You just asked civfanatics all over the world which civ game was best...this is something that is personal preference...I have a certain affinity for Classic Civ II, so I wouldn't want to knock it...but the truth is that Civ II is limited and doesn't play scenarios as well as CiC or FW....then again, Test of Time is hard to write scenarios or modpacks for because the engine is a bit different, so it doesn't do much for me yet (although I have the game). I intend to buy civ2 gold to add it to my collection, so I can't really comment on that yet. If I bought CTP, it would be so that I could see if it measures up to Civ II in any way. I would like to try to write a patch for it. Well, it really has to do with what you are into. Classic Civ II isn't a bad place to start...but I would say that you will almost certainly want to buy something else in the series later on.
If that is any help, tell me in what way.
------------------
John Valdez
Modpacks/Scenarios/Review