it, then what happened?


Why is there a need for a passage in time? IMO there were not even seasons until after the Flood. Now it says that the celestial bodies were created for that purpose, but signs were not needed in the earth at that time either. Just because that is their purpose does not mean that they were used that way upon creation.

The sixth day, we see the addition of beast and Adam. G-d did not call him Adam in the 1st chapter and the next verse shows us that G-d finished the heavens and the earth and all the HOST in them. It never says that G-d stopped creating. When Jesus said it is finished, His death was completed, but His "work" had just begun. No offence intended on the NT reference. I am not even sure if the same word is used, but as an English speaker, that is the record I have. Host is an unique term. It does seem to apply that nothing else was needed. Was time needed? In the end of "time" it has been prophecied that time will be no more. In a perfect reality one does not need to exist in time. To me it seems that time is a curse. Time is said to "March On" and unless one gets in "step" with time they will be left behind.

Why is time so deterministic? Why are we so driven by time? Why does time play so importantly in the "lack of a G-d" mindset? Will the universe cease if we stop "counting" time? Will the rotation around stars and galaxies dissappear if time stops? Why can we not travel faster than light, but yet we are so beholden to the passage of time, and at the same time have trouble relating time and space to each other? Did G-d even use hours the first 6 six days? Does it matter? I say 24 hours exist now, no need for anything different then. I say no it does not matter, because I do not think that time was even an issue.

Some Jews have even theorized that the 7th day has not happened, and that it was figurative but yet commanded as an observance of things to come. Not to mention the practicality of a day of rest. Everything was perfect and the "image" of G-d, man probably did not even need rest other than the period of light and darkness that was given. G-d appeared and communed with Adam during the day and Man rested during the night. There was no decay. Why did the laws we have in science today have to even apply before Adam made the choice to disobey G-d? Has it even occured to modern man, that time (as we know it) may not have even started until G-d "cursed" His creation and decay did enter the picture?

Did Adam name all the animals on day 8? I say that there were many periods of night and day even before Eve. I also propose that there were many periods of night and day before the serpent "chatted" with Eve. How long does it take for one to get a reputation for being subtle? Was that an instantanious knowledge? At what point in the night and day rotation did Satan rise up in rebellion? Why did G-d not reveal this to us? If we knew the end from the beginning would we not just grow lazy and not strive for better things? Is time the slave master that keeps hounding us at every turn? I propose that a lot of obedience and filling the earth did happen before that fateful night and day period that created the need for time to even exist. So G-d did not create time but He instituted it for His purpose. It was not a mean institution, but a necessary one.
 
timtofly
Continuous Creation
[Thus, if for the miracle of the splitting of the Red Sea the continuous action of G-d was necessary] how much more so is it in the creation of being out of nothing which transcends nature and is far more miraculous than the splitting of the Red Sea, that with the withdrawal of the power of the Creator from the thing created, G-d forbid, it would revert to naught and complete non-existence. Rather, the Activating Force of the Creator must continuously be in the thing created to give it life and existence. [These Forces] are the "letters of speech" of the Ten Utterances by which [beings] were created.
Everything happened before the expulsion
Chaper 02
Verse 20: The man called.

Scripture now returns to the earlier narrative, "And man gave names..." It was interrupted only to teach you that as a result of the calling of names he was mated with Chavah, as is written: "But the man found no helper for himself. Consequently: "[He] caused unconsiousness to fall..." And as a result of it being written: "The two of them were naked," it is followed by the narrative about the serpent to let you know that as a result of seeing them unclothed and seeing them indulging in marital relations, he desired her and came to them with a plan and deceitfulness.
Chapter 04
Verse 1: The man knew.

This had already [occured] before the previous narrative [i.e.,] before he sinned and was exiled from Gan Eden. This is also [true of] the conception and birth. Had it said {Hebrew Ref} it would imply that after he was exiled children were born to him.
 
What is your opinion of the Hasidim?
 
I thought you were hasidim in regards to your post in the "ask a theologian" thread.

As to my question, it was a generic what is your opinion of the hasidim, it served the dual purpose of a) getting your opinion in regards to this generic form of judaism if you weren't one, and b) finding out for certain that you were actually hasidim (as per my original thought)

Now that this question has been covered the question morphs into: What do you think are the fundamentals of Hasidic judaism, and how are the principles of hasidism incorporated into your day to day life?
 
Chassidism is just a branch of the orthodox (or I'd say, AUTHENTIC) Judaism, as much as the Litvish or Sephardic is.
To make it short - we all believe in the same G-d, same Torah, same Judaism.
The differences are superficial, mostly technical that are hard to tell the difference by outsiders.
I consider myself as a trying-to-be Chabadnik, cause the level I'm now is not the one I'd prefer to be at already... :(
Anyways, the immediate answer to your question lies on the screen:
1. The very topic of "Ask a JEW" - and by that I mean a "religious" (aka observant, in more Chassidic terms) Jew.
2. Just look at my sig.
3. What I mean is, apart from my everyday "Jewish-religious" things (from prayer to eating kosher), I'm not much of a "Chassid" (I mean, to be somewhat different from non-Chassidic ORTHODOX Jews), except when it comes to the topic of Moshiach.
I'm trying to "promote" it as much as possible, as well as the general knowledge about Judaism.
Reason:
Simple, most antisemitism is based on ignorance.
The more you educate people, the bigger the chance they WILL know the truth, which will make them "normal", not baseless haters.

Any more questions??? :D
 
I look at judaism and see the same spiritual war ongoing as occurs in my own faith. On the one had there are those who hold firm in the solid ground of the Divine and Catholic Faith against all maners of relativistic anthropocentrc dissent, dissent which ultimately deifies man and seeks to uplift him as the centre of creation. This sort of attitude ultimately leads to self-destruction and spiritual death as God is the Lord and giver of Life.

What is your attitude and opinion in regard to those jews who have fallen into the paradigm of uplifting human desires over God? (reform jews)
 
1. I feel sorry for them.
2. This is 99% of why I made this thread.
3. Everyone is bound to "come home", just the hope is it will be sooner than later.
4. The idea isn't new at all, it has historical precedents.
The result is the same always - some get back, some are lost forever, no one wins the fight.
Except nowadays it's somehow easier to bring people back, cause the reasons they go astray are fading away each day, THANK G-D! :goodjob:
Moshiach NOW!!!
(Might have sounded banal, but it's not. :king:)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom