Not so bad, I think - you run an irrigation line north from the jungle tile along the river NE of Carthage, past the gold mine.
Good catch!

That would indeed help a bunch.
That's the right long term play, but I would give serious consideration to placing the city one north of the copper. Carthage has plenty of sugar cubes; I'd be tempted to let Coppertino share the corn (which it can use before the first border pop, thanks to overlap.
Putting Coppertino on the coast also gives you a chance to throw a workboat together there for the clams.
Did you not notice that the tile 1S of the sugar is also coastal? Yet it minimizes the number of water tiles, which I also prefer. And it would have sugar and wheat to feed its citizens, and not have to share those with another city. By mid-game when I approach the health cap I'll be very glad to have all three cereal resources. Are you suggesting going for that location because of its proximity to the capital, to get the copper on-line ASAP?
On sugar plantations vs. cots on sugar: river commerce + sugar plantation commerce = 2c, kicking in the financial coin for 3c. Non-river sugar plantation is 1c, no financial boost. Riverside cot is 1+1=3c for Fin, but the cot will mature to hamlet for 2c kicking in the financial coin there even if not riverside. So I would definitelly plantate riverside sugar and cot non-river sugar instead. It's just one coint we're talking about, but hey - each coin counts.
Another good catch, and I was wonder which was better myself. I feel better now about farming the two riverside sugar tiles, especially since I was so close to Pottery for cottages. With this advice in hand, however, I'll leave them farmed until Calendar and cottage the other sugar tiles.
Regarding horse city... the city's primary purpose is to grab horses. It might not be a great city like Carthage will (that food surplus + cottability leads to Oxford for sure), but working plains horse + oasis + rice (not irrigated) + two grass hills will bring in hammers. And hammers with horses means Numidian Cavalry. That city should be just fine early on, and even if it'll never be a great city, it has a role to play.
I very much dislike horse city. Grabs 3 resources, no argument there, but even if you were to irrigate every single tile you'd still only have 8 food surplus (excluding the resource & hill tiles for a moment) until the advent of Biology. Moreover, it would have only 6 semi-valuable tiles: the horse, the incense, the oasis, 2 grassland hills and 1 yucky desert hill.
It'd be next to worthless early on - a definite no-no for one of the first cities IMO - and can grow into a drag on your economy later on at best (keeping the cost of city maintenance and civics in mind) Even production would be mediocre.
I think you're trying to hard to take advantage of the UU. While i understand that you want to leverage the numidain cavalry i think you'd have more success founding copper city, one south of sugar as u suggested and switch research to mysticism 4 the border pop... you should found the copper city and axe rush someone.
An interesting variety of opinions there (and I didn't quote KMad's distaste for the horse city site, but I'll acknowledge it here).
Please don't forget, folks, that horses are a priority in Warlords for
Chariots, who are now the best anti-barb unit early on for a number of reasons: 2 moves, +100% attack against Axemen, and they're dirt cheap. They do an even better job than Axemen of defending your early, vital, hard-earned tile improvements. Which is why I would tend to side with Elendal here. The Barbs are coming--I expect them from the seemingly-empty area to my north and from the inhospitable jungle to my west. If I can get chariots and axes, I'll be able to deal with them.
I am still inclined to go for horse city first because, as I mentioned, it will have horses in the first ring, so I can have a decent anti-barb unit ASAP. I do indeed have long-term plans for copper city--I'd like it to become, as I said, the HE/WP military city, so I want it in the best position possible. Since building a monument and popping its borders will delay making copper available for Axemen, I'd prefer to get Chariots on-line first.
However, we can obviously discuss this further, and so far I have one person siding with me in favour of horse city and at least 2 against, 2 others doubtful. Granted, this ain't a democracy, but the majority vote of the group mind has swayed me in the past.
In other words... convince me.
This will have an impact on research, potentially. I'll need to switch to Mysticism if I send the Settler south for copper but to my preferred spot, so I can build a Monument ASAP. Then again, given the cost of HBR right now, and the fact that copper city will at least be city #3, I should probably switch to Mysticism right now anyway. Whaddya think?
Carl Corey: you're a real stinker, ain't ya?
