Simpsons Mafia (Game Thread)

[Visorslash]

delete.

 

[BigTin]

Now what did Visorslash want to hide? I missed it...

 

[Visorslash]

I was going to say something along the line of: "We both know that won't happen."

But then I realised it's pointless dialogue. So I editted it.

 

[BigTin]

I hope you realize that is supicious, because we have no idea what you said. You could be telling the truth, but as there is no way to prove it currently. We will have to wait until the day is over, unless someone has the power to reveal roles.

 

[Autolycus]

Jail: Bigtin

Baseball is a good, all-American activity.

Let's release:BSmith It doesn't seem useful to be down three men from the beginning.

 

[Jarrema]

I agree, Autolycus.
Of course, I suppose that one of us jailed may be 'bad guy', but surely there are scanners in our town

 

[BigTin]

Epic triple post:

Kill Tin and Paul. Protip. I'll explain more when I can be bothered.

I am bothering you. Why do you want both me and paul to die?

Also your first vote on Day 1:

TLD, you can stay in Jail.

Meanwhile, I'd like to chat up that sexy nurse in the hospital!

Hospitalise: Visorslash
And Monorail: Yes

If you were the Reverend, you would not try to talk to any other females, but your wife.

Hospitalise: Takhisis

And why no explanation on your vote? You turned to me once you saw I was new to Mafia, and revealed my role, claiming it is a lie. Yet you have not given any proof that I lied, only hoping we will believe you.

FoS Visorslash and Unvote, Jail: Visorslash

 

[BigTin]

And by turning to me, I mean you conveniently joined my bandwagon, to hide suspicion away from you. If you are the reverend, reveal your PM.

 

[landlubber]

Jail:BigTin. If BigTin is clean, we should, of course, take a closer look at Visorslash.

 

[Turquoiside]

Hospitalize: Bigtin
Church Picnic. It is Sunday after all.

 

[Zack]

FoS: people voting for paul

Seriously, can we please start voting people for actual scummy behaviors, instead of stupid things like "posting too much" or OMGUSing? Christ.

 

[choxorn]

Make the votes end in a tie between me and paul, and paul will be jailed because of my ability as Reverend.

That only proves you have a double-vote or tiebreaker ability, not that you're Reverend Lovejoy.

Unvote, Jail: BigTin

 

[Zack]

Here is why you should vote for BigTin:

• He tries to vote in a way that will please others, not for whom he necessarily believes to actually be suspicious.
• His role claim, which is for a seemingly minor character, has been disputed. Either he is mafia faking this role, or Visorslash is lying.*

*Which is unlikely. Lying to get such a minor character lynched is a huge risk with trivial benefits. If Visorslash is lying to get BigTin lynched, the only logical conclusion is that it is to save his scumbuddy paul from being lynched. Needless to say, Visorslash telling the truth seems much more likely.


Obviously if BigTin is in fact the Reverend, then Visorslash should be lynched next.

 

[BigTin]

Ok choxorn you have a valid point with that comment. If you jail me today you will be jailing a townie so it would be best to release me the following day once I am proven to be innocent which I am. Visorslash is scum. I know none of you believe me because of the mistakes I have made for being a new mafia player.

 

[Mergle]

By the way everyone, we need to Jail BigTin, not hospitalise. The rules say that jailing reveals alignment, hospitalising doesn't (if I've read them right). Therefore, we need to jail bigTin so in the unlikely situation he's innocent we can jail visorslash.

Diddely.

 

[GamezRule]

unvote; jail: BigTin

 

[Zack]

Let's also not forget that Earthling has hosted a game which assigned three separate players the same role (Duncan Idaho). It's entirely possible, albeit unlikely, that Visorslash and BigTin are both innocent, and are both the Reverend.

I don't know hardly anything about the Simpsons, but for those who do -- is there any information about this particular character that could help?

 

[Verarde]

Right, like that game, The Reverend could be the generic townie role.

 

[Zack]

I don't know if it means anything, but BigTin didn't reveal his Personal Goal. For whatever reason, the Role PM he posted also excluded this part:

Feel free to ask any questions about your role. Good Luck!

robbiecon & Earthling

 

[Zack]

I really want to hear more from Visorslash.