Simpsons Mafia (Game Thread)

[Visorslash]

Jail: BSmith

 

[Visorslash]

Before I decide on who to lynch, I must know: if BSmith is sent back to jail, will we find out who he is?

Yes, we will.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Vote myself the Buzz Cola

I have no idea what it does, I'll find out and the appropriate parties can be quietly handed the item.

Vote NO on Proposition 24: Illegal immigrants make up a number of civilian, non-mafia roles in this game. Apu, Bumblebee Man, Moe, Luigi, and several others. Prop 24 is completely mafia-centric.

 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Note: Canon information from The Simpsons suggests a number of beloved characters are illegal immigrants. Possibly thrown in as a one-time gag, but then it becomes canon information and then, in this game, something bad could happen to you.

Would you like to deport Willie the groundskeeper or Apu the Kwik-E-Mart manager? Sure, if you're a scumbag.

 

[Tee Kay]

There are legal illegal immigrants, and then there are illegal illegal immigrants.

Vote YES on Proposition 24. Please think of the children!

 

[BSmith1068]

I told you guys I really didn’t want to be in jail. We could have done it the easy way and just voted one of us out, but since everyone is paranoid that didn’t seem like it was going to happen. So I had to take matters into my own hands. Can I tell you how annoying that singing is?!?!

So Bsmith was probably the scum among us jailants, I already thought that they's have an ability to break out, it would have been unbalanced otherwise.

Lynch him.

So I am scum simply because I can break out of jail? That would be pretty game breaking if that was the case. And why would I break out now, when we haven’t really done much to convince everyone to free us, especially if breaking out of jail is an obvious scum-tell?

Anyway, since I think we should let all three of us that started in jail out so others can get a good look at us and know if any of us are scum, release: TheLastDays.

I would encourage everyone else to do this too.

Before I decide on who to lynch, I must know: if BSmith is sent back to jail, will we find out who he is?

Yes. I am just like the rest of the town, except that I started in jail. Otherwise I am no different. But don’t take my word for it. You can scan me now. Putting me back in jail is counterproductive and is a wasted lynch.

Vote: No on Prop 24
I would like the soda. It has been a while since I have had a good drink.

 

[Kennigit]

Kennigit wants buzz cola
No on 24! we need the money for the bear patrol.
hospitalize landlubber
release jarrema

reasoning that there is a good chance bsmith did just escape himself as an innocent, seeing the incompetence of the springfield police department and tld is quick to assert that bsmith must have been the scum among the jailed.

also, why is no one dead?

 

[Verarde]

also, why is no one dead?

The standard assumption would be a protector.

 

[paulwhoisaghost]

Come on. Think about it for a little folks.

It is my understanding that at the time of me saying BigTin was lying he was in the lead by a fair amount. Why would I then claim he's lying to get him lynched? It makes no sense.

I want neutrals dead, because: Endgame, 2 townies and a scum equal possible win chance.

One townie and a neutral, and a scum equal we lose.

First of all, your first statement is false. BigTin was not vote leader when you counterclaimed him... I was... but he seemed to panic at the growing number of votes against him and he claimed.

Second, the statement above that I bolded for emphasis reeks of you having PIS. The rules thread gives us the Town VC, but not the scum VC. However, your statement implies knowledge of the scum VC.

My mafia history would have me believe that scum win when they equal or outnumber the non-scum players left in the game. However, your statement seems to indicate that scum would win by equalling or outnumbering the remaining town aligned members.

The difference being that in my experience, given a townie, a neutral, and a scum... the neutral could vote against the scum and hand the victory to Town. Your statement doesn't leave room for that possibility.


It seems to me that you know a little more than the rest of us about the scum VC.

Jail: Visorslash

Give me the Buzz Cola... since I'm neutral I don't have a silly VC that conflict with other player's VC's. I'll be able to objectively look at the game and decide how to best distribute the Cola.... most likely to my belly.

Vote no on Prop 24. (I thought Apu got his citizenship? In the episode Much Apu About Nothing. Although... in that episode the prop passed and Groundskeeper Willie was deported... we don't want that to happen do we? I mean, who else is gonna get greased up and climb through the vents at the school?)

 

[paulwhoisaghost]

also, why is no one dead?

Well...

1. People are still wasting their kills on me.

2. The kill target(s) were protected.

3. The scum want to confuse town and lie low at the same time.

4. The scum have alternate powers and have to choose between killing or using those powers.

5. There is no scum team and this game is all town and a mix of 3rd parties and PFKs. (You guys are familiar with the difference between 3rd parties and PFKs right? I only ask because you guys all call them neutrals. But grouping them together is a bad idea. A 3rd Party's VC is non-exclusive. It allows for any other alignment to acheive victory... the 3rd party just wins with whatever team wins. A PFK [Playing For Keeps] however, has a VC that is exclusive. They can steal the victory from all other players.)

 

[paulwhoisaghost]

Anyway, since I think we should let all three of us that started in jail out so others can get a good look at us and know if any of us are scum, [c]release: TheLastDays[/color].

I would encourage everyone else to do this too.

If we are going to release anyone from jail, shouldn't it be the one person in there that we know is Town?

Release: BigTin

FOS BSmith....

 

[Mergle]

No on 24!
Hospitalise: Visorslash
Release: BigTin

 

[BSmith1068]

Two points on that:

1.) We already know that BigTin is innocent. On the face if it, it should be a no-brainer to release him, but that will give the scum a clear target for the night. (Unless someone protects him). Right now he is safe in Jail and can’t be touched. We can release him any time we wish.

2.) We don’t know anything about TLD or Jarrema, other than they started in jail. If we release one of them, then we can scan them and know if they are a threat or not. Just as you can now scan me and find out about me.

 

[paulwhoisaghost]

Two points on that:

1.) We already know that BigTin is innocent. On the face if it, it should be a no-brainer to release him, but that will give the scum a clear target for the night. (Unless someone protects him). Right now he is safe in Jail and can’t be touched. We can release him any time we wish.

2.) We don’t know anything about TLD or Jarrema, other than they started in jail. If we release one of them, then we can scan them and know if they are a threat or not. Just as you can now scan me and find out about me.

1. He's of no use to us in Jail. If scum target him at Night (if there even is a scum team) then they would be taking out a confirmed Townie.... this much is true... but they also won't be attempting to kill any Cops or Docs. So releasing him does two things for us, it gives us someone we know we can trust AND it provides a tempting target that scum will have to take out eventually if they want to maintain a general air of uncertainty near end game, thus providing an extra line of defense for power roles.

2. The opposite of point number 1 applies here. We know nothing of the other 2 players in Jail. Releasing them could be opening Pandora's box. Yeah we could scan them.... but right now they are not a threat to us, so why bother releasing them. From the information we have, we could play this entire game without them ever leaving jail and just play as though they weren't even playing. There is a 50% chance they could be beneficial to town... but there is also a 50% chance they could be dangerous for town... releasing them just gives us an opportunity to reveal which side of that 50% is real. Schrodinger's cat.

 

[Jarrema]

Please, release me!

My argument is kind of OOC:
It REALLy sucks to play this game from jail. Show some humanity and let me play

 

[Gone 3 the Celt]

hospitalize: Visorslash

yes on propostition 24

give me the buzz Cola...

release: BigTin

 

[mayor]

jail: Visorslash He has been acting way to fishy for my tastes....

no on proposition 24 I agree with ATPG, it's way to mafia centric. I would like people who vote yes to explain there point of view a bit better than just saying : "think about the children" or not saying anything at all.

can we give the cola to BigTin? I vote for him, he's the only one I know for sure isn't mafia.

that said: I think we should releaseBigTin

 

[BSmith1068]

While I believe that Visorslash is indeed acting suspicious, I think we need to establish a counter wagon in case we need to change course later in the day. jail: paulwhoisaghost is our next best candidate to test with a jail sentence.

 

[Earthling]

can we give the cola toBigTin?

No, you generally can't vote/give an item to a player in jail or in the hospital.

 

[mayor]

ok

than unvote and I need to think about a new vote