That list has some very respected people in the modding community. I guarantee they were all not "yes men".
I beta tested for Play the World. After it was released... I didn't even bother to look at the reviews or read the forums here at Civfanatics. I already knew what they would be. (it was released in a terrible state) I felt a tad guilty, because I didn't play as much as I wanted to, but, there were a few things I saw that upset me.
I guess I can put it like this:
The developers of these games play them all the time, and get bored of working on them. So sometimes their focus shifts to bells and whistles or perhaps things they are interested in.
********************
Really, I think it took a serious swallowing of Sid Meier's desire to design, and pride, to let it come out like this. I think he tried to remind himself to go ahead and play with the franchise, to let "new" ideas be fleshed out. To not immediately shoot down what seemed to be nonsense to him... but he should have shot them down.
The franchise is fine, but who here actually believes they are still popping champagne bottles at Firaxis? They are going to polish this turd as well as they can, because they have to. But I'd bet, this series will only have one expansion.
I imagine Sid is actually quite a bit upset with himself.
******************
I see it all the time, especially in the mod forums. People on forums complain about things, and then supply suggestions to fix it. The suggestions are usually simplistic, and usually have a whole bunch of unintended consequences attached.
Somebody here said it is hard to screw up the civ franchise, and I believe it. They said they could have made a better civ V... and I believe it.
The design philosophy of Civ V was flawed from the outset. The whole "tear it down, build something better" philosophy was flawed... because Civ IV's design was damn near perfect... even at Vanilla release. I played the hell out of it when it first came out.. I looooved it.
*******
Finally, business is business. Somebody has about 3 years to take the TBS crown from firaxis and Sid Meier.