Wild turkeys are very different. Here is a recipe for turkey from an actual French chef.
Oh yes my timing is waaaaay off but heck, you never listen to me anyway.
Here is MY version of cooking a turkey and its... shocking!
Try to keep an open mind as most of these tips will be the opposite of what you've ever heard about Turkey so grab a seat first and if you like good food you might even try this one day
My main issues with Turkey are a rather bland taste and a dry meat. And of course my number one problem is the habit of Americans to OVERCOOK it of course
First the choice of bird: the difference in taste between industrial, battery turkey and free range is huge, I mean really huge. In a blind tasting I'd get 10 out of 10 for sure. But OK the price difference can be also huge so I understand everyone does not have 50 or a 100 bucks to invest in a turkey but hey its that once a year occasion remember and if you were cooking fillet steaks for 12 people it'd cost you a 100 bucks too. At least try not to buy a frozen animal, please
So what you need is the
KellyBronze variety, the Rolls Royce of the Turkey. Its actually an English variety sorry Yanks. Free-ranging at least, if not organic. The meat from this variety is much fatter than other turkeys and the bones have a sweet, slightly wild taste which makes the meat taste so much better.
Also you should not buy a big bird, the bigger the more bland it tastes, rather 2 small birds than one biggie. An average KellyBronze is 5kg and thats my recommended weight for turkey.
Here are my cooking tips:
- Let the bird out at room temperature a minimum 2 hours before cooking, no compromise.
- Do not stuff the turkey http://www.cybertavern.net/speakeasy/images/smilies/WTH.gif yes you've heard right, stuffing increases the cooking time and results in dryer meat. Stuffing will also absorb most of the juices out of your turkey meat, drying it even more
- Good stuffing can be perfectly cooked outside of the turkey and added to the cooking juices right at the end. If you need tips on how to do that, let me know. An onion or herbs can be used instead of stuffing.
- Do not use an oven with a fan or with hot air (dont know how you call it in US), again that dries out. Preheat at 180C for 30min.
- Salt and pepper your turkey (no brining) and it lay breast down in an oven tray! Thats the real secret to success: the juices and fats are mostly in the bottom of the bird so laying it down breast down means all those juices will sip through your big white breasts and create extra juiciness.
- You can have some vegetables at the bottom of the tray as it will help to make your own delicious gravy.
- The KellyBronze only needs 20mins per kilo! of cooking time. Other turkey usually require 30 min. max. so this shorter cooking time is also a factor in the quality of the meat as the less you cook it the better. So 5 kg= only 1h40 min cooking time
- Halfway through throw a glass of water with vermouth in the baking tray. No basting further needed
- 30 minutes before the end, turn the turkey around so that you get your get that great skin crispiness, since the skin will have absorbed the fat which was at the bottom, you will get a very nice crispy skin from this method! And with this no need to cover with stupid (drying) tin foil...
- Use a thermometer to get the cooking perfectly right, prick it in the thickest part of the meat (the breast) and wait til you hit 68C and... it's cooked!
- Take it out and let it rest in a warm place uncovered! for 30 minutes! That part is essential
- Right before serving throw the juices on top of it and...SERVE!
The results are usually phenomenal, most people than say that they actually never had turkey before they had mine and I even cooked this dish for an American friend of mine who is a restaurant owner and one of NYC most famous chef and he was gobsmacked, since then he has used my recipe for his restaurant and even got an article in the NYTimes for the quality of his turkey
Game turkey would fit his requirement for more flavor in the bird.