Vietnam Cultural Location

Joined
Jun 30, 2007
Messages
8,194
Location
Boston, Massachusetts
This question has been bothering me for ever since I joined CFC:

Is Vietnam culturally in Southeast Asia or East Asia?

Is South Vietnam more culturally SE Asian than North Vietnam?

Are there substantial cultural differences between S Vietnam and N Vietnam?

What is different from Vietnam and, say, Laos or Cambodia?

Please answer.
 
This question has been bothering me for ever since I joined CFC:

Is Vietnam culturally in Southeast Asia or East Asia?

Is South Vietnam more culturally SE Asian than North Vietnam?

Are there substantial cultural differences between S Vietnam and N Vietnam?

What is different from Vietnam and, say, Laos or Cambodia?

Please answer.

1.I always thought it was SE Asia
2. I don't think we share large culture traits with the rest of SE Asia, only China
3. There are differences between the two. The North speaks a different dialect, considered proper Vietnamese. The southern folks{like me} speak somewhat a more laid back form. There differences in cuisine as well. Other than that, I do not know as there aren't many northern Viets in Texas .
3. Vietnam is different from Laos and Cambodia as France is different from Spain and Germany
 
Like YuLaw? said, geographically SE Asian (even this is debateable - see Annamite Mountains below), but culturally East Asian:
  • At a number of points in history, China occupied parts of northern Vietnam, so the Vietnamese picked up much more Chinese culture than did the Lao, the Thai or the Khmer (Cambodians).
  • Vietnam, like China, Korea, and, Tokugawa-era Japan instituted Confucian based exam systems for its bureaucrats.
  • Vietnamese Buddhism is also more often Mahayana, again like the Northeast Asian countries, as opposed to Theravada, like Laos, Thailand, and Cambodia.
  • Prior to the French introducing a Latin based script, Vietnam used Chinese characters, something the other SE Asian nations never did.
Historically, South Vietnam has closer ties to Cambodia than does the North, and was at one time an entirely separate nation, Champa which had more Hindu, Theravada Buddhist, and Islamic elements than Vietnam. How much of that remains, I don't know. There are still some Muslim Chams in the south, but not many.

Laos is very closely related to Thailand. Their languages are very similar, and Northeast Thailand's regional dialect, Isan, is essentially the same language as that spoken in Laos. Culturally, there is little affinity between Laos and Vietnam. Crossing the Annamite Mountains, which separate the two countries, is like crossing into a different dimension: the language, the people, the weather, the flora and fauna all change drastically.

Cambodia is its own entity, though it bears more in common with the Lao and Thai than with the Vietnamese - they are also Theravada Buddhists. Other than that, I don't know much about Cambodia.

Hope that helps.
 
This question has been bothering me for ever since I joined CFC:

Is Vietnam culturally in Southeast Asia or East Asia?

Is South Vietnam more culturally SE Asian than North Vietnam?

Are there substantial cultural differences between S Vietnam and N Vietnam?

What is different from Vietnam and, say, Laos or Cambodia?

Please answer.

1. Cuturally, we're definitely East Asian. Ethnically we may be more SE Asian, but culturally we've pretty much copied the Chinese. A lot of our words, also, are loaned from the Chinese.

2. No real difference, as far as I know.

3. Nothing significant, except the dialect, which is as different as Texan and British English.

4. We were part of China for 1000 years, so we took a lot of influence from them. So, after we got free, practically all of our institutions - cultural, political, economic, social, etc. etc. etc. - were modeled after the Chinese.
Also, we beat the Americans. And Mongols. And Chinese a number of times. And French (thoh that took a while) :P
 
For number 4 I would say that Vietnam has a lot fewer left over landmines in it, but that's mostly fueled from watching too much television. >:
 
[/quote]Also, we beat the Americans. And Mongols. And Chinese a number of times. And French (thoh that took a while) :P[/QUOTE]

Don't forget we helped kick out the Japanese during WW1 and destroyed the Champa. The only reason the French were there was because we preferred them over the Chinese. There's a saying {loosely translated} "Better a French 100 year reign than a 1000 year Chinese reign"
 
^oh, and we also beat the Thai too, and ourselves a few times. :)
 
Back
Top Bottom