I think the XOTM competitions more competitive, because map conditions can really change the game. Having/not having a few rivers for a diplo./space. game can surely affect finish date significantly. Having low shield output in the core almost surely implies a slower conquest or domination game. And a high domination limit implies a higher score histographic game in a slew of cases.
I do like the competitive aspect of XOTM games. That said... I usually prefer HoF games, because the XOTM maps tend to have starts and core areas that feel a little bit "ugly" to me. Of course that's a challenge, but halfway in the game, things just don't feel right to me. That, and I don't like barbarians. We really ought to play a suped up XOTM game sometime... like we had an HoF game start with 4 rivers and 4 cows nearby. Maybe even throw in an SGL from the start too for the fun of it (not that all HoF games have an early SGL... but almost all of them... at least it seems so for the top spots... have a suped up start).
Some of the HoF spots have games that have stood the Test of Time, perhaps... but others can definitely use plenty of improvement. I recently submitted a much faster SS game for demi-god level, and in the last couple months, I've chopped off quite a few years off of some of the Deity 20k tables. More tables exist that can use much improvement (the gauntlets usually aim at these tables, or so it seems)... especially for Huge maps.
I do like the competitive aspect of XOTM games. That said... I usually prefer HoF games, because the XOTM maps tend to have starts and core areas that feel a little bit "ugly" to me. Of course that's a challenge, but halfway in the game, things just don't feel right to me. That, and I don't like barbarians. We really ought to play a suped up XOTM game sometime... like we had an HoF game start with 4 rivers and 4 cows nearby. Maybe even throw in an SGL from the start too for the fun of it (not that all HoF games have an early SGL... but almost all of them... at least it seems so for the top spots... have a suped up start).
Some of the HoF spots have games that have stood the Test of Time, perhaps... but others can definitely use plenty of improvement. I recently submitted a much faster SS game for demi-god level, and in the last couple months, I've chopped off quite a few years off of some of the Deity 20k tables. More tables exist that can use much improvement (the gauntlets usually aim at these tables, or so it seems)... especially for Huge maps.