Simpsons Mafia (Game Thread)

[Kennigit]

Because I already have strong evidence for the towniness of varying players; BigTin doesn't really mean anything to me, and a double-voter really isn't important imo.

Snake is a bad e.g., I'm just saying I'd rather free someone else and have all the associated risks with doing so than releasing bigtin, who I really honestly don't believe adds benefit at this point.

also yeah, I am mixing up my "anti-town" terminology. you are correct that some neutral party has to be eliminated as well for innocent victory. But I mean, that just makes me question you some. You're claiming a "neutral" role that supposedly can't be nightkilled. What does that imply? That the town has to take you down, or that everybody (town and mafia alike) need to jail/hospitalize you? How does your victory work in.

re visor: is there any more details you have on the stonecutters?

 

[paulwhoisaghost]

Guys, the people in jail are most likely sumbags (eg, the guy with a snake tatto) or worse (eg, Sideshow Bob). If he really is innocent as he says, then he wouldn't mind another round in jail to prove it. Jail: BSmith

We shoul release BigTin cos he is innocent.

No to prop 24

RNG says [COLOR="Orange]GamezRule[/COLOR] should have some beer.

It's cola... not beer... and RNG is either a cop out for giving it to GAmez... or a dangerous method of selecting who the item (that we have no idea what effect it will have) should go to.

 

[johnhughthom]

No to 24

Dimme the cola I needs me a sugar rush.

Jail: paulwhoisaghost

 

[paulwhoisaghost]

Because I already have strong evidence for the towniness of varying players; BigTin doesn't really mean anything to me, and a double-voter really isn't important imo.

Snake is a bad e.g., I'm just saying I'd rather free someone else and have all the associated risks with doing so than releasing bigtin, who I really honestly don't believe adds benefit at this point.

also yeah, I am mixing up my "anti-town" terminology. you are correct that some neutral party has to be eliminated as well for innocent victory. But I mean, that just makes me question you some. You're claiming a "neutral" role that supposedly can't be nightkilled. What does that imply? That the town has to take you down, or that everybody (town and mafia alike) need to jail/hospitalize you? How does your victory work in.

re visor: is there any more details you have on the stonecutters?

If you have "strong evidence" of towniness.... then I think I am missing a piece of the puzzle... help me out here, what am I not seeing... participation has been extremely light, with little to nothing said that would give any indication (let alone proof) of any alignment.

As far as I am concerned. Yes, if you want me out of the list of living players you need to lynch me.... which I've already said I'm okay with and will even aid. If lynched, I will go to jail or hospital just like any other player. But no, I cannot be killed by a vig, SK, scum, or any other killing power.... at least, not during the night cycle. A day vig would do the job... but I haven't seen any indication that one exists.

So yeah, as I said... if the town wants me gone they have to lynch me... but as I also said, it would be a waste of a lynch... kind of a catch 22. However, if you do want to lynch me then send me to jail so you can see that I've been telling the truth. Please explain the logic behind wanting me hospitalized? I don't see the point in that. If I am the lynch leader (or close to it in the event of a close vote count) and the majority of people voting for me are voting to jail me, then I will vote to jail myself.

 

[johnhughthom]

paul, how do you type, being a ghost? Is it like a telepathy thing, or do you take over somebody's body?

 

[paulwhoisaghost]

With my hands... I'm not all ethereal or anything... I'm just dead... and in order to keep people form becoming confused I wear a sheet so people know I'm a ghost.

Or at least that's what happens in the comic I got my name from.

Spoiler Here's the comic :

and

 

[paulwhoisaghost]

Hmmm... I hope that didn't break any rules....

 

[paulwhoisaghost]

So... who wants to give me the cola. Not sure what it is, but I'd feel more comfortable if I had it and was responsible for disbursing it.

If you vote to give me the cola, I'll give you one in return... (This offer obviously only applies to the first 3 people to vote for me to receive it)

 

[Takhisis]

I would suggest you eejits jail, not hospitalise me. Oh, and while we're at it, would you guys consider the Stonecutters to be cult?

Should we consider you to be cult? Maybe. Probably. But then, when El Homo found out about them everybody was a Stonecutter.

Hmmm... I hope that didn't break any rules....

Why would it?

 

[Visorslash]

I'm just curious, as to whether they would be a cult, or mason group? I'd say cult, as in the TV show, they can recruit. And recruiting Masons seem OP for the town, unless there are scums in it, or there are a lot of scums.

 

[paulwhoisaghost]

Yeah... I'm definitely missing pieces to this puzzle... we went from no knowledge of the stone cutters, to Visor hinting at the stonecutters, to Takhisis knowing Visor was a stonecutter.... to ... I don't even know anymore...

 

[Visorslash]

No, I asked whether people think that the Stonecutters are a cult.

Takhsis says I could be hinting that I might be one (which I'm not).

I still want an answer.

 

[paulwhoisaghost]

Well... conveniently.... The game of mafia has a role called Masons... and the Simpson's equivalent of masons are stonecutters.... So I would guess that the stonecutters are this game's masons. And in my experience... masons should be kept hidden as long as possible to maximize their effectiveness for town. Hinting around about them is shady.

 

[Visorslash]

Masons or cult? Reasons why please.

 

[johnhughthom]

Surely the Sonecutters would be too snobby to recruit, there would only be a few potential roles they would want to recruit. Masons are more likely.

 

[Verarde]

No to Prop 24
Jail: paulwhoisaghost
Buzz cola to Zack

 

[paulwhoisaghost]

I love how whenever people provide reasons on this board they are silly reasons based almost solely on color.... maybe color carries more weight on this board than in my homeland...

 

[paulwhoisaghost]

By my loose count (AKA not really keeping count but it seems like I have a majority of votes and they are mostly to jail me..) I'm in the lead and I am going to be jailed.... soooo.....

Jail: Paulwhoisaghost

 

[Visorslash]

Eejits.

 

[paulwhoisaghost]

Eejits.

why? Last time you called us eejits for voting to hospitalize you.... whats the reasoning this time?