Civ Leader Depiction Elimination Thread

[God of Kings]

Teddy Roosevelt = 22
Saladin = 20
John Curtin = 14
Montezuma I = 11
Pedro II = 20
Qin Shi Huang = 18
Cleopatra = 15
Victoria = 22
Catherine d'Medici - 14 - 3 = 11
Frederick Barbarossa = 17
Gorgo = 20
Pericles = 21
Mahatma Gandhi = 11
Hojo Tokimune - 22 + 1 = 23
Mvemba a Nzinga (Alfonso I) = 17
Harald Hadrada = 20
Cyrus the Great = 23
Jadwiga = 19
Trajan = 21
Peter the Great = 21
Tomyris = 20
Phillip II = 19
Gilgamesh = 21

Good. No more Alexander the Great. Instead, Catherine d'Medici gets hurt, since she doesn't seem interesting to me, while Hojo Tokimune gets healed, thanks to the Golden Goddesses of Hyrule (note the Triforces on Hojo's shirt).

 

[Zharques]

Teddy Roosevelt = 22
Saladin = 20
John Curtin = 14 + 1 = 15
Much less over the top than some other depictions in this franchise.

Montezuma I = 11
Pedro II = 20
Qin Shi Huang = 18
Cleopatra = 15
Victoria = 22
Catherine de Medici = 11
Frederick Barbarossa = 17
Gorgo = 20
Pericles = 21
Mahatma Gandhi = 11 - 3 = 8
Hello, ET.

Hojo Tokumine = 23
Mvemba a Nzinga = 17
Harald Hadrada = 20
Cyrus the Great = 23
Jadwiga = 19
Trajan = 21
Peter the Great = 21
Tomyris = 20
Phillip II = 19
Gilgamesh = 21

 

[Zaarin]

Teddy Roosevelt = 22
Saladin = 20
John Curtin = 15
Montezuma I = 11
Pedro II = 20
Qin Shi Huang = 18
Cleopatra = 15
Victoria = 22
Catherine de Medici = 11
Frederick Barbarossa = 17
Gorgo = 20
Pericles = 21
Mahatma Gandhi = 5 - It's like Gollum and a troll doll had a hideous baby. He is the stuff of nightmares.
Hojo Tokumine = 23
Mvemba a Nzinga = 17
Harald Hadrada = 20
Cyrus the Great = 23
Jadwiga = 20 - I seriously have the biggest crush on her.
Trajan = 21
Peter the Great = 21
Tomyris = 20
Phillip II = 19
Gilgamesh = 21

 

[Nigel_Tufnel2]

Teddy Roosevelt = 22
Saladin = 20
John Curtin = 15
Montezuma I = 11
Pedro II = 20
Qin Shi Huang = 18
Cleopatra = 15
Victoria = 22 + 1 = 23 She was definitely the most entertaining my first games, expressive yet aloof, fun animations
Catherine de Medici = 11
Frederick Barbarossa = 17
Gorgo = 20
Pericles = 21
Mahatma Gandhi = 5 - 3 = 2 blech
Hojo Tokumine = 23
Mvemba a Nzinga = 17
Harald Hadrada = 20
Cyrus the Great = 23
Jadwiga = 20
Trajan = 21
Peter the Great = 21
Tomyris = 20
Phillip II = 19
Gilgamesh = 21

 

[Returning Lurker]

Teddy Roosevelt = 22
Saladin = 20
John Curtin = 15
Montezuma I = 11
Pedro II = 20
Qin Shi Huang = 18
Cleopatra = 15
Victoria = 23
Catherine de Medici = 11
Frederick Barbarossa = 17
Gorgo = 20
Pericles = 21
Mahatma Gandhi = TERMINATED
Hojo Tokumine = 23
Mvemba a Nzinga = 17
Harald Hadrada = 20
Cyrus the Great = 23
Jadwiga = 20
Trajan = 21
Peter the Great = 21
Tomyris = 20
Phillip II = 19+1=20
Gilgamesh = 21

While I genuinely wasn't going to vote for Gandhi twice in a row the opportunity to kill off that little gremlin is too good to pass up. From here on out I won't vote for the same people in a row until the pool gets too small to avoid it, but all I can say here is... YOU. ARE. TERMINATED.

And I'll also take this opportunity to restore Phillip to the status quo. I love his armor and his disposition, and while he is on the cartoonier side I actually think it works in his favor as his flamboyant personality compliment the stylized animation making it seem more natural and fitting rather than off putting.

 

[Pietato]

Teddy Roosevelt = 22
Saladin = 20
John Curtin = 15
Montezuma I = 11
Pedro II = 20
Qin Shi Huang = 18
Cleopatra = 15
Victoria = 23
Catherine de Medici = 11
Frederick Barbarossa = 17
Gorgo = 20
Pericles = 21
Hojo Tokumine = 23
Mvemba a Nzinga = 17
Harald Hadrada = 20
Cyrus the Great = 23
Jadwiga = 20
Trajan = 21
Peter the Great = 21
Tomyris = 20 + 1 = 21
Phillip II = 20 - 3 = 17
Gilgamesh = 21

 

[Morgawr]

Teddy Roosevelt = 22
Saladin = 20
John Curtin = 12 (15-3) Still find him dull, stiff, low energy
Montezuma I = 11
Pedro II = 20
Qin Shi Huang = 18
Cleopatra = 16 (15+1) She at least has "personality" so coming to her rescue. Although the comment that she acts like a ghetto **** made me LMAO because it's kind of true
Victoria = 23
Catherine de Medici = 11
Frederick Barbarossa = 17
Gorgo = 20
Pericles = 21
Hojo Tokumine = 23
Mvemba a Nzinga = 17
Harald Hadrada = 20
Cyrus the Great = 23
Jadwiga = 20
Trajan = 21
Peter the Great = 21
Tomyris = 21
Phillip II = 17
Gilgamesh = 21

 

[nzcamel]

Teddy Roosevelt = 22
Saladin = 20
John Curtin = 9 (12-3)
Montezuma I = 11
Pedro II = 20
Qin Shi Huang = 18
Cleopatra = 16
Victoria = 23
Catherine de Medici = 12 (11+1)
Frederick Barbarossa = 17
Gorgo = 20
Pericles = 21
Hojo Tokumine = 23
Mvemba a Nzinga = 17
Harald Hadrada = 20
Cyrus the Great = 23
Jadwiga = 20
Trajan = 21
Peter the Great = 21
Tomyris = 21
Phillip II = 17
Gilgamesh = 21

I don't dislike Curtain like I do Gandhi, but I'm already finding it hard to pick on anyone as they are all done pretty well
Same as first post (Cat reminds me of a couple of women I know in real life) and I find Cat adds a very different character to the mix.

 

[Leyrann]

No need to be that close a clock watcher, but the point of spacing out your posts to be roughly a day apart is to avoid too rapid elimination of an alternative just because others who might be inclined to "rescue" that item with up-votes weren't given a fair shot before you multi-post downvoted that item to oblivion (which might be viewed as a form of "thread-jacking" or "trolling," since this is supposed to be a forum game for the enjoyment of all who participate).

So, it would not be kosher to post at 11:50 pm on one day and then again 12 minutes later at 12:02 am on what is technically the "next" day. But, conversely, you are highly unlikely to be called to task for occasionally posting 23 hours apart.

Oops. I just automatically assumed it would be something along the lines of "at least five posts in between" because I'm used to that from another forum. I'll just skip today.

 

[SMcM]

Leyrann- I don't suppose there is any need for you to skip today; the points from the second post you made yesterday have already been removed

Teddy Roosevelt = 22
Saladin = 20
John Curtin = 9
Montezuma I = 11
Pedro II = 20
Qin Shi Huang = 18
Cleopatra = 16
Victoria = 23
Catherine de Medici = 12
Frederick Barbarossa = 17
Gorgo = 20
Pericles = 21
Hojo Tokumine = 23
Mvemba a Nzinga = 17
Harald Hadrada = 20
Cyrus the Great = 23
Jadwiga = 17 (20 - 3)- In my opinion very goofy looking, and her outfit makes her look like a cosplayer
Trajan = 21
Peter the Great = 21
Tomyris = 22 (21 +1)- Really like her armour
Phillip II = 17
Gilgamesh = 21

 

[Leyrann]

Well, in that case...

Teddy Roosevelt = 22
Saladin = 20
John Curtin = 9
Montezuma I = 11
Pedro II = 20
Qin Shi Huang = 18-3=15 Just because he always hates me and its mutual by now.
Cleopatra = 16
Victoria = 23
Catherine de Medici = 12
Frederick Barbarossa = 17
Gorgo = 20
Pericles = 21
Hojo Tokumine = 23
Mvemba a Nzinga = 17
Harald Hadrada = 20
Cyrus the Great = 23
Jadwiga = 17+1=18 I just really like her.
Trajan = 21
Peter the Great = 21
Tomyris = 22
Phillip II = 17
Gilgamesh = 21

 

[upi00r]

Teddy Roosevelt = 22
Saladin = 20
John Curtin = 9
Montezuma I = 11
Pedro II = 20
Qin Shi Huang = 15
Cleopatra = 16
Victoria = 20 (23-3) Cuz she annoys me with her hand fan
Catherine de Medici = 12
Frederick Barbarossa = 17
Gorgo = 20
Pericles = 21
Hojo Tokumine = 23
Mvemba a Nzinga = 17
Harald Hadrada = 20
Cyrus the Great = 23
Jadwiga = 19 (18+1) Cuz SMcM downvotes her
Trajan = 21
Peter the Great = 21
Tomyris = 22
Phillip II = 17
Gilgamesh = 21

 

[Kimiimaro]

Teddy Roosevelt = 22
Saladin = 20+1=21 - I'm surprised that nobody upvoted him yet. His design is one of the best here. He looks like a noble sultan. Deserves an upvote.
John Curtin = 9
Montezuma I = 11-3=8 - He looks unnatural. Civ V version of Monty was much better. This version is not good. Just no.
Pedro II = 20
Qin Shi Huang = 15
Cleopatra = 16
Victoria = 20
Catherine de Medici = 12
Frederick Barbarossa = 17
Gorgo = 20
Pericles = 21
Hojo Tokumine = 23
Mvemba a Nzinga = 17
Harald Hadrada = 20
Cyrus the Great = 23
Jadwiga = 19
Trajan = 21
Peter the Great = 21
Tomyris = 22
Phillip II = 17
Gilgamesh = 21

 

[Alphons Rodulfo]

Teddy Roosevelt = 22
Saladin = 21
John Curtin = 9
Montezuma I = 8
Pedro II = 20
Qin Shi Huang = 15
Cleopatra = 16 + 1 = 17 - I like the things she does with her eyes
Victoria = 20
Catherine de Medici = 12
Frederick Barbarossa = 17
Gorgo = 20
Pericles = 21
Hojo Tokumine = 23
Mvemba a Nzinga = 17
Harald Hadrada = 20
Cyrus the Great = 23
Jadwiga = 19
Trajan = 21
Peter the Great = 21 - 3 = 18 - Everything he says seems bland and uninspired
Tomyris = 22
Phillip II = 17
Gilgamesh = 21

 

[duckofurl]

Teddy Roosevelt = 22
Saladin = 21
John Curtin = 9
Montezuma I = 8
Pedro II = 20 - 3 = 17 I can't stand his eye-rolling, sighing, and general all around passive aggressiveness
Qin Shi Huang = 15
Cleopatra = 17
Victoria = 20
Catherine de Medici = 12
Frederick Barbarossa = 17
Gorgo = 20
Pericles = 21
Hojo Tokumine = 23
Mvemba a Nzinga = 17
Harald Hadrada = 20
Cyrus the Great = 23
Jadwiga = 19 + 1 = 20 OK, sue me. I'm a sucker for cuteness
Trajan = 21
Peter the Great = 18
Tomyris = 22
Phillip II = 17
Gilgamesh = 21

 

[sadsquid]

Teddy Roosevelt = 22
Saladin = 21
John Curtin = 9
Montezuma I = 8
Pedro II = 14 (17-3) Agreed with the previous poster, he's just an annoying dude.
Qin Shi Huang = 15
Cleopatra = 17
Victoria = 20
Catherine de Medici = 12
Frederick Barbarossa = 17
Gorgo = 20
Pericles = 21
Hojo Tokumine = 23
Mvemba a Nzinga = 17
Harald Hadrada = 20
Cyrus the Great = 23
Jadwiga = 20
Trajan = 22 (21+1) Love that they chose Trajan this time instead of the more obvious Julius or Augustus. His voice sounds terrific to me and I usually seem to get along well with him. He just looks cool with his design and background too.
Peter the Great = 18
Tomyris = 22
Phillip II = 17
Gilgamesh = 21

 

[CPWimmer]

Teddy Roosevelt = 22
Saladin = 21
John Curtin = 9+1 = 10
Montezuma I = 8
Pedro II = 14
Qin Shi Huang = 15
Cleopatra = 17
Victoria = 20
Catherine de Medici = 12-3 = 9
Frederick Barbarossa = 17
Gorgo = 20
Pericles = 21
Hojo Tokumine = 23
Mvemba a Nzinga = 17
Harald Hadrada = 20
Cyrus the Great = 23
Jadwiga = 20
Trajan = 22
Peter the Great = 18
Tomyris = 22
Phillip II = 17
Gilgamesh = 21

Curtin is far away from being the 2nd worst. It's not time for him to go yet.

Is that black wine Catherine is drinking?? I hate her color palette and I don't need to see her any longer.

 

[Xandinho]

Teddy Roosevelt = 22
Saladin = 21
John Curtin = 10
Montezuma I = 8 - 3 = 5 He's just weird and I do not like his drawing.
Pedro II = 14
Qin Shi Huang = 15
Cleopatra = 17
Victoria = 20
Catherine de Medici = 9
Frederick Barbarossa = 17
Gorgo = 20
Pericles = 21
Hojo Tokumine = 23
Mvemba a Nzinga = 17
Harald Hadrada = 20
Cyrus the Great = 23
Jadwiga = 20 + 1 = 21 She is very beautiful and I love her smile.
Trajan = 22
Peter the Great = 18
Tomyris = 22
Phillip II = 17
Gilgamesh = 21

 

[The Kingmaker]

Teddy Roosevelt = 22
Saladin = 21
John Curtin = 7 (10-3) Nothing against him, he just doesn't strike me as a very big personality. Not that there is very much choice among the leaders from Down Under.
Montezuma I = 5
Pedro II = 14
Qin Shi Huang = 15
Cleopatra = 17
Victoria = 20
Catherine de Medici = 9
Frederick Barbarossa = 18 (17+1) I've been asking for him for the better part of 20 years. Yeah, his armor is too late for him, but at least he made it in!
Gorgo = 20
Pericles = 21
Hojo Tokumine = 23
Mvemba a Nzinga = 17
Harald Hadrada = 20
Cyrus the Great = 23
Jadwiga = 21
Trajan = 22
Peter the Great = 18
Tomyris = 22
Phillip II = 17
Gilgamesh = 21

 

[DJ_Tanner]

Teddy Roosevelt = 22
Saladin = 21
John Curtin = 7
Montezuma I = 6 (5+1)
Pedro II = 14
Qin Shi Huang = 15
Cleopatra = 17
Victoria = 20
Catherine de Medici = 9
Frederick Barbarossa = 18
Gorgo = 20
Pericles = 21
Hojo Tokumine = 23
Mvemba a Nzinga = 17
Harald Hadrada = 20
Cyrus the Great = 23
Jadwiga = 21
Trajan = 22
Peter the Great = 18
Tomyris = 22
Phillip II = 14 (17-3)
Gilgamesh = 21

I think Monty looks great the jewellery is fantastic. I am not a fan of the brillo pad in a puffy shirt.