Evie
Pronounced like Eevee
It's hard to determine where in time we are exactly because of the compression. Sauron hasn't even occupied Mordor (1000 SA) but Miriel is queen and Numenor falling (3255 SA),
Most of the time indication say it's been several centuries since the end of the War against Morgoth, not millenias. My reading is that we are about 1000 years into the Second Age, and the eventd of the later age are being compressed. If so, Galadriel is about 1500 years removed from the flight of the Noldor - but still whatever's left of the second age plus the entire Third Age (3018 years) removed from the Galadriel who could refuse the Ring. Much closer in age to the former than the later.
And Galadrie's struggles with pride were a thing late in her life - she herself admits she long desired to possess the Ring, and it's still a momentous test for her when she's offered it. And even in LOTR she's not especially diplomatic - she relies on mind reading far more than talking (also implied by the failure of her plans to have a Gandalf-led white council rather than a Saruman-led one), and she has one of the Three to help her at that point.
Now, it's true that even this Galadriel wouldn't do one thing, and that's falling for Sauron's entreaties. She wasn't taken in by Annatar, so if Halbrand is Sauron, yes, this interpretation of Galadriel would be out of line. Tolkien's clear on that.
But I'm in the camp that sees Halbrand as a future Witch King or King of the Dead more than Sauron. Because having Sauron randomly wander the ocean on a raft until he stumbles on the one needle in the watery haystack who can help him infiltrate Numenor would be such horrible characterization as to make any criticism of Galadriel seems empty in comparison. Plus, Sauron has a LOT he needs to do on the mainland before imprisonment on Numenor.
Most of the time indication say it's been several centuries since the end of the War against Morgoth, not millenias. My reading is that we are about 1000 years into the Second Age, and the eventd of the later age are being compressed. If so, Galadriel is about 1500 years removed from the flight of the Noldor - but still whatever's left of the second age plus the entire Third Age (3018 years) removed from the Galadriel who could refuse the Ring. Much closer in age to the former than the later.
And Galadrie's struggles with pride were a thing late in her life - she herself admits she long desired to possess the Ring, and it's still a momentous test for her when she's offered it. And even in LOTR she's not especially diplomatic - she relies on mind reading far more than talking (also implied by the failure of her plans to have a Gandalf-led white council rather than a Saruman-led one), and she has one of the Three to help her at that point.
Now, it's true that even this Galadriel wouldn't do one thing, and that's falling for Sauron's entreaties. She wasn't taken in by Annatar, so if Halbrand is Sauron, yes, this interpretation of Galadriel would be out of line. Tolkien's clear on that.
But I'm in the camp that sees Halbrand as a future Witch King or King of the Dead more than Sauron. Because having Sauron randomly wander the ocean on a raft until he stumbles on the one needle in the watery haystack who can help him infiltrate Numenor would be such horrible characterization as to make any criticism of Galadriel seems empty in comparison. Plus, Sauron has a LOT he needs to do on the mainland before imprisonment on Numenor.