JohannaK
Heroically Clueless
I'm also down 40 hit points! Get outta there, Demoman!
And, as I said I would, vote: mgsmuhammad
And, as I said I would, vote: mgsmuhammad
Team Fortress 2 Mafia: Game Thread [concluded]
- Thread starter choxorn
- Start date
SamSniped
DJ Goodboye
I'm down 15 plus bleeding 5 for the next three turns. Would someone mind healing the bleeding tonight? Also, thank you whoever healed that 10 HP 
Vote: Omega124
Vote: Omega124
- Joined
- Apr 4, 2010
- Messages
- 8,873
Because we have no leads on Scum and the lynch isn't 100% guareented to kill, we should kill the person who has the most damage. That would be you, Vote: mythmonster2
Also, claiming damage is something scum could do to distract our Medics. I know it's WIFOM, but it's worth a shot.
Also, claiming damage is something scum could do to distract our Medics. I know it's WIFOM, but it's worth a shot.
SamSniped
DJ Goodboye
Before I stated my damage, daveshack posted the list with annotations of the players.
Page 8 if you wish to see it.
Page 8 if you wish to see it.
- Joined
- Apr 4, 2010
- Messages
- 8,873
SamSniped
DJ Goodboye
You said,
and I was proving that I wasn't scum.
- Joined
- Apr 4, 2010
- Messages
- 8,873
Didn't you get some damage yesterday? That would be a reason for a medic to heal you.
Anyway, I'm getting some serious townie vibes from you. And since all the people who I thought were scum were major townie power roles, I'm hoping it will work the other way around as well. unvote:
SouthernKing
crickety cricket
Since it's an unconfirmed claim andI have my doubts, Vote: JoanK although I'll likely change.
JohannaK
Heroically Clueless
Unconfirmed claim on what?
Zack
99% hot gas
Vote: Takhisis
SamSniped
DJ Goodboye
@JoanK-The damage you took. I'm not unvoting and voting you, however, for I am suspicious of Omega. And this time, I really do have my own reasons.
JohannaK
Heroically Clueless
Oh my! What are you? He reads minds! 
- Joined
- Apr 4, 2010
- Messages
- 8,873
Okay, SamSniped just role revealed to me. It doesn't seem right, for multiple reasons which I will list in this post later. Also, he said that Backwards Logic and Red Spy believe his roleclaim as well, which is odd considering it is so early in the game. It's also the kind of thing new players do when they are scum. Okay, more oddness:
1) He says he's a BLU soldier that has an ability called "Battalion's Backup" which gives a Two-Shot invunriblity from night kills to himself and another player. My ability comes in the form of a weapon and that does not sound like the name of a weapon, although this is TF2 and I have never played the game before so I could be very wrong. Also, I could be wrong about this for similar reasons, but Two-Shot invunriblity from nightkills doesn't sound like an ability that a soldier would have, especially because I am a Scout with an attack ability, abiet a very weak one. Yes I just roleclaimed in the middle of an accusation. Deal with it.
2) He also said that he was voting for Omega because he said he was a Demoman on SonIOT Chat and that someone was blowing people up. Considering Spies like to stab people in the back rather than blow someone up, that would make Omega more likely to be a viglante. Holding this information back from the town only serves to hurt the town and spread confusion. And who talks about roles on chat of all places anyway?
3) The fact that he roleclaimed to me when there was ONE vote against him. Flintch much?
4) BL and RS apparently knowing about this. That makes no sense unless they were Masons, which he would have mentioned; Mafia or he did that weird roleclaim thing to those two as well. RS might believe him, but someone with as much Mafia experience as BL? Please. This point is definitely the most damning point of all.
In Summary: Lynch SamSniped today, if he is a RED then lynch BackwardsLogic and Red_Spy the next days. If he is BLU, BL and RS are probable town, I will kick myself in the leg really hard and I'll give town permission to kill me. That is all.
Correction: I am too lazy to edit it into my post, so a I shall put it here: The PM says that RS and BL have merely been informed about this and that they might not believe him, but this is still über fishy and I still don't like it. FoS: SamSniped, BackwardsLogic and Red_Spy
1) He says he's a BLU soldier that has an ability called "Battalion's Backup" which gives a Two-Shot invunriblity from night kills to himself and another player. My ability comes in the form of a weapon and that does not sound like the name of a weapon, although this is TF2 and I have never played the game before so I could be very wrong. Also, I could be wrong about this for similar reasons, but Two-Shot invunriblity from nightkills doesn't sound like an ability that a soldier would have, especially because I am a Scout with an attack ability, abiet a very weak one. Yes I just roleclaimed in the middle of an accusation. Deal with it.
2) He also said that he was voting for Omega because he said he was a Demoman on SonIOT Chat and that someone was blowing people up. Considering Spies like to stab people in the back rather than blow someone up, that would make Omega more likely to be a viglante. Holding this information back from the town only serves to hurt the town and spread confusion. And who talks about roles on chat of all places anyway?
3) The fact that he roleclaimed to me when there was ONE vote against him. Flintch much?
4) BL and RS apparently knowing about this. That makes no sense unless they were Masons, which he would have mentioned; Mafia or he did that weird roleclaim thing to those two as well. RS might believe him, but someone with as much Mafia experience as BL? Please. This point is definitely the most damning point of all.
In Summary: Lynch SamSniped today, if he is a RED then lynch BackwardsLogic and Red_Spy the next days. If he is BLU, BL and RS are probable town, I will kick myself in the leg really hard and I'll give town permission to kill me. That is all.
Correction: I am too lazy to edit it into my post, so a I shall put it here: The PM says that RS and BL have merely been informed about this and that they might not believe him, but this is still über fishy and I still don't like it. FoS: SamSniped, BackwardsLogic and Red_Spy
SamSniped
DJ Goodboye
Gee, thanks for believing me 
. You know what, if you want to lynch me go ahead. You are going to kill someone who could help in the future.
Also, this is the Battalion's Backup.
You know, maybe I wanted to clear myself, and since there was only one vote against me, maybe it's the fact that THIS IS THE FIRST MAFIA GAME I HAVE EVER LOOKED AT?
Considering my inexperience, why would I try to lie if I wanted to survive?
. You know what, if you want to lynch me go ahead. You are going to kill someone who could help in the future.Also, this is the Battalion's Backup.
You know, maybe I wanted to clear myself, and since there was only one vote against me, maybe it's the fact that THIS IS THE FIRST MAFIA GAME I HAVE EVER LOOKED AT?
Considering my inexperience, why would I try to lie if I wanted to survive?
Omega124
Challenging Fate
I deny all accusations of role reveal on the chat as calumny.
JohannaK
Heroically Clueless
Unvote; vote: Omega124
Jusy in case: if you're a Demoman, you have targeted me or the mythmonster, and I don't really care atm if he's RED or BLU, but that you might have inflicted direct damage on me. And if you're RED, better for us. If you're BLU, one name less in the list.
Jusy in case: if you're a Demoman, you have targeted me or the mythmonster, and I don't really care atm if he's RED or BLU, but that you might have inflicted direct damage on me. And if you're RED, better for us. If you're BLU, one name less in the list.
Zack
99% hot gas
Ninja, never reveal someone's private roleclaim to you in public. If you think they're town, then the reasons for not doing so should be obvious. If you think they're scum, chances are they're not, and instead of explicitly revealing their claim, say "their roleclaim is fishy/suspicious/whatever." That way, suspicion is still cast on them, and if they're town the mafia don't know their role.
From what you said, I'm guessing you're a town scout, SamSniped is a town soldier, and Omega is some sort of town vigilante demoman (his response all but confirms it). Experienced players such as BL extract roleclaims from inexperienced players all the time, it's like taking candy from a baby for them. Most of the time, the inexperienced player is town -- new players tend to not be very skilled at faking roleclaims.
Now the mafia won't target SamSniped, because they know he has a temporary bulletproof ability, and you just cast a bunch of suspicion on him and made him a lynch candidate. The proper move would have been to try and trick the mafia into wasting a nightkill on Sam when he's invincible; instead, you have now effectively rendered his ability useless. And now the mafia know the identity of a likely vigilante. Congratulations.
I seriously urge the town to vote for Takhisis, for reasons I'll keep to myself.
From what you said, I'm guessing you're a town scout, SamSniped is a town soldier, and Omega is some sort of town vigilante demoman (his response all but confirms it). Experienced players such as BL extract roleclaims from inexperienced players all the time, it's like taking candy from a baby for them. Most of the time, the inexperienced player is town -- new players tend to not be very skilled at faking roleclaims.
Now the mafia won't target SamSniped, because they know he has a temporary bulletproof ability, and you just cast a bunch of suspicion on him and made him a lynch candidate. The proper move would have been to try and trick the mafia into wasting a nightkill on Sam when he's invincible; instead, you have now effectively rendered his ability useless. And now the mafia know the identity of a likely vigilante. Congratulations.
I seriously urge the town to vote for Takhisis, for reasons I'll keep to myself.
Zack
99% hot gas
And the notion that all mafia are spies is erroneous; MartinLuther was an innocent spy, for one. And really, does anyone actually believe that the hosts would make the mafia team so homogeneous? I'd guess the character classes for the mafia are just as diverse as for the town.
JohannaK
Heroically Clueless
Precisely why I said Omega can be either BLU or RED, and I'm sure that there are RED Snipers and Heavies...
