Originally posted by Algernon Pondlife
Dexter was referring to the idea (speculation, if you like) that the origins of religion lie in attempts to explain things beyond their understanding. To me this would suggest that these were very intelligent people tackling difficult questions in an innovative way. This is a plausible idea and some people are probably highly convinced by it, but of cours it would be very difficult to prove, even in a non-rigorous manner.
You seem to have little faith in your ancestors ability, besides just look at Ancient Greek God's, God's of fire and the like.
I'm not convinced by your description of the purpose of religion. I can see that it may well be true for your specific religion, but it does not seem to relate so clearly to at least some other religions where more emphasis is placed on worship or transcendence or personal redemption.
Modern religion's were born from these simple doctrine's of the ancient world's perception of life. Christianity and Judaism have things in common with the ancient Babylon's.
Here is the story told by the Babylon's...
One of their God's Enlil sent many plagues to earth to kill the Human's but they continually survived so he decided to send a great flood. But one god called Enki told a man named Atra-Hasis to build a great boat and bring two of every animal on board. So he did and he survived the floods.
This story is basically the story of Noah's ark with a few changes.
Now as you will know the Jewish faith was born around the mediterranean where the great Babylon's lived, Jews were born from the Babylonian faith, Christians were born from the Jewish faith and Muslims were born from both Christianity and Judaism (I know this because Muslims and Jews have the same prophets, i.e. Jacob and David). I think that proves my point that modern religion birthed from the beginnings of old religion's.
Originally Posted by Shaolin
I am by no means a pacifist, nor do i support the killing of innocent people, I am not a Christian, Muslim or Jew. And in being neutral and having no biased toward any religion what-so-ever, I can honestly say that most religion has been responsible for more murders than anything else in history.
You hit the nail on the head Shaolin.
Well I hope I answered your questions clearly,
Dexter